Live data from Hacker News

Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

nytimes.com

71–80 of 138 posts

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#71
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

America has the same business culture; what's saving (most of) us is our better-functioning regulatory culture.

> America has the same business culture; what's saving (most of) us is our better-functioning regulatory culture. The difference in America is it's not good business practice to hurt your own customers. i.e. reputation matters. You mess up just once, and it takes years for your brand to recover (this includes non-brand brands, like store brands or generics). In China it seems like there's a never ending supply of new…

Sometimes the backlash can be catastrophic in China though.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_Chinese_milk_scandal

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This quote reeks of self-righteousness. Western corporations have done as much harm as they could get away with to make a quick buck as well. Jordan Peterson is an individual who seems like he struggled to make sense of the world according to his Christian/Pure-Capitalistic view of the world and decided to concoct wild self-righteous theories to justify his bias rather than change his viewpoint. The only thing he has…

> decided to concoct wild self-righteous theories to justify his bias rather than change his viewpoint To what? Is there a "right" answer that would serve someone better? It's always going to appear self-righteous when you justify your own worldview. The utility of JP's views, is why other people adopt it, not some fictional "messianic cult". JP's reasoning has flaws and gaps as with all people. Even the utility is f…

>Easily digestable and as rational as any other I have seen.

Maybe you need to see more then.

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#73
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really not. Spend some time in China. It won't take long (hours to days) before you notice the utter callousness with which people habitually treat strangers and the environment around them. It can't be believed until it's experienced.

Is there any place with comparable population density with a substantially better social environment? If so, have you any theories that could explain the difference?

Taiwan.

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#74

I mean, let's be honest here: is this really a surprise? There's a business culture of dishonesty throughout the country that is unprecedented. Their food supply is poisoned by factories that simply don't care about life and only care about money. There have been articles about how cooking oil is recycled from waste, and how fish are fed feces instead of food and packed in ice from polluted waters. Fake milk, fake ba…

I have no evidence of this, and I am not proposing it is true...

more like a plot for a novel or something, but

What if a nation that produces almost everything purposely contaminates their products with slow poisons and heavy metals so that the enemy consumer population slowly becomes stupid and ill, and unable to compete effectively on the international stage.

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#75

I mean, let's be honest here: is this really a surprise? There's a business culture of dishonesty throughout the country that is unprecedented. Their food supply is poisoned by factories that simply don't care about life and only care about money. There have been articles about how cooking oil is recycled from waste, and how fish are fed feces instead of food and packed in ice from polluted waters. Fake milk, fake ba…

There's plenty of precedent for this sort of thing in the West's industrial past. Being a fast-growing economy and also keeping a strict eye on product purity, has it ever successfully been done before? Not to say that as an excuse, but it's not at all an uncommon pattern.

I think it's pretty much what we'd expect when markets are allowed to operate unhinged; it doesn't necessarily speak to a point in time in an economy's development—it moreso speaks to the fact that less developed economies are less strictly regulated because they've yet to develop the case law and obituaries on which protective regulations are formed.

With that in mind it's a bit hard to ignore the irony in the regulatory uncoupling that's happening in the US right now. We have learned from our own past and from the aforementioned stories that greed and self interest will always produce externalities that trump a society's well-being; it seems that the lawmakers have too perverse an incentive structure and their constituents have too short a memory to realize which regulations are necessary to protect the greater good.

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All currently rich "sophisticated" countries were in a similar phase when they were fighting their way out of poverty. Once countries get rich enough, they can afford to care about the environment. China seems to advance much faster than others did historically, so I'm hopeful.

We also assumed as countries became more rich/industrialized/advanced they would become more democratic, and more concerned with human rights, and less zero-sum adversarial in dealing with the United States. I think those hopes are no longer mainstream thinking in regards to China. How confident should we be about the prediction that China will adopt similar policies to the US in regards to the things you are mention…

China has definitely become much better on human rights.

It's not often mentioned in polite company, but the Chinese communist government killed ~65 million of its own citizens under Mao.

I don't want to downplay the current regime's many and serious human rights violations, but they are thankfully on a much more modest level.

Internationally, China has focused strongly on peaceful trade, not military confrontation.

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All currently rich "sophisticated" countries were in a similar phase when they were fighting their way out of poverty. Once countries get rich enough, they can afford to care about the environment. China seems to advance much faster than others did historically, so I'm hopeful.

We also assumed as countries became more rich/industrialized/advanced they would become more democratic, and more concerned with human rights, and less zero-sum adversarial in dealing with the United States. I think those hopes are no longer mainstream thinking in regards to China. How confident should we be about the prediction that China will adopt similar policies to the US in regards to the things you are mention…

We should be quite confident because there are signs they're already adopting environmentalist policies. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/chinas-choice/2014/a...

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#78

Should they be under international sanctions for polluting our commons and destrying the planet?

US was shipping most of its garbage to China for years until China stopped accepting it not too long ago. Millions of people in China had suffered from the pollutions of those imported garbages(there’s a documentary about this). Who’s at the moral high ground here?

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#79
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is actually something Hank Paulson comments on in his book "Dealing with China": the Chinese have a huge government, but they actually have something like a half to a third as many government workers per capita. And their comms infrastructure, despite the Huewai bruhaha, is severely lacking in comparison, so those additional people don't stretch as far.

What about their comms infrastructure is lacking? I got full high-speed cellular internet reception even in the deep countryside when I visited there last year.

Don't recall, feel free to read the book.

Re: Study Pinpoints Source of Banned Gas That Saps Ozone Layer: Eastern China

#80

Not only banned flourocarbons, China and Asia are the main source of plastics entering the oceans through their rivers. Some are calling for environmental mercenaries, like Earth First! or GreenPeace, who will reek havoc on those who pollute or endanger the planet, ourselves included.

Oh god, I’d love to see some environmental mercenaries go after China. Look at how they treat their own Muslim citizens! You think they’d hesitate to lock up/beat/kill them?
Post reply on HN