Live data from Hacker News

Panic at the Job Market

matt.sh

661–670 of 1001 posts

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#661
post #476

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> As in, a person who has used and learned a dozen plus languages but only tacitly used C++ suddenly will be a complete invalid when trying to write in C++? I've switched at least 5 languages professionally and used probably 5 more for extended periods of time and wrote a decent chunk of C++ "back in the day". I'd say C++ is the least suitable for "learn on the job" approach out of any language I can think of (I'm lu…

> I'd say C++ is the least suitable for "learn on the job" approach out of any language I can think of Anecdote: I've got a couple languages and decades under my belt, and a very simple C/C++ Arduino project is making me doubt my sanity. Ex: Serial.printf("%s", String("Hello world...")); // Emits 4 nonsense bytes... But shorter literals work fine. ________________________ EDIT: To save readers some time--I didn't int…

eh forget all this coding minutiae, i dabbled with arduino here and there.

in my experience it's not to do with code. your serial/usb runs the bytes back through your debugger (typically IDE On the PC). Your IDE has config settings like baud rate +/- encoding that you have to config. If that IDE config is messed up (IDE Is presumably printing out your printf bytes over usb or whatever), then your output is bytes. Make sure your baud is correct.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#662

I'm hiring two senior SWE roles right now, after many many months alternatively cajoling and threatening various VPs in my org. They kinda admitted at the start of the year we were due some headcount after some other engineers left last year... But I digress. Today alone I spent three hours going through resumes generated mostly by ChatGPT to find anyone with even sufficient experience to make it to interview. I spen…

[dead]

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#663
post #657
post #653

Pure speculation: what is the possibility the current administration told silicon valley to dial down hiring and salaries to help with inflation? the result being our job market has been destroyed. it would be worth investigating this.

absolutely 0 chance of this. Consider how much of the Government’s moves are leaked. Something like this would almost certainly fall in the hands of someone in the Press.

not too sure about that. remember when zuckerburg etc met with obama? how much do we know about what was said?

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#664

Agree with a lot of this and have seen a lot of similar stuff as a former developer gone cloud infra guy for most of my career now. The core problem, as he gets to in a lot of this, is that if you work on infra, you are seen as a pure cost, and not adding anything to "revenue" or "product" (which is of course false). One of the most common patterns in hiring I see now is so exasperating it drives me to despair someti…

I had that experience this week, but with $X as a job title instead of a technology. Hiring manager: "I see your resume doesn't list 'Frontend Developer'." Me: "I haven't had that exact title, but I have years of experience building front-end applications using the tools you listed." Hiring manager: "Hm, it seems like you might not have enough experience as a 'Frontend Developer' for what we need."

they did you a favor. if the manager is that clueless, you probably don’t want to work for them.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#665
post #221

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Years ago I was talking about exactly this issue and how the U.S. is producing far too many degrees than the market can receive. As usual the truth is ignored in favor of a comfortable lie, at the cost of others lives. Don't go to university. Their value is no longer what it used to be, and they have figured out how to suppress students under a thousand pounds of administrative grift. We need to strip all public fund…

As much bad rep as schools get nowadays, if you get into a good university (think of top 50 in the world), it will open up a lot of doors for you. Very anecdotal, but I have open offers from people whom I know from uni years. Connections matter, especially in bad market days. Everything else (bootcamps, diploma mills and etc.) are just noise though, I would say it’s not worth the money. It’s also easy for me to say,…

It's also a great indicator of a wealthy upbringing, if you're optimizing for that sort of thing.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#666
post #249

I will add my two cents for people who believe that this might be related only to the SWE and tangent industries: It's really not. I have many friends (in Europe) who are trying to get through to different jobs in unrelated industries ranging from finance to fashion, or just trying to get promoted vertically (or horizontally), failing rather miserably. Most jobs are now hoops after hoops, not taking into consideratio…

> Most jobs are now hoops after hoops, not taking into consideration your particular profile or the contributions you can make. This is really key. I have applied for jobs before, and then get questions like: "what's your experience with C++ or advanced graph algorithms?". Only that, none of that shows up in my profile or resume. But they act surprised and completely shrug off how a decade of software and other relev…

In my experience, C++ programmers have the smallest range of programming language knowledge. Basically, their whole world is C++. They have a hammer, and everything looks like a nail. "But performance!" they declare ... when you are writing a single function to reverse a string: "Can I use Python?" In my career and domain, I have never once seen a graph algorithm used, yet 5% of posts of HN are all about them. I guess I am an idiot.

Another thing about C++ interviews: Frequently, their difficultly far exceeds anything they are using in their own code base. That can be hugely embarrassing after you slog through a brutal few rounds of C++ interviews and land that offer. A few weeks later, you are rolling up your sleeves, waiting for the first Git clone to complete. Then you feast your eyes on a puddle of dog doo that they call uber-C++-2027 or whatever they claim. "Oh." Such defeat.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#667
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

except that referral hiring isn't a thing almost anywhere I know because I've referred people I KNOW are great SE's and I'm literally willing to vouch my own employment for, and they still get treated no different to any other candidate

I remember the first time I worked at a company that did referral hiring that skipped the interview process. The first few hires were amazing. Everyone thought we had struck gold: Just find people your employees can vouch for, and hire them! Why didn't anyone else think of this? Then we got a referral hire who turned out to be rather bad at everything, from coding to getting along with people. And another who was rea…

Referral bonuses led to this being gamed too. Tech companies giving ~$5k out for a hired referral - people would bring in literal strangers and claimed they worked with them. There is/was even a market for referrals on blind and suchlike.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#668
I'll just note that there's a lot of non-tech industry-specific science around behavioral and structured interviews, including large meta-studies, and they pretty universally show that structured interviews, including a mix of behavioral and functional competency questions, have some of the best correlation with positive on the job performance.

https://psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2F0021-9010.8...

https://psycnet.apa.org/record/1998-10661-006

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/peps.12052

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/38092551_What_You_S...

I've got no doubt there are companies doing these things poorly, but the fundamental idea that this class of interview is bad just doesn't align with the research.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#669
post #151
post #86

Hiring people (mostly engineers) has been my full-time job now for about 15 years and I found myself emphatically agreeing with a lot of Matt's criticisms of modern hiring. Most tech interviews are as relevant to job performance as if hiring a baker required interviewing them about how electron orbitals bind worked gluten together then rejecting bakers who don’t immediately draw a valid orbital configuration. Matt's…

except that referral hiring isn't a thing almost anywhere I know because I've referred people I KNOW are great SE's and I'm literally willing to vouch my own employment for, and they still get treated no different to any other candidate

I've experienced the same thing in recent years. Referrals are just another way to put a resume into the ATS. I have no opportunity to actually expend any social or political capital to bring that person in. I get excluded from the hiring loop to avoid bias. I basically become a human "Apply" button.

I don't even get a referral bonus anymore.

Re: Panic at the Job Market

#670
post #249

I will add my two cents for people who believe that this might be related only to the SWE and tangent industries: It's really not. I have many friends (in Europe) who are trying to get through to different jobs in unrelated industries ranging from finance to fashion, or just trying to get promoted vertically (or horizontally), failing rather miserably. Most jobs are now hoops after hoops, not taking into consideratio…

> Most jobs are now hoops after hoops, not taking into consideration your particular profile or the contributions you can make. This is really key. I have applied for jobs before, and then get questions like: "what's your experience with C++ or advanced graph algorithms?". Only that, none of that shows up in my profile or resume. But they act surprised and completely shrug off how a decade of software and other relev…

"Low level python" is an amusing statement
Post reply on HN