Live data from Hacker News

M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

wired.com

71–80 of 175 posts

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#71
post #32

This seems like a move into the Chinese-style mega-app where you can do everything from one app - buy shoes, talk to your friends, figure out when the train departs. Facebook already has two top-50 apps, and creating new, unproven apps and promoting them to that point is expensive. So, to increase influence they are putting more into the existing apps.

The privacy implications would keep me from recommending this to others or even trying it out myself.

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#72
post #24
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The first thing I thought after seeing that example is FB is the new Yelp. Restaurants will have to pay FB for visibility and recognition... Same thing as Yelp, just a lot scarier.

Have mixed feelings about this like I'm sure many do. Greater convenience, but less and less privacy.. Our Fb/goog/nsa overlords know what we eat, where we shit, all of our conversations and relationships. What a scary world we live in.

Grocery stores have been tracking your food purchases since the 1990s at least. That's why they have those shopping cards.

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#73
“The AI tries to do everything,” says Alex Lebrun, the founder of Wit.ai, a startup Facebook acquired to help build this smartphone tool. “But the AI is supervised by the people.”

Congrats to ar7hur! Here's the original Show HN introducing Wit.ai: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6373645

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#76
post #32

This seems like a move into the Chinese-style mega-app where you can do everything from one app - buy shoes, talk to your friends, figure out when the train departs. Facebook already has two top-50 apps, and creating new, unproven apps and promoting them to that point is expensive. So, to increase influence they are putting more into the existing apps.

> promoting them to that point is expensive

(1) Not for facebook and (2) I don't think that they would inevitably promote every new app to the top — I think they'd rather see how it grows organically first to determine how good it turned out to be.

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#77
Thought: There's going to be a need for a very open platform that can do things like this, which will offset many of the worries that have been echoed on this thread today about one or a few corporations having access to everything.

To use an analogy - if messaging apps are the new "browsers", then content accessed through them are the new "websites". What FB is doing is the equivalent of AOL in the 90s.

What then, is the equivalent of a search engine like Google/Yahoo, in that world?

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#78
post #77

Thought: There's going to be a need for a very open platform that can do things like this, which will offset many of the worries that have been echoed on this thread today about one or a few corporations having access to everything. To use an analogy - if messaging apps are the new "browsers", then content accessed through them are the new "websites". What FB is doing is the equivalent of AOL in the 90s. What then, i…

For a period, a few people thought that twitter had enough sway to be that new "messaging search" engine. I've used it in such a way when I wanted to find hyper localized information.

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#79
post #50

Ah, Mechanical Turk strikes again..

I worked in AWS for a bit and my favorite joke was to flippantly suggest mturk as a solution to some convoluted architecture/process.

That's not a joke, that's a legitimate solution.

Re: M, a personal digital assistant inside Facebook Messenger

#80
The part I find most interesting here is I'm working on something mildly similar in my spare time. Though it'll certainly be more limited than something a big company like Facebook can come up with but I'm tired to sending all my data every time I want to do something so I'm trying to squeeze this into a phone without the need for the internet to, at least, process commands. Oh and extending it will only require a little bit of JavaScript.

But I'm far away from launching it and it's only a side project. But it's cool to see so many in the space doing something I also want / wanted to do.

Post reply on HN