Live data from Hacker News

The Most Dangerous Writing App

maebert.github.io

71–80 of 193 posts

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#71
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well then you are already writing in plain text. Why not use git for committing revisions rather than making backup copies on the file system?

It is an interesting idea. But I'm more comfortable with stuff staying local, unless I explicitly put it online.

git is a local program that doesn’t require that you put anything online. It sounds like you might be unfamiliar with it and I suggest that you check it out - it might be just what you’re looking for!

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#72
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well then you are already writing in plain text. Why not use git for committing revisions rather than making backup copies on the file system?

It is an interesting idea. But I'm more comfortable with stuff staying local, unless I explicitly put it online.

'Git' doesn't necessarily imply 'github'. You can make a local repo, and get all the benefits of VC without any necessary exposure.

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#73
post #70

In Neal Stephenson's novel Cryptonomicon, one of the characters is tied to a cabinet containing a bomb and a laptop sitting on top of it. The character is then told that the bomb will explode the moment he stops typing.

The office worker and the mortgage?

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I still have a habit of pressing CTRL-S intermittently...

I think everyone older than 30 does. I also have the habit of pressing it more than one time, every time I press it. I'm not even be sure that save will really save.

Is this an age thing? I do the exact same thing. Every time I stop typing I hit ctrl-s between 2-5 times. I don't eve think about it anymore.

My kids are getting to the age where they are doing projects on a computer and I'm constantly telling them to "save early, save often."

I guess it's some form of PTSD from computing in the 90's.

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#76
post #4

This reminds me of early versions of Microsoft Word. Edit: And more generally, DOS, FAT and CHKDSK. You never knew, when there was a power interruption -- or when the system just crashed for whatever mysterious reason -- just how bad it would be. NTFS was such an improvement.

I still have a habit of pressing CTRL-S intermittently...

In university, we did programming exams on machines with no hard disks, which booted from DOS floppy disks.

The teacher recommended at the beginning of the exam to save often, especially before running our programs, because if they got stuck, we would have to reboot, losing everything.

Of course, there was still a guy that typed for a whole hour without saving. Upon running his program, it obviously crashed and he lost all his work.

I got the habit of saving constantly pressing ctrl-s ever since. I do it even in apps that don't save anything, getting annoying sounds from my computer.

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#77
post #38

I don’t think this is particularly useful as it does not let you to fully form an idea in your head. Granted, it forces you to spew out your mind but in that case I would prefer to have a voice recorder with good speech to text algorithm. Also I would like to have a mode when an amount of text, rather than the length of session would be considered because for things like this HN comment even 3 minutes is too long. No…

>Also I would like to have a mode when an amount of text, rather than the length of session would be considered because for things like this HN comment even 3 minutes is too long.

It has a feature like that, just click on "Words" on the same thing that lets you change amount of minutes. If you want to do less than 150 words you can change the limit in URL to anything you want to too.

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#78
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think everyone older than 30 does. I also have the habit of pressing it more than one time, every time I press it. I'm not even be sure that save will really save.

Is this an age thing? I do the exact same thing. Every time I stop typing I hit ctrl-s between 2-5 times. I don't eve think about it anymore. My kids are getting to the age where they are doing projects on a computer and I'm constantly telling them to "save early, save often." I guess it's some form of PTSD from computing in the 90's.

I worked at the help desk when I was in college back in the 90s and our mantra to users (and ourselves) was “save often and make backups”. We figured the more people we could inculcate that practice into, the fewer “I’ve been writing all afternoon and the computer just crashed, I can get my work back, right?” and “My only copy of my thesis was on this floppy and now I’m getting a disk read error, you can fix it, right?” visits we’d get that would end in tears.

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#79
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is an interesting idea. But I'm more comfortable with stuff staying local, unless I explicitly put it online.

git is a local program that doesn’t require that you put anything online. It sounds like you might be unfamiliar with it and I suggest that you check it out - it might be just what you’re looking for!

OK, right. I jumped to GitHub.

But if it's local, what's the advantage vs saving as a file? Simple revision history management?

Re: The Most Dangerous Writing App

#80
post #4

This reminds me of early versions of Microsoft Word. Edit: And more generally, DOS, FAT and CHKDSK. You never knew, when there was a power interruption -- or when the system just crashed for whatever mysterious reason -- just how bad it would be. NTFS was such an improvement.

I still have a habit of pressing CTRL-S intermittently...

I have seen saving causing a crash! :-(
Post reply on HN