Live data from Hacker News

The Flaw that May Bring Down Bitcoin or Change it Forever

globalguerrillas.typepad.com

61–62 of 62 posts

Re: The Flaw that May Bring Down Bitcoin or Change it Forever

#61
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The "encoding method" is ASCII text. The data can be extracted by running "strings *.dat" on the block chain on any UNIX system. After that you can grep through the output. This is not like XORing data, or as some people have said "everything occurs somewhere in the digits of pi". The blockchain in no sense encodes all possible values, or a fraction thereof, the data is trivial to extract. This is much more like, it'…

No, it's not just ASCII text. Only miners (like Satoshi's headline in the genesis block and Kaminsky's ASCII Bernake) are able to include ASCII data in blocks, everyone else needs to somehow encode it in transaction data.

err, yes it is just ASCII text. I suggest you run "strings" over the blockchain yourself, which I have done. If it wasn't I doubt anyone would find it.

I don't know if they used Kaminsky's technique or something else but it is plain text.

Re: The Flaw that May Bring Down Bitcoin or Change it Forever

#62
post #9

This will neither bring bitcoin down or change it forever. Any information contained in those bytes is just that: information. What can you say in 20 bytes that can have permanent, material damage to human beings? A wonderfully sensationalist title, but really nothing to back it up.

I really don't understand why people are saying it's 20 bytes, the wikileaks cables are about 2mb, with a 100+ line python program. The latest issue is a long (at least 1000 lines) FAQ containing urls.

I think part of the problem is that people don't want to directly point to the data due to it's nature. But you can easily run strings over the blockchain and see what's there. I did myself and then deleted it and zero'd by free space, it's unfortunately not something I would want on my HD. I moved to a blockchainless client.

Post reply on HN