Live data from Hacker News

Run to Stay Young

well.blogs.nytimes.com

61–70 of 120 posts

Re: Run to Stay Young

#61
post #46

The conclusions drawn in the article don't seem to match the study in question. The participants were not experimentally assigned to be either walkers or runners; rather, they had themselves already selected whether or not to be walkers or runners. This implies that the large proportion of older adults who are neither walkers nor runners are not represented in this study. It also makes it impossible to determine the…

Even if the study had been conducted properly, this only addresses walking vs running. That running is better than walking doesn't necessarily mean that people should go and start running. How about running vs lifting weights, running vs yoga, or running vs tai chi?

Re: Run to Stay Young

#62

After 30 years of running, I can attest to the irreversible damage caused to knees, shins, and other joints and ligaments due to running on paved and other man made surfaces. A good alternative as you get up in years is swimming and/or cycling or recumbent biking.

I got this when I got hurt. I love it.

http://www.elliptigo.com/

Re: Run to Stay Young

#63
post #32
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Running barefoot on pavement in the city doesn't work very well. Every time I try it for a significant journey, I can barely walk for a week due to blisters and small glass fragments. Also, people, rightly, stare at me like I'm insane.

Just get some "barefoot" shoes. I use merrell trail glove.

Agreed, merrell trail gloves are great shoes. I run 60-70km per week in them.

I highly recommend barefoot style shoes in general, but you do have to acclimate to them slowly while you build up your foot strength.

After building foot strength in 'barefoot' shoes, I can now run much faster in any kind of shoe.

Re: Run to Stay Young

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Try running barefoot on grass (or, if you live near a beach, sand) instead of concrete -- much better on the joints!

Sure, until you step on something sharp hiding in that grass, like broken glass.

If that's stopping you, try something like the Merrell Trail Glove or the New Balance Minimus. You get good sharp protection but pretty much zero padding and very minimal heel drop.

Re: Run to Stay Young

#65
In 1977 Jim Fixx published the best-selling book "The Complete Book of Running" which popularized running for sport, and purported to demonstrate its health benefits - including increased longevity.

7 years later he died of a heart attack while jogging at the age of 52.

His death doesn't mean running is a bad idea - a single anecdote is statistically insignificant - but perhaps it can remind us that nothing we do can guarantee a long and healthy life.

All too often we take a mildly correlated statistic, give it a hand-wavy air of "science", and then pronounce it as a set-in-stone moral absolute. How much of the received wisdom about healthy lifestyles that you were taught has been shown to be completely wrong? I don't doubt that in 3 years there will be another New York times article, demonstrating why running is actually terrible for you, and you should never do it no matter what age you are.

Growing up in a secular society ancient religions can seem awful strange: why did people worship stone statues and sacrifice to them? Did they really believe all that effort did anything?

But perhaps our modern obsession with "healthiness" reflects the same underlying human motivation: incapable of accepting the reality of our own deaths we grasp at anything to try and give ourselves the illusion of control. Is eating an organic strawberry in the hopes of living longer really any different than performing a ritualistic dance in the hopes of bringing rain?

Re: Run to Stay Young

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

why? downhills are free.

Not on your knees. Downhill running (and hiking) is also more anaerobic (stopping your self from falling) than aerobic (working to move up).

If you're stopping yourself from falling when running downhill, you're doing it wrong. You should be "leaning into" the hill, which is counterintuitive and feels like you're going to fall, but is way better for your knees and also faster than stopping yourself.

Re: Run to Stay Young

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not on your knees. Downhill running (and hiking) is also more anaerobic (stopping your self from falling) than aerobic (working to move up).

If you're stopping yourself from falling when running downhill, you're doing it wrong. You should be "leaning into" the hill, which is counterintuitive and feels like you're going to fall, but is way better for your knees and also faster than stopping yourself.

That only works for some grades. The grades in the Bay Area are pretty steep. If you leaned into the downward slope, you would be on your face in a few seconds.

Re: Run to Stay Young

#68
post #36

isn't running absolutely horrible for one's joints (e.g. knees)? not to mention the bowel issues

The joints issue was my first thought too. Could you explain the bowel point though? How does running effect this?

Runner's diarrhea [0].

[0] http://www.mayoclinic.org/runners-diarrhea/expert-answers/fa...

Re: Run to Stay Young

#69
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I ran 4 years of D1 cross country. Can confirm. The oft-repeated trope is "concrete is 12x harder than soft surface grass." Not sure how true that is or how the physics work, but stay away from roads. Run on the dirt on the side of them.

I would rather run on a level surface even if it is harder. You can hurt your knee or ankle rather quickly running through some fields; but that's part of the experience I guess.

Running on an uneven running surface isn't bad for you at all. Most people run primarily on the roads - so if they encounter a long path with uneven terrain - the ancillary muscles that control stabilization generally tire more quickly. It's all about transitioning slowly and letting the muscles, that haven't been used very often, strengthen.

Re: Run to Stay Young

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

why? downhills are free.

Not on your knees. Downhill running (and hiking) is also more anaerobic (stopping your self from falling) than aerobic (working to move up).

You may have just misspoken but it'd be almost impossible to get any anaerobic training out of downhill running. You might be doing some muscle strengthening though.
Post reply on HN