Live data from Hacker News

Twitter Blue for $8/Month

twitter.com

661–670 of 1001 posts

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#661
post #454

Elon is the PM from hell. Has some shower thought and starts throwing tickets on everyone's board 45 minutes later. This is why the Model X has those silly doors.

How do you reconcile that view with Elon's successful ventures, e.g. the other Tesla's, Starlink, and SpaceX?

I'm not OP but I think that they said that Elon sounds like a bad PM to work under, not that he's unsuccessful at developing and marketing products

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#662

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Anywhere Stephen King writes, he'll have an audience. That's what's so funny about this particular example. There are indeed Twitter celebrities who depend on Twitter for their audience, but King isn't one of them: he's pumping more credibility into Twitter than he's extracting from it, and the platform (and all the Twitter celebrity remora attached to it) depend on people like him to keep doing it. He's right: Twitt…

Instead it should be $1/month to be allowed to post replies to blue-check tweets! (But leave quote-tweeting alone).

The Elon Musk dunk tank?

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#663
post #322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's the core problem with this approach. Elon and others have the idea in their head that Twitter is a social graph where people come to interact with each other, and everyone is relatively equal. So every user paying $X/mo to solidify their place in the graph makes some conceptual sense. In reality Twitter is more akin to YouTube than Facebook. A tiny percentage of users are creators while the vast majority are c…

Stephen King’s tweet on that topic, to summarize: “ $20 a month to keep my blue check? Fuck that, they should pay me. If that gets instituted, I’m gone like Enron.” https://twitter.com/stephenking/status/1587042605627490304?s...

Twitter may lose one Stephen King, but presumably now anybody with the same name can get the blue check. All those $8 per month will add up.

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#664
post #582

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What does a blue check get you anyway that you can't just have with a blue check emoji?

From the linked thread: 1) Priority in replies, mentions & search, which is essential to defeat spam/scam 2) Ability to post long video & audio 3) Half as many ads I also expect the following: 4) Increase in perceived legitimacy #1 and #4 are valuable to me. #2 I don't care about at all, because my long-form content goes on my blog and YouTube. #3 is 'meh'--it'll be nice to have fewer ads, but my brain glazes right p…

And fancy custom iOS icons for sure.

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#665

I'm likely to pay for it at that price. For reference, I have a bit more than 14K followers on Twitter. Why? Two reasons. 1) Funding social media through advertising has led to dysfunctional outcomes like outrage being more visible than high-quality content. I’m in favor of alternative revenue streams, although they have to provide value, and removing ads doesn't count as providing value. 2) My Twitter account is par…

> Funding social media through advertising has led to dysfunctional outcomes

> Eight dollars a month isn't much to pay if it improves my visibility

What you're describing in that second quote is advertising. You are paying for additional reach, in this case you'd get those additional impressions via "priority" in replies, mentions & search. What they've done is dressed up advertising as a membership feature because it'll make people like you more likely to advertise.

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#666

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We're not really discussing reality if you believe that Stephen King gets status from the blue check rather than it working the other way around. There are people that do (sadly, pathetically) extract status from blue checkmarks, but they're only able to do that because people like Stephen King play ball with this system. The "blue checkmark status" could literally be phrased as "people as high-status as Stephen King…

Quoted post unavailable.

He's quite active. https://stephenking.com/works/all/ then sort newest to oldest.

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#668
post #454

Elon is the PM from hell. Has some shower thought and starts throwing tickets on everyone's board 45 minutes later. This is why the Model X has those silly doors.

I'll take those silly doors any day over some designed-by-committe boring car. Like stupid bean-shaped electric Mercedes for example.

Wait till it freezes in winter. Those doors are great, till they’re covered in a small layer of ice.

The doors are an interesting example since they always seemed strictly worse than the traditional design, unlike the rest of the car.

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#669
post #322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's the core problem with this approach. Elon and others have the idea in their head that Twitter is a social graph where people come to interact with each other, and everyone is relatively equal. So every user paying $X/mo to solidify their place in the graph makes some conceptual sense. In reality Twitter is more akin to YouTube than Facebook. A tiny percentage of users are creators while the vast majority are c…

I always felt Twitter as "old man yells at cloud" kind of communication. I've never seen proper "content" created (like pinterest, tik tok, etc). Most of the "content" I see are the asinine multi-post threads and text-pictures notices from angry people/companies.

Agreed. If I like a writer I always find better ways than Twitter to follow them - Substack, etc

And even if they tweet something worthwhile it’s usually followed by 98% garbage replies with “LOL you’re so stupid” so I’m not wasting my time sifting through that trash heap.

It is useful for events with people on the ground to share info - the story of the guy in Pakistan tweeting about helicopters when Bin Laden was killed was pretty amazing to be honest.

But those types of writers tend to die out after the event.

Re: Twitter Blue for $8/Month

#670
post #54

Verification is more of a benefit to Twitter than to verified users. At least for mega celebs. I am verified because years ago I knew someone who worked at Twitter. I wouldn't pay a penny for it though.

Tweet it at Musk, maybe he'll reduce the price to $0.01
Post reply on HN