Live data from Hacker News

Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

bbc.com

71–80 of 238 posts

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#71
post #28

Ed Sheeran pays more tax in the UK than Amazon.

Is this true? Edit: holy moly it is! https://metro.co.uk/2018/10/12/ed-sheeran-may-be-the-worlds-...

That article seems to be confusing revenue with profit. The $2 billion Amazon made in the UK is revenue; I suspect its profit is actually smaller.

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#73
post #37
post #5

Good. It is becoming more and more apparent that there is a toll on society created by these companies. They have a negative impact on our domestic businesses (traditional brick and mortar, as well as home-grown digital businesses) not to mention our mental health and even democracy. By taxing them, hopefully we can go some way to reversing some of that damage (although I'm less hopeful of that...).

> They have a negative impact on our domestic businesses (traditional brick and mortar, as well as home-grown digital businesses I have a home grown, UK based digital business. This is going to affect me negatively more than the continued existence of the FAANG companies.

You do more than £500m a year in sales in the UK?!

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#74
post #65

This will only hurt the people who live in the UK. Those companies will just raise their prices to cover the tax. Sure maybe the local companies could then undercut Amazon if they somehow don't have to pay the tax, but eventually they'll just raise their rates to match because why give up the profit margin if they don't have to? It doesn't matter anyway, the tax will never happen. They're just using it as a point of…

It will not “hurt” people in the UK. If that tax passes through and is applied, it’s possible that the price transfer will only apply to UK residents. In that case, the Treasury will have more money to spend on services for UK residents which would hardly be hurtful.

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#75

I give it 20 minutes before one of the big accountancy firms find the (totally unintentional) loop hole to evade this tax.

It's getting much harder since you have to register tax evasion schemes now... But probably yes. In the other hand I can't believe it is expected to raise so little.

Tax avoidance

I imagine if you registered your tax evasion scheme you would receive a knock at the door in short order

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#76
post #65

This will only hurt the people who live in the UK. Those companies will just raise their prices to cover the tax. Sure maybe the local companies could then undercut Amazon if they somehow don't have to pay the tax, but eventually they'll just raise their rates to match because why give up the profit margin if they don't have to? It doesn't matter anyway, the tax will never happen. They're just using it as a point of…

>Those companies will just raise their prices to cover the tax

How exactly will Facebook raise prices in a way that it will hit the average consumer?

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#78
post #65

This will only hurt the people who live in the UK. Those companies will just raise their prices to cover the tax. Sure maybe the local companies could then undercut Amazon if they somehow don't have to pay the tax, but eventually they'll just raise their rates to match because why give up the profit margin if they don't have to? It doesn't matter anyway, the tax will never happen. They're just using it as a point of…

> They're just using it as a point of negotiation for a new US trade deal after Brexit

I suspect it's got more to do with countering Labour

Re: Tech giants face 2% UK digital services tax

#80
post #65

This will only hurt the people who live in the UK. Those companies will just raise their prices to cover the tax. Sure maybe the local companies could then undercut Amazon if they somehow don't have to pay the tax, but eventually they'll just raise their rates to match because why give up the profit margin if they don't have to? It doesn't matter anyway, the tax will never happen. They're just using it as a point of…

The tech giants are free services! Adding 2% to the price of Facebook leaves it still free!

I know it's a dogmatic talking point that you have to make to pretend that tax incidence is pointless, but it doesn't work here.

Post reply on HN