Live data from Hacker News

Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

youtube.com

611–620 of 827 posts

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#611

It's interesting to see people here and on Blind are more wary? of AI than people in say, Reddit or Youtube comments

Reddit and YouTube are such huge social media platforms that it really depends on which bubble (read: subreddits/yt channels) you're looking at. There's the "AGI is here" people over at r/singularity and then the "AI is useless" people at r/programming. I'm simplifying arguments from both sides here but you get my point.

Even looking at r/programming I felt they were less wary of AI, or even comparing the comments here vs those on YouTube for this video

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#612

I spent a lot of time thinking about this recently. Ultimately, English is not a clean, deterministic abstraction layer. This isn't to say that LLMs aren't useful, and can create some great efficiencies.

no, but a subset of English could be

You just invented programming languages, halfway

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#615

This DevOps friction is exactly why I'm building an open-source "Firebase for LLMs." The moment you want to add AI to an app, you're forced to build a backend just to securely proxy API calls—you can't expose LLM API keys client-side. So developers who could previously build entire apps backend-free suddenly need servers, key management, rate limiting, logging, deployment... all just to make a single OpenAI call. Any…

Yeah, hit this exact wall building a small AI tool. Ended up spinning up a whole backend just to keep the keys safe. Feels like there should be a simpler way, but haven’t seen anything that’s truly plug-and-play yet. Curious to see what you’re working on.

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#616

This DevOps friction is exactly why I'm building an open-source "Firebase for LLMs." The moment you want to add AI to an app, you're forced to build a backend just to securely proxy API calls—you can't expose LLM API keys client-side. So developers who could previously build entire apps backend-free suddenly need servers, key management, rate limiting, logging, deployment... all just to make a single OpenAI call. Any…

Do you think Firebase and Superbase are working on this? Good luck but to me it sounds like a platform feature, not a standalone product.

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#617
post #378

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I say this all the time! Does anybody really want to be an assembly line QA reviewer for an automated code factory? Sounds like shit. Also I can’t really imagine that in the first place. At my current job, each task is like 95% understanding all the little bits, and then 5% writing the code. If you’re reviewing PRs from a bot all day, you’ll still need to understand all the bits before you accept it. So how much time…

> Does anybody really want to be an assembly line QA reviewer for an automated code factory? Sounds like shit. On the other hand, does anyone really wanna be a code-monkey implementing CRUD applications over and over by following product specifications by "product managers" that barely seem to understand the product they're "managing"? See, we can make bad faith arguments both ways, but what's the point?

I hesitate to divide a group as diverse as software devs into two categories, but here I go:

I have a feeling that devs who love LLM coding tools are more product-driven than those who hate them.

Put another way, maybe devs with their own product ideas love LLM coding tools, whilr devs without them do not.

I am genuinely not trying to throw shade here in any way. Does this rough division ring true to anyone else? Is there any better way to put it?

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#618

This DevOps friction is exactly why I'm building an open-source "Firebase for LLMs." The moment you want to add AI to an app, you're forced to build a backend just to securely proxy API calls—you can't expose LLM API keys client-side. So developers who could previously build entire apps backend-free suddenly need servers, key management, rate limiting, logging, deployment... all just to make a single OpenAI call. Any…

Yeah, hit this exact wall building a small AI tool. Ended up spinning up a whole backend just to keep the keys safe. Feels like there should be a simpler way, but haven’t seen anything that’s truly plug-and-play yet. Curious to see what you’re working on.

It’s very obvious this account was just created to promote your product…

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#619

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I also think that structured outputs are criminally underused, but it isn't perfect... and per your example, it might not even be good, because I've done something similar. I was trying to make a decent cocktail recipe database, and scraped the text of cocktails from about 1400 webpages. Note that this was just the text of the cocktail recipe, and cocktail recipes are comparatively small. I sent the text to an LLM fo…

have you tried schema-aligned parsing yet? the idea is that instead of using JSON.parse, we create a custom Type.parse for each type you define. so if you want a: class Job { company: string[] } And the LLM happens to output: { "company": "Amazon" } We can upcast "Amazon" -> ["Amazon"] since you indicated that in your schema. https://www.boundaryml.com/blog/schema-aligned-parsing and since its only post processing, t…

Interesting! I was using function calling in OpenAI and JSON mode in Ollama with zod. I may revisit the project with SAP.

Re: Andrej Karpathy: Software in the era of AI [video]

#620

This DevOps friction is exactly why I'm building an open-source "Firebase for LLMs." The moment you want to add AI to an app, you're forced to build a backend just to securely proxy API calls—you can't expose LLM API keys client-side. So developers who could previously build entire apps backend-free suddenly need servers, key management, rate limiting, logging, deployment... all just to make a single OpenAI call. Any…

[dead]
Post reply on HN