Live data from Hacker News

Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

alcorn.law

71–80 of 120 posts

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#71
post #26

Just move to Europe, you'll be happier for it.

EU programmer salaries are way too low. In the US a senior web dev can make $200-300K. Good luck finding anything even close to that in the EU. Maybe if you're extraordinary, but then you can make a lot more in the US.

Living costs are proportionately lower as well, even within the US (and many have chimed in saying most US devs don't make anywhere near SV salaries).

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#73
post #26

Just move to Europe, you'll be happier for it.

EU programmer salaries are way too low. In the US a senior web dev can make $200-300K. Good luck finding anything even close to that in the EU. Maybe if you're extraordinary, but then you can make a lot more in the US.

Money isn't the only metric for most people. Better healthcare (even if you lose your job), more paid holiday leave and paid maternity leave are all things people take into consideration.

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#74
Republicans are "afraid" of unknowns. People, places things. It seems to be wired in. They are not really racists, just they are "afraid." Probably goes back to ancient days. Who is that stranger? Do they carry a disease, will they take my wife, etc. Why take a chance?

While Democrats seem to welcome the unknown. Take that chance. Lets just take a leap. WTF, life is to experience it all. And then we die.

Seems that we are really not ready to live in urban areas yet, with all these foreign "tribes", amazed we all do.

Conservative friends: OMG that food is so spicy, how can you eat it?

Liberal friends: Give me more spice! Pile it on!

I'm an old WASP, pile on the spice, drop me off where I don't speak the language, can't figure out the food, toilet paper? What's that? Life is so short, I'm ready to just take any chance.

Mars? Sign me up, one way is better.

:-)

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#75
post #68

To be honest, the current system is so dysfunctional that this may even be an improvement. It is shocking to me that only 10% of our immigrants have gotten here though merit. There was an article on nytimes recently about the Canadian immigration system, how successful and popular it's been, and how this is largely the result of a system that heavily priorities immigrants who are highly skilled and can contribute the…

If only 10% of your immigrants are there on merit... maybe your legal definition of "merit" is way too tight? Loosening it while decreasing the amount of non-merit-based green cards available would be the obvious solution.

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#76
post #68

To be honest, the current system is so dysfunctional that this may even be an improvement. It is shocking to me that only 10% of our immigrants have gotten here though merit. There was an article on nytimes recently about the Canadian immigration system, how successful and popular it's been, and how this is largely the result of a system that heavily priorities immigrants who are highly skilled and can contribute the…

"those holding advanced degrees, and those with extraordinary ability in a particular field."

Would be interested to see a break-down of degree and field. I will posit that majority of H-1Bs are Masters holders in IT field from the same country.

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#77
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you don't want the government to take half your salary, of course.

God forbid you live in nice clean cities.

Or have universal health care, working public transportation, (almost) free higher education,...

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#79
post #68

To be honest, the current system is so dysfunctional that this may even be an improvement. It is shocking to me that only 10% of our immigrants have gotten here though merit. There was an article on nytimes recently about the Canadian immigration system, how successful and popular it's been, and how this is largely the result of a system that heavily priorities immigrants who are highly skilled and can contribute the…

I suspect the old system was designed to keep people of color out of the States. The United States was predominately white Christian, so people related to Americans were mostly white Christians.

However today the people most likely to bring their families over are "brown" people who immigrated on merit or as refugees or who got lucky, so now it's time to close that loophole.

Re: Trump Administration to Slash Green Cards by 50%, Affecting H1-B/EB

#80
This article is short on facts. As a high skilled temp immigrant in US (from India), I follow these stories very closely and it is sad to see such scare mongering articles based on pure imagination!

1) Diversity lottery needs to go. IMO it's purpose was to find low skilled immigrants who'd often become taxi drivers or food cart owners. Most of these industries that relied on DV immigrant labor have been disrupted and the new incoming DV immigrants have fewer jobs. If not stopped, the US itself has a brewing problem with unemployed new low skilled immigrants.

2)for people from India and China, abolishing h1b and EB green cards and replacing it with merit based system will be a zillion times better. Current system of giving 20,000 green cards to Indians, 20k to Chinese and 20k every other country, is highly discriminatory and leads to many many sufferings that Americans don't (want to) realise. Hope Trump admin abolishes h1b, L1b, EB green cards and replaces the whole thing with a merit based immigration system.

3) iirc Trump's rhetorics against legal immigration that his voters are concerned about, is primarily the h2b visa, which was expanded under the Obama administration, thus regularising the illegal immigration from Mexico into legal one (correct me if I'm wrong here). Either his voters liked it when there was more illegal immigration so the labor would be cheaper, or just that right now there's a lot of competition they face for their jobs and want to reduce h2 b visas.

US economy is changing a lot in terms of automation, AI, and machine learning, thus reducing the need for a lot of cheap immigrant labor, while increasing the need for high skilled labor to stay competitive with Tech giants from China. Which means, the US immigration policy needs to adapt to it ASAP.

I wish politico and alcorn.law dug into these points instead of writing click baity articles to score points against Trump.

Post reply on HN