Live data from Hacker News

Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

bbc.com

71–80 of 124 posts

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#71

Aren't Chinese space travelers called Taikonauts? The title make it sounds like Americans are invading China's space station.

I think so... anyways I find stupid the need to differentiate the "space worker(?)" by country of origin. They all do the same awesome thing.

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#72
post #69

China has now done 6 crewed missions to space in the last 3 years. In that time, Russia has had 13 manned missions many of which NASA astronauts have hitched a ride on. NASA is still on the ground since discontinuing the shuttle program in 2011.

If it wasn't for the national dick waving contest that we call space exploration, it wouldn't matter that NASA isn't from the nation running a vehicle project. But out of everything that NASA does what gets attention? The fact that it's not the nation sending rockets up. Why? Because it's not about exploration and expanding knowledge, it's about dick waving. I laugh at all this talk about going to Mars to save the hu…

Well I guess we won't be sending you then.

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#73

Aren't Chinese space travelers called Taikonauts? The title make it sounds like Americans are invading China's space station.

Taikonaut is the word sometimes used for Chinese astronauts in English language journals and Taiwan and Hong Kong. It's mix of Mandarin and Greek (naut = sailor in Greek). Chinese call their astronauts hang tian yuan.Indian astronauts will be vyomanauts.

Astronaut is still valid name for crew member of a spacecraft in any nation.

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#74
post #71

Aren't Chinese space travelers called Taikonauts? The title make it sounds like Americans are invading China's space station.

I think so... anyways I find stupid the need to differentiate the "space worker(?)" by country of origin. They all do the same awesome thing.

"Chinese space workers enter space camp"

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#75
post #57
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The argument is that Astronaut means "sailor of the stars", but "Cosmonaut" means "sailor of the cosmos". As they’re obviously not sailing between stars, but in the cosmos, Cosmonaut is obviously the correct term.

What about Spationaut ? They are sailing through space...

Everybody is a bloody Spationaut.

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#76
post #69

China has now done 6 crewed missions to space in the last 3 years. In that time, Russia has had 13 manned missions many of which NASA astronauts have hitched a ride on. NASA is still on the ground since discontinuing the shuttle program in 2011.

If it wasn't for the national dick waving contest that we call space exploration, it wouldn't matter that NASA isn't from the nation running a vehicle project. But out of everything that NASA does what gets attention? The fact that it's not the nation sending rockets up. Why? Because it's not about exploration and expanding knowledge, it's about dick waving. I laugh at all this talk about going to Mars to save the hu…

I think you are being too harsh. If all the humans had all the information available all the time and not dependent on their community then it would be just a matter of character.

Humans are humans - and at least currently it appears we learn and improve all the time.

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With so much at stake, is it possible for all nations to play together and strive for the better good when it comes to space exploration?

Yes! This is the concept between ISS! The idea that we are regularly sharing launch missions is a great work for international diplomacy.

> Yes! This is the concept between ISS!

Sort of. China is banned by the US government from participating in the ISS (or any other cooperation with NASA). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_exclusion_policy_of_NA...

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#78
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My statements above were neutral but yes I do think that the US and the western world in general are falling behind. What happens if US and Russian relations break down? Privatization of the US space industry is interesting but has yet to prove itself. No private institution has achieved manned orbit.

Having people in space is kind of pointless right now. Yes, it's a low G environment, but ISS is in such a low orbit that people in my state can be further from me than an overhead ISS 'Astronauts'. It's even protected by earths magnetic field making it a poor test of long term space flight.

I won't take a strong position on the larger point of whether humans in space are worth it, but there are other uses for a space station than "being far away", "being low g", and "seeing how many astronauts get cancer".

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#79
post #7

Are the docks compatible with Soyuz?

Chinese reportedly use APAS-89/APAS-95 system docking adapters (jointly developed by Americans and Russians) so they be able to dock with currently used Soyuz spacecraft in principle. They should also be legacy compatible with new International Docking System Standard (IDSS).

Emphasis on principle. Until they confirm that their intent is to be compatible and some testing is done to verify it, I don't think anyone wants to dock.

Re: Astronauts enter China's space station [video]

#80
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My statements above were neutral but yes I do think that the US and the western world in general are falling behind. What happens if US and Russian relations break down? Privatization of the US space industry is interesting but has yet to prove itself. No private institution has achieved manned orbit.

Having people in space is kind of pointless right now. Yes, it's a low G environment, but ISS is in such a low orbit that people in my state can be further from me than an overhead ISS 'Astronauts'. It's even protected by earths magnetic field making it a poor test of long term space flight.

Absolutely wrong. Having a manned station is a boon for the research taking place. Without a station anyone wanting to do research like the packed bed or the docking and refueling experiments would require the investigating institution to design and launch a vastly more complicated automated satellite or to rely on short manned missions that would have more competition for space and time. Instead it's much easier to package an experiment and send it to the station which has a lot of equipment to support experiments and humans that can troubleshoot and modify experiments.

As for studying long term space flight the only thing it really doesn't provide a model for is radiation which we can model on the ground pretty well. You still get the other health impacts from microgravity that we're still trying to figure out how to effectively combat.

Post reply on HN