Live data from Hacker News

Poll Finds 70% of Bitcoin Users Prefer Segwit for Scaling

coinjournal.net

71–72 of 72 posts

Re: Poll Finds 70% of Bitcoin Users Prefer Segwit for Scaling

#71
post #70
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That suggestion has been put forward a number of times since the limit was put in place. One problem with that is that it is a backwards incompatible change so there need to be some signalling mechanism in place to ensure the rule change takes place at the same block height for every node. The logic would need to have been put in years before it activates. A more longer term problem is the governance problems it enta…

> The logic would need to have been put in years before it activates. But we HAD years to do this. Why didn't we do it?

Well, "we" did. It just took longer than most people thought. Segwit was put in last year, it just hasn't activated yet.

Why did it take so long to develop? I think it's a combination. Many people wanted to get it right, a bad solution could be worse than no solution. There was also concern about miners blocking it, as many had been very skeptical about lowered fees.

Why does it take so long to active? Yeah, this is the tough one. It was deployed the same way as other soft forks. But this turned out to be quite contentious as it played right into an ongoing governance conflict. Worst case, the current deployment has to time out later this year and then it can be safely re-done.

Re: Poll Finds 70% of Bitcoin Users Prefer Segwit for Scaling

#72
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find the various communities to be sharply divided, yes, but only some of them are heavily moderated. On the other side, you just get downvoted into oblivion if you disagree - but at least your comment isn't hidden from those who seek it out. I agree that it takes the fun out of things.

You're very right, and it still sucks. I wish we had a bitcoin community that was less like reddit and more like HN: well-reasoned submissions and replies and moon jokes (we are bitcoiners after all) from everyone are welcome, trolling and flamewars heavily moderated.

If you ever find that community, please let me know :-)
Post reply on HN