Live data from Hacker News

My verdict after one day of using the iPad

scripting.com

71–75 of 75 posts

Re: My verdict after one day of using the iPad

#71

My favorite paragraph: http://www.scripting.com/stories/2010/04/03/verdictAfterOneD...

The thing that nobody seems to acknowledge is that iTunes really has gotten a lot better over the last year.

At this point it should be called iHydra, given how many separate roles have been shoehorned into it.

Re: My verdict after one day of using the iPad

#72
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You make a good point, which proves that neither of us actually knows which phrasing Dave Winer meant. Don't be a jerk. We live in the same city and might actually meet at some point. I don't like being on bad terms with people I've never met.

I'm sorry if I came off as attacking you: there wasn't any intent to do that. I just was trying to point out where I think you misread Winer's article, which is in the grand scheme of things a pretty minor mistake, probably not even worth the downvotes. I certainly wasn't trying to make it personal. I think one issue may have been that what I wrote in my post was just the first two sentences; the whole second paragra…

Thanks Mark, I appreciate the message on Facebook. I haven't had an opportunity to get back to you yet (my day has been hectic), but I'll send you a response later when I have a chance to do it justice.

Re: My verdict after one day of using the iPad

#73
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The thing that nobody seems to acknowledge is that iTunes really has gotten a lot better over the last year.

How so?

The Quicktime-based GUI has become a lot more responsive, even as they've added more features. That was my main complaint -- the idea that a 2D UI should bring a 3 GHz processor to its knees.

Re: My verdict after one day of using the iPad

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Everyone realizes it. I think the contention is (right or wrong) that a pure-consumption device isn't what people want or need (given the other things that they have in their lives). It's redundant. It doesn't replace anything. I think if they had multi-tasking it'd go a long way to shutting up this criticism.

Hey Tony - Pity that seemingly everyone in Seattle is staying in tonight. Crappy weather... Two things: 1. You've probably forgotten more about this sort of data than I'll ever know, but I look around at folks on laptops in cafes and see nothing but Facebook or Gmail on Netbooks. I think we, as a class of users, are the exception: most people on computers spend the bulk of their time consuming information instead of…

Heh-- yaw, I'm not certainly I AGREE with the contention. No one ever went broke overestimating the vapidity of consumers. Still, I wonder. IM Facebook, and email are content creation. Will the swoosh-factor of the iPad make up for inconvenience of an onscreen keyboard, no multi-tasking, etc?
Post reply on HN