IMHO nothing you said contradicts with anything I said.
People are free to buy or not-buy any stock, and to sell or not-sell any stock that they already hold. Everyone trading is an adult and is free to do it (notwithstanding things like insider trading, etc).
There is nothing illegal in the activities that I've seen: just people/institutions trading and holding stocks in an open market.
Some of those people are/will be making money through these actions and some are/will be losing money. As Nick Maggiulli recently posted (on a somewhat unrelated topic):
> If it wasn’t obvious before, it bears repeating now—some people are going to beat you at investing. Some of them will be dumber than you. Some will be less knowledgable. Some will even be completely wrong about the future. But they will beat you just the same. There is no great arbiter of justice in the investment world. There is no cosmic force that ensures that only the knowledgable make money. If there were, then I would be a far richer man today.
* https://ofdollarsanddata.com/let-them-vote/
As someone who rides a motorcycle, I think it's stupid not to wear helmet, gloves, etc., and yet in Michigan it's legal to ride without a helmet. IMHO it's dumb, but many people do it and ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Currently some people think GME is worth US$347.51 per share and are willing to pay for it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
It's their money and they can do whatever they want with it. I invest in index and bond funds (80/20), but if someone wants to YOLO on this: not my circus, not my monkeys.