Live data from Hacker News

U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

reuters.com

631–640 of 651 posts

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#631

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> My guess is that it serves a domestic narrative, and that they've backed themselves into a corner by staking their core legitimacy on annexing Taiwan for so long. > So yes, by offering Taiwan a better deal than they get from the US, they could remove a lot of influence from the region. But it never happens. I doubt this is actually as much a cultural issue for the CCP as it was for past emperors. They've long since…

This makes no sense. With US involvement, Taiwan and South Korea become proxy wars with China. Without us, they become regional conflicts affecting a few million people, not WW3. With US involvement, those conflicts never happen. Hence why they're not happening now. After a hypothetical Taiwan annexation, Okinawa is next. The PRC have made their claims clear. This is the bloodshed the US is preventing. You may be fin…

Without US involvement, those never would've even been around long enough to become conflicts.

If we had pulled out twenty, thirty years ago, they would've been much smaller conflicts. They only get to these proportions because they have strategic value to US hegemony and so we keep arming them and escalating tensions.

> After a hypothetical Taiwan annexation, Okinawa is next. The PRC have made their claims clear. This is the bloodshed the US is preventing.

Taiwan would've surrendered without much of a fight, long ago, if not for US involvement. Taiwanese presidents would not have gotten so bold if not for their big US brother waving carrier groups around. I spent two decades there witnessed firsthand how the culture and anti-Chinese sentiment grew louder as US-China relations continued to deteriorate and Taiwan felt increasingly safe hiding behind the US.

I get your point, that sometimes MAD can be a deterrent, but in this case, we created those flashpoints ourselves, it's only a matter of time before they destabilize. The longer we wait, the worse it's going to get, as the weapons on both sides continue to get more lethal and resource conflicts escalate. Conversely, Hong Kong and Tibet fell without much of a fight because the Chinese army saw no real resistance.

The US can't prevent bloodshed indefinitely, merely postpone it until some future boiling point. The same thing we did in Iraq and Afghanistan. We suck at nation building and "peace"keeping. We defend places only until they are no longer strategically important to us, and then we let them implode, former allies be damned.

> You may be fine with the idea of millions dying because you hate America or whatever. I'm not.

"Millions dying" is probably an inevitability of the new world order, at this point. What I'm not OK with is the US pretending like we can still control the world the same we did in the post-WW2 years, forevermore, with no repercussion. We can't even govern our own country anymore, and we expect to safeguard the world? Who are we kidding?

> Also the fact you think I was alluding to the US allies nuking each other following an American withdrawal shows you really don't understand the situation there at all.

Well, I did ask. I'm still asking. I really don't know what you're referring to. I think regional spheres of influence, vs a failed US global hegemony, would still be the long-term, big-picture, less-lethal route with fewer overall casualties.

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#632

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think that "told you specifically what I was referring to" defines the discussion? Who died and bequeathed it to you alone? imchillyb explicitly mentioned stuff -- yeah, lots of stuff, including among other things false internments at Guantanamo -- so pointing out that your claimed "debunking" does not at all debunk those isn't "vague" at all. Any "vagueness" in their comment is only in your head.

Of the very few topics I consider myself an ultimate authority on, my own mental state and intent is a prime instance. I may not have communicated effectively. And in discussion with you it seems I'll never be able to. But I know what I intended to communicate, and have stated what that is, repeatedly. You seem bent on steering the conversation to what you wanted to hear me say. Which seems to be a premise founded on…

If anyone who seems bent here, it's you: Bent on dictating the terms not only of what you are talking about, but what everyone is.

But yeah: As long as you think you get to define what the conversation is about by what you "were referring to", yes Doug, we're done here.

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#633

Wow, Israeli's spying on their main sponsor?? Espionage is part of the political territory but hopefully this sets precedent to a change of optics. (Which probably not since Russia does it boldly for fun at this point).

There's a big, big difference between acting against your ally, and irresponsibly proliferating technology that's used against them. cf. France's Exocet sales and the Falklands, though much lower impact this time.

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#634

I'm curious what the iPhones being hacked means as they were thought by general public as being very secure. Would this imply 0-day exploits? Did they use backdoors put in place for US spying agencies?

Zero-days.

"They and other targets notified by Apple in multiple countries were infected through the same graphics processing vulnerability that Apple did not learn about and fix until September, the sources said.

Since at least February, this software flaw allowed some NSO customers to take control of iPhones simply by sending invisible yet tainted iMessage requests to the device, researchers who investigated the espionage campaign said."

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#635

Sanction them then. The US has sanctioned companies for much less.

They did.

"A State Department spokesperson declined to comment on the intrusions, instead pointing to the Commerce Department's recent decision to place the Israeli company on an entity list, making it harder for U.S. companies to do business with them.

NSO Group and another spyware firm were "added to the Entity List based on a determination that they developed and supplied spyware to foreign governments that used this tool to maliciously target government officials, journalists, businesspeople, activists, academics, and embassy workers," the Commerce Department said in an announcement last month."

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#636

I thought the exploited holes were patched by iOS at some point. How are these phones still getting hacked?

This is being publicized only now.

The issues were patched in September, the exploit was being used as of February, and it took some time for someone to notice that an @state.gov Apple ID was among the compromised phones.

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#637

Imagine that sinking feeling in the NSO offices. Uncle Sam's coming...

You sure about that?

Yes.

"A State Department spokesperson declined to comment on the intrusions, instead pointing to the Commerce Department's recent decision to place the Israeli company on an entity list, making it harder for U.S. companies to do business with them.

NSO Group and another spyware firm were "added to the Entity List based on a determination that they developed and supplied spyware to foreign governments that used this tool to maliciously target government officials, journalists, businesspeople, activists, academics, and embassy workers," the Commerce Department said in an announcement last month."

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#638

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Suing is hardly the same as having the suit decided, grow up.

Okay. Let's assume they do have the suit decided, and they rule in Apple's favor. What next?

NSO is a corporation with US bank accounts and business deals; the courts take its money.

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#639

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> This happened several times, so unless the Israeli command center had the memory of a goldfish - they intentionally kept sending attack aircraft until they eventually got a pilot to pull the trigger. Why would they do such a thing? To that point, it's worth noting here friendly fire incidents happen all the time in war, as well as attacks against neutral parties. For instance: the US has bombed its own troops proba…

The Israeli government had strong incentive to do this, and accounts on the ship were that this was clearly intentional. Why is this so hard for you to believe?

> The Israeli government had strong incentive to do this, and accounts on the ship were that this was clearly intentional. Why is this so hard for you to believe?

Because an imputed motive is not proof of anything, and there's no way "accounts on the ship" could provide the information you claim they do (knowledge of the attackers mental state).

I don't think anyone disputes that the Israelis attacked the ship intentionally, but you can say the same about most friendly fire incidents. The question is if the people who made the attack deliberately decided to attack what they know to be an American ship.

Re: U.S. State Department phones hacked with Israeli company spyware

#640
post #552

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nobody claimed in the article that this is a case of Israel spying on the US. That would be quite a jump.

But it’s only one or two steps removed = Israeli company, acting with the approval and protection of the Israeli state, enabled and facilitated spying on the US by a third party.

The world is only one or two steps removed. Israel is acting under the approval and protection of the US ==> US was spying on itself /s
Post reply on HN