Live data from Hacker News

New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

washingtonpost.com

611–620 of 1001 posts

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#611

> The two sides negotiated until late Sunday. The sticking points in recent days were over whether they could get a “just cause” provision in their contract, which means workers can be terminated only for misconduct or another such reason; pay increases and pay equity; and return-to-office policies. This seems like a LOT of issues that still need to be hammered out. It would be one thing if they were disagreeing abou…

> Striking during election week is kind of a crappy move to pull. Can we get a definitive list of weeks where workers’ rights are officially less important than $world_event? That way we can schedule our requests appropriately. We don’t want to inconvenience anyone.

I know you are trying to be flip, but there topics that are more important than worker's rights. I'm not going to argue that the NYTimes crossword is up there, but I think a good case can be made that independent journalism is up there, especially during open elections.

There is a long list of organizations and governments that made worker's rights more important than inclusive democratic institutions, and it didn't work out for anyone, especially the workers.

Maybe any of the 207 weeks between presidential elections? Or any of the thousands of weeks when one of the running candidates has threatened the legitimacy of their institution directly?

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#612

I totally support their demand for remote work. NY Times should hire more remote! They could save a lot by hiring offshore without hassle of providing benefits or fighting unions.

Have you ever done knowledge work with offshore contributors? It’s challenging to say the least. Even when working between first-world countries speaking English, there’s a host of serious problems. Cultural differences; different expectations; time zone differences.

Yes, I did. For more han a decade. With same failure rates as with in-office teams.

With 100k annual budget you can hire a contractor with good English who will be working in your timezone.

Regarding cultural difference - does everyone in your office has the same culture? No indian-born developers? No asian-born?

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#613
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good luck. I'm curious what you feel about the following: These days news publications generally have a pretty weak business model and a lot of competition. Does it still make sense to have a union in this case? Why?

Something I've learned from 404 media is journalism actually has a fine business model. People are willing to pay for good journalism. The problem is (much like the rest of the economy) what passes for news media is incredibly top heavy and bloated with managers, executives, and shareholders who suck up money without providing any value. For every journalist there are 15 managers and editors hired for nepotism reason…

Lots of interesting things in here - thanks for sharing - but why on earth do you call NYT and WashPo "right wing"?

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#614

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Are you deliberately ignoring the concept of power imbalance and wide spectrum on which it occurs? All of those examples you cited are drastically different types of relationships, set in very different contexts, that absolutely deserve different terms of engagement. >Do we now hate the rich so much that we want to impose that burden on them when they pay someone I don't even know how to parse this. We're talking abo…

That power imbalance mainly exists if you don't save any money and/or live in an area with only a couple of employment options in your field and can't move. If you save up enough money to take a couple years off, there's no power imbalance.

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#615

Why would anybody trust a NYT article about internal drama at the NYT? Does HN not understand bias? Compare the NYT article to other reporting, and you can see the difference. There's a few things the NYT forgot to mention, like the fact that these negotiations have been drawn out for 2 years now. Or this: "Throughout the bargaining process, Times management has engaged in numerous labor law violations, including imp…

Hello - former NYT employee here, who would have been part of the Guild union if I worked there still. The story is written by a reporter, Katie Robertson, who is also part of their own union (Times Guild). The Times has been pretty good at covering itself imho.

> former NYT employee here

> The Times has been pretty good and covering itself imho.

This is silly. It's like the people who say that the Bible is true because the Bible says the Bible is true.

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#616

With the shit show that the current tech industry has turned into, unionization is crucial. US has a very low percentage of unionized workers compared to Iceland, Finland and Scandinavian countries for instance. Time to change and make our voice heard.

How? How can we go from an HN comment to making this a reality?

This book[1] was a great read on the topic.

[1]: https://ethanmarcotte.com/books/you-deserve-a-tech-union/

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#617

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If it's low for the market why choose to work at the NYT? Being a tech worker isn't like being a steelworker where you're kinda screwed if the plant shuts down. You're fully capable of moving job if you're dissatisfied. > Why they have 600 people is a question for management, no? It's a question for everyone at the organisation. If you're joining a firm with a massively bloated headcount you need to think if you're g…

Well let's get into what NYT does: apps and widgets for several platforms, a separate paid "games" product, advertising backend, podcasts on separate apps, visualizations for key stories.. the list goes on. And at a very large scale. NYT isn't comparable to The Guardian. It's subscription based so the news isn't enough. They have to add cooking, games, The Athletic, etc, across a ton of different apps, feeds, and pre…

I know they have a larger range of services, but are they 20x the breadth of services? Think of what other companies do with 600 tech people and compare what the profitability per employee should be at an tech organisation of such a scale.

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#618

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A neutral source from a third party news outlet. Do you think bias is a one-dimensional tug of war that cancels each other out when combined?

Would you prefer neutral coverage from a third party news outlet with a unionized workforce or one without a unionized workforce?

Just a third party news outlet is probably fine.

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#619

Have devs at any of the large tech companies ever tried to unionize? If not, why not?

Historically big tech provided amazing compensation and benefits compared to everyone except some finance companies. Why unionize and potentially risk a very good thing?

For context, the NY Times does not provide amazing compensation or benefits.

Re: New York Times Tech Guild goes on strike

#620

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A neutral source from a third party news outlet. Do you think bias is a one-dimensional tug of war that cancels each other out when combined?

Would you prefer neutral coverage from a third party news outlet with a unionized workforce or one without a unionized workforce?

How is this relevant? We expect newspapers to be balanced regardless. The issue here is reporting from someone, , at arm's length.
Post reply on HN