Live data from Hacker News

Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

cerebroapp.com

71–80 of 171 posts

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#71
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Choosing Electron kinda by definition means that you as a developer chose the easy way when developing the app and decided to compromise on user experience, performance and disk space to save a bit of time. It's an antithesis of "working hard".

This app took at least many months of work of the developer, who, by the way, is giving it for free. No need to be harsh or disqualify him. IF you dont like it, move on.

[deleted]

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#72
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Completely agree. Electron is free, easy to use and doesn't take much effort. Although it isn't the most memory efficient thing in the world, it is great at making really small applications (like this one) which developers can easily make plugins for. Javascript is probably one of the most common languages, with Node.JS the most common server-side variant of it, allowing so very many people to contribute. Also, we li…

Choosing Electron kinda by definition means that you as a developer chose the easy way when developing the app and decided to compromise on user experience, performance and disk space to save a bit of time. It's an antithesis of "working hard".

I guess we should all start making apps in assembly lang so that we can save some more disk space and performance on use machines.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow, some of the comments in this thread are pretty harsh considering the developer has worked hard on providing what looks to me like a pretty cool free app. Nobody is forcing you to install it.

So, people shouldn't be able to comment their point of view because the developer worked hard?

A considered statement in measured language about the negative consequences of using electron is one thing. This wasn't that: it's unnecessarily hostile — as if the OP was genuinely inconvenienced or put out by something that doesn't impact them in the least.

Disagreeing with someone isn't the same as shitting on their hard work and good-faith effort to create something useful.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#74
post #18
post #13

I wish siri would let me type queries. Having "information at your fingertips" really kills productivity for me. I need long stretches away from twitch reactions to "what's the capital of Uganda?" type of intrusive thoughts. I'd honestly pay for a "2 click" browser extension where you only get to make two clicks on any link per hour for a given domain on a blacklist of time sinks during certain hours.

Here's an extension that can block sites by domain after a pre defined number of minutes on those sites: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/stayfocusd/laankej... Here is more of a nuclear option that lets you micro manage your activity on an os-level. Unfortunately no Linux client afaik. A bit pricy, but very customizable and very effective: https://focusme.com

http://rescuetime.com/ has clients for almost all OS including Linux but excluding iOS. It also has browser extensions.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#75

i see some criticism of electron in the comments because of it's high memory footprint. If i would have to create an offline app i would also choose electron, because of it's simplicity and my familiarity with the technology. Is there something being done or planned to reduce the footprint? Or something on the roadmap? I would guess a browser is just not optimised for a use-case comparable to Cerebro (running as a da…

> I would guess a browser is just not optimised for a use-case comparable to Cerebro (running as a daemon).

That's pretty much it. There's no useful way to make electron slimmer in any way, since it comes with the full chrome browser in the backpack and there's nothing you can do, because chrome's being the base of the huge pyramid with your teeny tiny bits of html and js on top.

It's useful for proto-typing or one-off apps, but for long-running things you're better of making it a chrome app directly (i.e. reusing Chrome's memory foot-print), or making it into a proper native app.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#76
post #13

I wish siri would let me type queries. Having "information at your fingertips" really kills productivity for me. I need long stretches away from twitch reactions to "what's the capital of Uganda?" type of intrusive thoughts. I'd honestly pay for a "2 click" browser extension where you only get to make two clicks on any link per hour for a given domain on a blacklist of time sinks during certain hours.

Forgive me if you aren't looking for advice, but I recommend a distraction notebook:

Keep a small notebook beside you and promise yourself you are going to focus on the topic at hand for a period of time. When a thought, question or search topic pops into your brain, write it in the notebook. When you have some free time you can pick up the notebook at look up all those things. Of course, I often find that coming back to them they aren't all that important at all, and feeling of desperately needing to know has gone.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#77
post #63
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could not QT fill this space better than a whole electron stack ?

QT used to fill this space, but developers flock to electron because it's a much nicer development experience.

Also, Qt Widgets are in maintenance mode. Not a good sign, imo.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#78
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Completely agree. Electron is free, easy to use and doesn't take much effort. Although it isn't the most memory efficient thing in the world, it is great at making really small applications (like this one) which developers can easily make plugins for. Javascript is probably one of the most common languages, with Node.JS the most common server-side variant of it, allowing so very many people to contribute. Also, we li…

Choosing Electron kinda by definition means that you as a developer chose the easy way when developing the app and decided to compromise on user experience, performance and disk space to save a bit of time. It's an antithesis of "working hard".

What a smug reply. Developer community is quite harsh. Shipping is most of the times better than sitting on an armchair and delivering sermons.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#79
post #70
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Choosing Electron kinda by definition means that you as a developer chose the easy way when developing the app and decided to compromise on user experience, performance and disk space to save a bit of time. It's an antithesis of "working hard".

What if the developer was 16 and this was the first thing they had ever made and they were super proud of being able to get something out the door? Read HN and then never made anything again. That happened to me with music when I was young, so discouraging and missed out on an awesome hobby in my 20s and am thankful I had the courage to pick it back up. The tone some folks take in this community often make me want to…

Oh come on. Half this thread is praise for the app. This one post is about how he picked a terrible technology. He'll live. Best case scenario, he'll even learn a valuable lesson, to not use Electron.

Re: Cerebro App – Open-source productivity booster with a brain

#80
post #63
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could not QT fill this space better than a whole electron stack ?

QT used to fill this space, but developers flock to electron because it's a much nicer development experience.

I can't blame people for trying to build things in what they find introduces the least friction to shipping. With traction, this app could be rewritten as native, supposing it's tenable as a first iteration. I use an Electron app on my Mac that's been open for days and is only using 100MB ram at the moment. RAM is cheaper than time for many folks.
Post reply on HN