Live data from Hacker News

Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

well.blogs.nytimes.com

71–80 of 122 posts

Re: Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

#71

Correlation vs causation. Is it possible that people who eat the peppers also eat lots of vegetables as opposed to starchy carbs? Definitely. Is it possible people who, say, exercise more are for some reason more inclined to eat spicy foods. They can control for any number of things, but this isn't science, it's a correlation and anyone who has taken an intro to statistics class shouldn't be fooled by a pseudoscience…

[deleted]

Re: Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

#72

Since some comments are trying to explain away the findings, here is a quote from the article about what variables were controlled for and the results: > After controlling for family medical history, age, education, diabetes, smoking and many other variables, the researchers found that compared with eating hot food, mainly chili peppers, less than once a week, having it once or twice a week resulted in a 10 percent r…

I wonder if it has anything to do with the fact that you eat less food when it's particularly spicy? Fasting/caloric intake reduction and better health/longer life have been correlated for a while.

No, people that routinely eat extremely spicy food eat as much of it as anything else. It might put off the occasional eater of spicy food, but regular consumption depletes the neurotransmitters that generate the effect. It is an acquired immunity that can quickly escalate the level of spiciness required to perceive it. (You lose that immunity relatively quickly though.) Being able to eat almost arbitrarily spicy food is a trivially acquired ability.

Source: I eat quite a lot of habaneros and thai chilis, mostly because those are the peppers that taste strongly "spicy" to me on a day to day basis. If I eat too much on an ongoing basis, even the habaneros start to lose their spiciness. Most people have a "spiciness" threshold so low that the pepper is barely detectable to me. I was not born this way, peppers have been a regular part of my diet because I like the flavor and that confers a natural immunity to the effects.

Re: Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

#75

Since some comments are trying to explain away the findings, here is a quote from the article about what variables were controlled for and the results: > After controlling for family medical history, age, education, diabetes, smoking and many other variables, the researchers found that compared with eating hot food, mainly chili peppers, less than once a week, having it once or twice a week resulted in a 10 percent r…

I wonder if it has anything to do with the fact that you eat less food when it's particularly spicy? Fasting/caloric intake reduction and better health/longer life have been correlated for a while.

That's not the American!™ way. Just drink lots of milk to dampen the pain and keep chugging.

Re: Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

#77
post #61

Well, if that is true, then why is German statistically the country with the highest average age in the world (on par with Japan), even though their food is quite bland?

Because access to healthcare and the quality thereof dominates; and German randomly fall at the upper-ends of the acceptable statistical bounds when comparing Western countries? :)

Re: Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

#78

Since some comments are trying to explain away the findings, here is a quote from the article about what variables were controlled for and the results: > After controlling for family medical history, age, education, diabetes, smoking and many other variables, the researchers found that compared with eating hot food, mainly chili peppers, less than once a week, having it once or twice a week resulted in a 10 percent r…

On the other hand, keep in mind it's an observational study, not an experiment. As such, it's highly succeptible so various biases, including P-hacking (choosing a hypothesis based on data). Most importantly, keep in mind the astonishing number of false & dubious nutritional recommendations made in the past (salt is bad, salt is ok, fat is bad, fat is good, sugar is good, sugar is bad, cholesterol is bad, cholesterol is fine, ...).

Re: Eating Spicy Food Linked to a Longer Life

#79

Correlation vs causation. Is it possible that people who eat the peppers also eat lots of vegetables as opposed to starchy carbs? Definitely. Is it possible people who, say, exercise more are for some reason more inclined to eat spicy foods. They can control for any number of things, but this isn't science, it's a correlation and anyone who has taken an intro to statistics class shouldn't be fooled by a pseudoscience…

No, you are not correct, and you're engaging in a classic middlebrow dismissal.

This is a scientific research paper published in the BMJ, and a well-documented, controlled cohort study. It's pretty much the opposite of pseudoscience. The blog post is perfectly restrained and does not claim that eating spicy food will increase lifespan, instead reporting (accurately) that the two factors appear to be linked.

Did you even bother reading either?

Post reply on HN