Live data from Hacker News

The Codex App

openai.com

631–640 of 671 posts

Re: The Codex App

#631

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you're using 5.2 high, with all due respect, this has to be a skill issue. If you're using 5.2 Codex high — use 5.2 high. gpt-5.2 is slow, yes (ok, keeping it real, it's excruciatingly slow). But it's not the moronic caricature you're saying it is. If you need it to be up to date with your version of a framework, then ask it to use the context7 mcp server. Expecting training data to be up to date is unreasonable f…

Perhaps if he was able to get Claude Code to do what he wanted in less time, and with a better experience, then maybe that's not a skill he (or the rest of us) want to develop.

still a skill issue, not a codex issue. sure, this line of critique is also one levied by tech bros who want to transfer your company's balance sheet from salaries to ai-SaaS(-ery), but in what world does that automatically make the tech fraudulent or even deficient? and since when is not wanting to develop a skill a reasonable substitute for anything? if my doctor decided they didn't want to keep up on medical advances, i would find a different doctor. but yet somehow finding fault with an ai because it can't read your mind and, in response to that adversity, refusing to introspect at all about why that might be and blaming it on the technology is a reasonable critique? somehow we have magically discovered a technology to manufacture cognition from nothing more than the intricate weaving of silicon, dopants, et al., and the takeaway is that it sucks because it is too slow, doesn't get everything exactly right, etc.? and the craziest part is that the more time you spend with it, the better intuition you get for getting whatever it is you want out of it. but, yeah... let's lend even more of an ear to the head-in-sand crowd-- that's where the real thought leaders are. you don't have to be an ai techno-utopian maximalist to see the profound worthiness and promise of the technology; these things are manifestly self-evident.

Re: The Codex App

#632

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perhaps if he was able to get Claude Code to do what he wanted in less time, and with a better experience, then maybe that's not a skill he (or the rest of us) want to develop.

Sure, that's fine. I wrote my comment for the people who don't get angry at an AI agents after using them for the first time within five hours of their release. For those who aren't interested in portending doom for OpenAI. (I have elaborate setups for Codex/Claude btw, there's no fanboying in this space.) Some things aren't common sense yet so I'm trying my part to make them so.

common sense has the misfortune of being less "common" than we would all like it to be. because some breathless hucksters are overpromising and underdelivering in the present, we may as well throw out the baby, the bath water, and the bath tub itself! who even wants computers to think like humans and automate jobs that no human would want to do? don't you appreciate the self-worth that comes from menial labor? i don't even get why we use tractors to farm when we have perfectly good beasts of burden to do the same labor!

Re: The Codex App

#633
post #506

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure, that's fine. I wrote my comment for the people who don't get angry at an AI agents after using them for the first time within five hours of their release. For those who aren't interested in portending doom for OpenAI. (I have elaborate setups for Codex/Claude btw, there's no fanboying in this space.) Some things aren't common sense yet so I'm trying my part to make them so.

Feelings are information with just as much, or more, value as biased intellectualizing. Ask Linus Torvalds.

i have absolutely no idea whatsoever what this means

Re: The Codex App

#634

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't get this HN worship of Qt. Have you ever used Qt apps on macOS? They don't feel native at all. They feel sort-of native-emulating in the same way wxWidgets apps on macOS feel: they use native controls but all the little details including design language are off. I'm not saying this is a huge problem for me even if it bothers me personally. But if you're here on HN advocating native over Electron, then it seem…

This is not because of Qt - it is due to some (most) Qt developers not caring enough. I created my Qt app feel native both on macOS and Windows[1]. It did require a lot of tuning - but those are things I'll reuse across other apps. [1] https://get-notes.com/

god damn, I've never though Qt app could be this smooth and looking nice.

Re: The Codex App

#635

It's basically what Emdash ( https://www.emdash.sh/ ), Conductor ( https://www.conductor.build/ ) & CO have been building but as first class product from OpenAI. Begs the question if Anthropic will follow up with a first-class Claude Code "multi agent" (git worktree) app themselves.

until then, the https://CommanderAI.app tries to fill the gap on Mac

Re: The Codex App

#636
post #369

Earlier quoted context omitted.

PS: Yes, I spent several hours on the weekend getting Codex to add animations, sound effects, and a mini game to our home page hero graphic. That was fun. I look forward to the creativity that people unleash with tools like this in the coming months.

Link to the site?

I can't share it yet. It's cool but it's definitely not ready for prime time. Thank you for asking.

Re: The Codex App

#637
post #369

Earlier quoted context omitted.

PS: Yes, I spent several hours on the weekend getting Codex to add animations, sound effects, and a mini game to our home page hero graphic. That was fun. I look forward to the creativity that people unleash with tools like this in the coming months.

I think that's the real enabler. Iterating on some polish details that we know the shape of but is hard to get the nuances right.

Absolutely. Things you would ask your designer if they weren't on the drip at $80/hr and maxed out with "other projects".

Re: The Codex App

#638

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm so sick and tired of the macOS elitism in the AI/LLM world.

It's just realism. MacOS is unix under the hood so the models can just use bash and cli tools easily instead of dealing with WSL or Powershell. MacOS has built-in sandboxing at a better level than Windows (afaik the Codex App is delayed for Windows due to sandboxing complexities) Also the vast majority of devs use MacBooks unless they work for Microsoft or are in a company where the vast majority of employees are loc…

> Also the vast majority of devs use MacBooks unless

It takes 15 seconds to verify this isn't even true in webdev, less so everything else.

Re: The Codex App

#639
post #422

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Okay, so you are claiming "every single one of those 8 providers, along with all others who don't serve openrouter but are at similar price points, are subsidizing by more than 50%". That's an incredibly bold claim that would need quite a bit of evidence, and just waving "$500k in gpus" isn't it. Especially when individuals are reporting more than enough tps at native int4 with <$80k setups, without any of the scalin…

Imagine thinking that $80k setups to run Kimi and serve a single user session is evidence that inference providers are running at cost, or even close to it. Or that this fact is some sort of proof that token pricing will come down. All you one-shotted llm dependents said the same thing about Deepseek. I know you need to cope because your competency is 1:1 correlated to the quality and quantity of tokens you can affor…

It directly disproves this wild claim

> You still need $500k in GPUs and a boatload of electricity to serve like 3 concurrent sessions at a decent tok/ps.

as being patent bullshit, after which the burden is squarely on you to back up the remainder of your claims.

Re: The Codex App

#640

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their goal is to ship as fast as possible b/c they don't care about what you care about. Their objective is to gather as much data as possible & electron is good enough for that.

I work at OpenAI, and I get the concern. From our side, this was a careful tradeoff: Electron lets us iterate faster and makes it possible to bring the Codex app to Windows and Linux very soon. That doesn’t mean performance or UX don’t matter—we’re actively paying attention to both. Would genuinely love your thoughts if you try it. Early users have been surprised by how native it feels!

Could you please pass on feedback to the team that the git diff view is very hard to read for red/green colourblind users like myself? Colour scheme like GitUp.co is very readable for me.
Post reply on HN