Live data from Hacker News

HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

finance.yahoo.com

71–80 of 148 posts

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#71
post #20
post #11

I'm an idiot. I've been mulling buying some PALM for a while.

By awhile, I hope you mean less than a month, since they've been in a downward spiral and a month ago were above the $5.70 asking price. 2 months ago they were at $8 and 6 months ago they were at $16 per share. It was a good thing you didn't buy it (unless you purchased December 2008).

I'd been thinking about it a little over a month, yeah.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#72

Man, that is a big pile of cash. It hardly seems worth it, but if HP wanted to be a player in the mobile space now they are. But Palm has a (very long and storied) software problem, not a hardware problem. HP doesn't have much of a reputation in consumer-grade OS software development so I'm not sure how they will be able succeed where Palm failed.

Software problem? Though Palm Pre and Pixi didnt sell as expected, Palm's WebOS has received pretty decent feedback from all over.

They spent an eternity trying to develop a successor to the old Palm OS, then they abruptly threw it all away and created WebOS by sticking WebKit on top of a Linux kernel.

As a result, WebOS has been plagued with performance and reliability problems that they're still trying to address, and that shouldn't surprise anyone familiar with system software development.

They've also had a lot of trouble getting 3rd-party development off the ground.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#73

I have to think that HP could just throw $100m at the problem and build an embedded OS that's far better than Palm, without having to take on the assets of a long-since failed corporation.

That would take them how long? Buying Palm they get that now.

Yep but something really interesting can happen in the process of creating something new. Buying a company that was not able to provide great things for a log time is not exactly exciting IMHO.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That would take them how long? Buying Palm they get that now.

Probably a lot quicker than it will take to save the sinking ship that is Palm. Sure this is a market penetration play, but why? Palm was a failure. PalmOS was a failure. WebOS might be cool, but the damage is done. Google is making good penetration into the mobile market, and they didn't need to buy grandpa to do so.

I know it does not exactly compare, but they too have purchased Android, not developed it from the scratch.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#75

I have to think that HP could just throw $100m at the problem and build an embedded OS that's far better than Palm, without having to take on the assets of a long-since failed corporation.

If they had started 3 years ago maybe. HP is not a software company in any significant way. Look at how many years of development Apple & Google, both very good software companies, needed to build their platforms. WebOS is at least a legitimate competitor today.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#76
post #67

HP's getting a hell of a deal here. They're now a major player in the mobile devices market, overnight. Palm has current relationships with the three biggest American cell carriers, plus channels in Canada, France, Germany, UK, and Mexico. Palm also has an extensive patent portfolio, many of which Apple is infringing upon. However, the real prize is WebOS. I just got back from Palm's Developer Day, and their technolo…

"This deal (...) gives HP all the things they need to go head-to-head with Apple." Except for the one thing that makes apple products special: Design.

Except for the one thing that makes apple products special: Steve Jobs

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#77

I have to think that HP could just throw $100m at the problem and build an embedded OS that's far better than Palm, without having to take on the assets of a long-since failed corporation.

When a big company throws $100,000,000.00 at something it tends to attract a lot of people (either internally or externally) who are more interested in figuring out how to acquire as much of the $100,000,000.00 as possible without worrying too much about delivering a final product in any kind of time frame.

By buying Palm HP knows that it's getting a modern mobile OS that's already in use on shipping products. For a company like HP a known quantity is better than spending money on R&D it may not be able to pull off.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#78

HP's getting a hell of a deal here. They're now a major player in the mobile devices market, overnight. Palm has current relationships with the three biggest American cell carriers, plus channels in Canada, France, Germany, UK, and Mexico. Palm also has an extensive patent portfolio, many of which Apple is infringing upon. However, the real prize is WebOS. I just got back from Palm's Developer Day, and their technolo…

Is there more information about the next OS version publicly available? It sounds pretty awesome.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#79

I have to think that HP could just throw $100m at the problem and build an embedded OS that's far better than Palm, without having to take on the assets of a long-since failed corporation.

As a developer, HP coming out with their own OS makes me want to do about anything else with my time rather than write an app for it. There are already too damn many mobile OSes. But, buying Palm makes WebOS seem that much more relevant, and makes me consider it much more than I was.

Re: HP Buying Palm For $1.2 Billion

#80
post #67

HP's getting a hell of a deal here. They're now a major player in the mobile devices market, overnight. Palm has current relationships with the three biggest American cell carriers, plus channels in Canada, France, Germany, UK, and Mexico. Palm also has an extensive patent portfolio, many of which Apple is infringing upon. However, the real prize is WebOS. I just got back from Palm's Developer Day, and their technolo…

"This deal (...) gives HP all the things they need to go head-to-head with Apple." Except for the one thing that makes apple products special: Design.

I've been using the Palm Pre for the last month after using an iPhone for more than a year. I feel the Pre is as polished from hardware to software as iPhone. They are two different animals, but webOS and the Pre are fine examples of good design.
Post reply on HN