Live data from Hacker News

GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

bbc.co.uk

71–80 of 160 posts

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#71
post #50
post #48

Do you know why 99,99% of the extant spiders are harmless to humans? 1) Because many spiders (but not all) are evolved to target insect methabolism instead mammal methabolism 2) Because spiders aren't bees. The majority are solitary and small, have a limited body size and can just inject a single tiny dose of its extra-potent poisons. 3) and their tiny chelicers are too small and weak to pierce the human skin until r…

Of course having 3000 species of spiders to choose they needed to play with the cool funnel-web spider. One of the most deadly spiders for humans. Wise choice. Atracotoxins. Stuff extremely toxic for a particular kind of animal: primates, causing pulmonary and cerebral edema in humans. Fortunately for mosquitoes, atracotoxins are relatively weak as insect killer. Big spiders rely in their fangs to subdue the prey. My…

[deleted]

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#72
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We have to take into account that with climate change the area where the mosquitoes live will probably be wider affecting more people so extending malaria to bigger populations. IMHO, can be wrong , that we have not made a lot against malaria because till now it affected only poor countries but from now on it will probably arrive to richer ones.

The rich countries drained their swamps to end malaria starting in the 19th century. It was one of the first major public works projects.

Yup. Not a lot of people know that in the early 20th century there was a lot of malaria, yellow fever, etc in the southern US.

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#73
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not sure why you're being downvoted. Colonization, was brutal, self-serving, and its economic consequences are still felt to this day (especially when neocolonialism through private corporations and puppet governments is still a thing).

It's probably this incredible nonsense: >> The reason former colonies haven’t been able to do the same at home is because their society and economy are permanently crippled by colonization. Here's an interesting passage from Early China: A Social and Cultural History ( https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00GA22L0E/ ): > Even when we are talking only about the areas that can be considered as part of Early China, back in a time…

> So no, no one has been "permanently crippled by colonization"

Your post is quite long, but none of it actually supports this conclusion, or even mentions colonization at all.

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#74
post #2

I wonder how much ecological damage is done by humans trying to protect their communities from disease borne mosquitos. I grew up with parents that urged me to prevent pools of standing water, but don’t lots of non-mosquito insects need standing water to breed?

Fighting Malaria will presumably enable humans to settle in more areas than before, which will in itself do a lot of ecological damage. Edit: 2 downvotes. At this point, HN might as well switch off voting. It has become ridiculous. Here is something else for you to vote down: 2 + 2 = 4 Take that, suckers!

Mere habitable area is already not the main constraint by far. Farmland isn't even as increased yield has lead to a decrease and market breaking surpluses for almost a century with lesser yield boosts. If habitable land was the constraint we would see ruralization - instead we see urbanization even when policies favor the suburban.

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#75
post #50
post #48

Do you know why 99,99% of the extant spiders are harmless to humans? 1) Because many spiders (but not all) are evolved to target insect methabolism instead mammal methabolism 2) Because spiders aren't bees. The majority are solitary and small, have a limited body size and can just inject a single tiny dose of its extra-potent poisons. 3) and their tiny chelicers are too small and weak to pierce the human skin until r…

Of course having 3000 species of spiders to choose they needed to play with the cool funnel-web spider. One of the most deadly spiders for humans. Wise choice. Atracotoxins. Stuff extremely toxic for a particular kind of animal: primates, causing pulmonary and cerebral edema in humans. Fortunately for mosquitoes, atracotoxins are relatively weak as insect killer. Big spiders rely in their fangs to subdue the prey. My…

you realise this is a carefully-controlled scientific experiment and not the latest Telsa model rollout, right?

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#77
post #48

Do you know why 99,99% of the extant spiders are harmless to humans? 1) Because many spiders (but not all) are evolved to target insect methabolism instead mammal methabolism 2) Because spiders aren't bees. The majority are solitary and small, have a limited body size and can just inject a single tiny dose of its extra-potent poisons. 3) and their tiny chelicers are too small and weak to pierce the human skin until r…

The thing is it isn't "unlimited" but based on growth impact and still targets insectoid metabolisms. It isn't Ice-9 here. Fungals tend to be mostly nuisances to humans except for Anthrax and even then it is finnicky as hell to weaponize when actively trying. Apparently a balance to be dense enough to be deadly while still able to spread enough to infect.

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#79
post #31

These threads about whether it's moral to kill mosquitoes en masse always seem to end up being about unintended consequences and ecosystem collapse. Some points to consider: - Those who study the strains of mosquito (a generous 50 out of ~3500) which spread disease in humans regularly state that they are not a primary food source for any one predator.[1] - Malaria killed 429 000 people in 2015, 90% of those being in…

I'm curious, if we had the power to just snap our fingers and irradiate all mosquitoes, do we have consensus to do so? I worry about unforeseeable consequences.

Re: GM fungus can rapidly kill mosquitoes that spread malaria, study suggests

#80

If this works, GMO seem interesting but fraught with all sorts of unknowns. Why can't a similar effort that cleared malaria from the American South after WW2 be applied again, but on a larger scale (sans horrible insecticides)? https://www.cdc.gov/malaria/about/history/elimination_us.htm...

My understanding was that those horrible insecticides were the primary thing that worked. The link you posted mentions about draining breeding sites, but seems to be saying that DDT application was the biggest component: "It consisted primarily of DDT application to the interior surfaces of rural homes or entire premises in counties where malaria was reported to have been prevalent in recent years."
Post reply on HN