Live data from Hacker News

The Diet Fix

sciencebasedmedicine.org

61–63 of 63 posts

Re: The Diet Fix

#61
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nope. As far as having an effect on weight loss, net-energy balance (energy added - energy used) is several magnitudes more important than anything else, and the "energy added" side of this equation is entirely calories. Hormones are driven by your environment, and food is a huge environmental stimulus, especially when we're limiting our discussion to weight-loss. But don't conflate that with the idea that hormones a…

Except for silly edge cases? Okay then eat your recommended calories worth of cocopuffs for breakfast, since it's all about energy. Calorie counting oversimplifies the problem. Sure it might describe what is going on, but it can be a poor guide for a dieter trying to decide what to eat next.

Edge cases are exactly that; not typical and therefore need special consideration. But these are rare in the general public.

I didn't say its ALL about energy, just that nothing comes close to the contribution of calories in weight-loss. The type of food you eat is completely drowned out by how much food you eat. So you CAN eat only cocopuffs and lose the exact same weight you'd lose eating a "balanced diet" consisting of the same # of calories (which means both diets contain the same amount of energy), although you risk becoming malnourished over time.

If a dieter's goal is to lose weight, the amount of food they eat (or more precisely the amount of food + amount of activity) is most important. This fundamental principle makes it easy to decide what to eat next. However if the goal is long term health, athletic performance, or growing muscle, then we need to modify how we choose. But it's really not that complicated for almost everyone; just eat mostly whole foods.

Re: The Diet Fix

#62
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm interested in what you mean by "fundamentals"?

I wish there was a way to answer that appropriately in the space of a comment. Regarding nutrition, this is what I tell people to start with: http://www.amazon.ca/Advanced-Nutrition-Metabolism-Sareen-Gr... It's a great book, and more accessible than you might think.

my nick at gmail, I'd love to open a conversation on this if you're willing

Re: The Diet Fix

#63
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wish there was a way to answer that appropriately in the space of a comment. Regarding nutrition, this is what I tell people to start with: http://www.amazon.ca/Advanced-Nutrition-Metabolism-Sareen-Gr... It's a great book, and more accessible than you might think.

my nick at gmail, I'd love to open a conversation on this if you're willing

These are an EXCELLENT resource - http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/articles

Read them all, or only the topics that matter to you; Lyle is one of the best in the world.

Post reply on HN