Live data from Hacker News

Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

bbc.co.uk

71–80 of 123 posts

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#71
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also it's mildy amusing that the police stopped it because OBVIOUSLY that's not road legal, but it turns out that actually there was nothing they could cite it for - unlike a good number of cars on the road.

To be fair to the police in this situation: most velomobiles would be more like electric bikes and therefore not be legal on motor highways, wouldn't they? It probably wouldn't be the first time someone eccentric created something cool in their garage and not go through the motions of getting it properly registered.

Yeah - it seems pretty sensible to me that the police stop and check that vehicle.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#72
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Towing should be a strong point of electric vehicles, with all that torque, shouldn't it?

Towing kills the range

Additional batteries in trailers doesn’t seem unreasonable.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#73
post #5

IMHO the future of personal transportation is vehicles like that. We don't have the space in cities to support 2-3 tons of steel per traveler, and plain bicycles are uncomfortable in bad weather, or when you are physically impaired. But small (electric?) velomobiles with three or four wheels are perfect for city commutes when cycling is not an option. They also don't need 15-20kWh/100km like an electric car would.

I've expressed the same sentiment before. The problem is that even talking about electric cars gets people's knickers in a twist; they need to be able to drive for 1000 miles straight while towing an apartment on wheels behind them and any vehicle which can't do that just isn't good enough. They'd rather be dead than have to drive one of these.

Whist driving that hit anything or be hit by anything, would have a good chance of being dead, it looks like a DIY Sinclair C5.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#74
post #5

IMHO the future of personal transportation is vehicles like that. We don't have the space in cities to support 2-3 tons of steel per traveler, and plain bicycles are uncomfortable in bad weather, or when you are physically impaired. But small (electric?) velomobiles with three or four wheels are perfect for city commutes when cycling is not an option. They also don't need 15-20kWh/100km like an electric car would.

So many problems would be solved with a lower population.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've expressed the same sentiment before. The problem is that even talking about electric cars gets people's knickers in a twist; they need to be able to drive for 1000 miles straight while towing an apartment on wheels behind them and any vehicle which can't do that just isn't good enough. They'd rather be dead than have to drive one of these.

> The problem is that even talking about electric cars gets people's knickers in a twist; they need to be able to drive for 1000 miles straight while towing an apartment on wheels behind them and any vehicle which can't do that just isn't good enough. I mean that's understandable, if the car you buy can only handle small commuting that means at the very least the additional cost of using other transport methods or re…

I agree with what you are saying. The tradeoffs are complex between an electric car and something else. In many cases the only reasonable solution is to have both and use the appropriate vehicle for the appropriate trip. The downsides of that are many unless you already need two vehicles.

However, you seem to have illustrated exactly my point. An electric car has some limitations compared to a conventional car. But the gap from an electric car to an electric velomobile is probably even greater.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#77
post #5

IMHO the future of personal transportation is vehicles like that. We don't have the space in cities to support 2-3 tons of steel per traveler, and plain bicycles are uncomfortable in bad weather, or when you are physically impaired. But small (electric?) velomobiles with three or four wheels are perfect for city commutes when cycling is not an option. They also don't need 15-20kWh/100km like an electric car would.

I drive a motorcycle daily and this seems like the drawbacks (low crash protection, lower stability, low load capacity) without the benefits (agility, effortless parking). If this looks viable to you - consider getting a scooter or a small bike, they are great secondary vehicles when you need to get from a to b alone or with one more person and a lot of fun to drive/very versatile for parking. There are some electric…

For super short range commutes there is the new Vespa Electrica - but it costs more than the new 300HPE Vespas.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#78
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> three or four wheels are perfect Presumably, not like the three-wheeled Robin Reliant car that launched in the UK in the 1970s :-) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQh56geU0X8

To be pedantic it's a Reliant Robin (Reliant being the brand). They actually are pretty stable vehicles, contrary to their reputation. For that clip you linked to it's like everything in Top Gear - staged for TV[0]. [0] https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/entertainment/news/...

They are if you (like the Morgan) put the two wheels at the front.

Re: Homemade Electric Motorcycle Stopped on M25 in Hertfordshire

#80
post #74
post #5

IMHO the future of personal transportation is vehicles like that. We don't have the space in cities to support 2-3 tons of steel per traveler, and plain bicycles are uncomfortable in bad weather, or when you are physically impaired. But small (electric?) velomobiles with three or four wheels are perfect for city commutes when cycling is not an option. They also don't need 15-20kWh/100km like an electric car would.

So many problems would be solved with a lower population.

The most pressing problem, climate change, needs to be solved in twenty years. There is no ethical way of reducing population levels in that time frame.
Post reply on HN