Live data from Hacker News

Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

bbc.com

691–700 of 784 posts

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#691
post #458

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“Come out and we will tell you what you’re guilty of”. The US was once a great defender of liberty and democrac, but when you talk to its average citizen nowaday you start to get truely weimarian vibes.

His actions are entirely undemocratic. Sweden and the US have both democratically built a system of justice that we all agree to subject ourselves to. He decided to evade that system to serve his own self-interest. What about defending the liberty of the alleged rape victim? Do they only have the right to their day in court if the accused is ok with it?

From the moment he was removed from the embassy and locked in jail the Swedish prosecutor lost all interest to continue the case, and by a coincident the US extradition order came in.

That is how much anyone cared about defending the liberty of the alleged rape victim.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#692
post #470

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> that's stealing a document in anyone's book. It would certainly be stealing if she deleted the documents in the server afterwards, which she did not. Stealing implies that the original is gone in everyday speech. Most people would be very upset if you stole their car, not so much if you copied it. > I'm simply saying that a military court said that. You might want to edit your previous post then. From "technically…

So copying Coke's secret formula is not stealing?

I do not think so, no. Especially not if it was released to the world for free.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#693

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Another take, with no more or less evidence as far as I can tell: He essentially had no choice, as it was obvious he was going to be railroaded at any trial, and would likely be bounced to the US at some point.

This was far from "obvious". Extradition from Sweden would have been harder than from the UK.

Not if the request was dropped before he got to Sweden. The prosecutor demonstrated that point very clearly today.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#694

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The US ”justice” system has replaced justice with vengeance and punishment with suffering..

Those who cause the innocent to suffer deserve vengeance and suffering. Why are we so concerned about the comfort of people who, the majority of the time, are in prison for violent crime? Before someone brings up "muh drugs" and only cites stats from federal prisons... "In 2011, 55.6% of the 1,131,210 sentenced prisoners in state prisons were being held for violent crimes (this number excludes the 200,966 prisoners b…

Because vengeance as a central tenet in justice systems is straight from the Hammurabi code and unfit for the modern world. If your source is the Bible, I'll agree to disagree.

If you want a legal system that treats citizens fairly, you want one focused on rehabilitation. Locking someone up simply doesn't accomplish that goal. Dehumanising prisoners doesn't either.

What's more, crime is a proxy for socio-economic status, which given the greater inequality in the US, partly explains the disparity with other developed nations.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#695

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The US justice system is possibly the most cruel justice system in the West, and by quite a margin, too. It is one of a few aspects in which the US is far closer to today's developing and third world countries than to the Western average. Also over many decades many organizations have called out the conditions in parts of the US justice system as torture(-like).

> The US justice system is possibly the most cruel justice system in the West, and by quite a margin, too. Many of the world's most dangerous countries and most brutal justice systems are in Latin America. The US looks bad from a northern European perspective, but it's far from the worst in the West.

Off-hand I wouldn't consider Latin America in general a part of the West, not in the same way the US or Europe are. Not-so-off-hand it seems like whether Latin America is part of the Western world or something else, that "just happens" to be strongly influenced by it, is pretty open for debate.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#696

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is in the business of assassinating visible targets. By probability and behavioral record. Unless you have special evidence to contrary.

As I said, Manning is still alive, and she's spent an inordinate amount of time under US custody. She's under US custody right now. If the government had "assassination of visible targets" as standard black-ops policy, why is she not dead? Conspiracy theories suffer on lack of consistency.

It is plausible that if US govt was't able to contrive her current imprisonment via contempt of court charges, she would be dead.

Kind of amusing that a user named "shadowgovt" is vehemently arguing that the government is less malicious than many members of the public suspect.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#697
post #488

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not a 1% chance. Even if one accepts your definition of torture, people who aren't criminals are very rarely caught up in the system at all. So it's far less than 1% as long as you're simply not a criminal. If the US were really so bad, people would leave. The people who do leave typically leave for tax purposes opposite to your belief.

I've had US police pull guns on me several times, thrown to the ground have been arrested and jailed overnight, despite not having committed a crime on any of the occasions. My transgression in each case was to have not learnt the submission rituals that American police expect, the whole stay in your car with you hands on the wheel, the yes sir, yes mam. One of these times was on a late night Santa Cruz to SF drive,…

>My transgression in each case was to have not learnt the submission rituals that American police expect

Either you are a slow learner, or you make a point to be a smartass with cops. Do you think it's specific to American cops? Maybe try that with Algerian or Brazilian cops and see how things turn out for you.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#699
post #528

> Ms Persson said: "I would like to emphasise that the injured party has submitted a credible and reliable version of events. > "Her statements have been coherent, extensive and detailed; however, my overall assessment is that the evidential situation has been weakened to such an extent that that there is no longer any reason to continue the investigation." Did Ms Persson also clarify that a lack of evidence suggests…

No, lack of evidence is not evidence of a lack of crime.

Evidence is material. A lack of evidence by definition is not material.

Re: Sweden Drops Julian Assange Rape Investigation

#700

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whistleblowers do not deserve to be in prison. Exposing war crimes is good.

She wasn't technically a whistleblower, technically she stole classified documents and betrayed her country that she swore to protect. The military have a different way of dealing with justice, especially in U.S. She was in fact sentenced by court-martial not by a regular court.

Snowden demonstrated that the "technical whistleblower" channels are ineffective at ending illegal behavior by the govt.

The assertion that whistleblowers must use official channels is just a paper-thinly veiled argument for silencing all whistleblowing.

Post reply on HN