Live data from Hacker News

Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

techcrunch.com

61–70 of 101 posts

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#61
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a software developer you're playing a round of roulette for every 10k you make. As noble as what you're saying sounds, nobody wants to be a casualty of war.

It's not a casualty. It's a cause. What is there to lose? The laws are already imprisoning us. Might as well see it through.

Mostly time, sadly. We all have lots of ideas and aspirations, but time is always short at hand. If we had more of it, much easier to fight things.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#62
post #28

The moral of the story is don't develop software unless you have the resources to fight patent lawsuits. I haven't, so I don't.

you mean dont do it in USA , the so-called land of opportunities ...

The article mentions Mojang and Uniloc suing for the '067 patent.

Mojang are not in the US.

Maybe companies threatened by patents could motivate the public by preventing US citizens from having access to those companies' software for a week, but that's unlikely to happen.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#63
post #4
post #2

I honestly don't even know what to say when these things come up nowadays. It just seems like the bullshit won't end. I can't think of any options that even exist to fix this broken patent system.

It's as if some sort of patent "tragedy" would need to happen, such as an extremely popular application used by multiple voting blocs be shut down, an application whose absence would set off a larger popular response. However, the owner of such an application would have to somehow be vulnerable, and I'm not sure what's out there that would match this criteria. Certainly not a Google or Microsoft, to state the obvious…

Someone like Google or Microsoft can just pay to settle. No such 'tragedy' is possible.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#64

"Just think about the logic here. The people complaining about the law suits here are complaining that a company is trying to protect it's own right to make a living from a technology that the patent office has verified as unique and novel. If you disagree then track the patent office and voice your problems with the patents as they are published." Because the patent office verified it as "novel," that's the reason h…

If you disagree then watch every patent as they are published to make certain they are non-obvious? This guy is full of it. Of course you would have to be full of it to think this patent was non-obvious.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You'd spend more money suing the patent troll organizations than you'd ever recover, because they could just close up shop and move on, being non-practicing entities with no real assets or holdings.

In other words, you put that entity out of business. Sounds like success!

No, there was an article recently on HN about how Intellectual Ventures "loads" a shell company by transferring a patent to it only days before filing the dispute. If you put the shell out of business they lose only the single patent (if that). They don't care about the shell, it's like an eyelash of the giant.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#66

The moral of the story is don't develop software unless you have the resources to fight patent lawsuits. I haven't, so I don't.

I think the moral is to incorporate company A, which sells source code without any warranty to company B (also yours), which sells the binaries to users. Company B is perpetually in debt to company A; if they are sued they use their remaining assets to pay A and then declare bankruptcy.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#68
post #62
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

you mean dont do it in USA , the so-called land of opportunities ...

The article mentions Mojang and Uniloc suing for the '067 patent. Mojang are not in the US. Maybe companies threatened by patents could motivate the public by preventing US citizens from having access to those companies' software for a week, but that's unlikely to happen.

But Mojang doesn't need to care about it. The only reason they do is because it could affect their deals with US payment processors but they can just ignore it if they would like to. Austin Meyer on the other hand has to submit since he's based in the US.

Re: Creator Of The X-Plane Flight Simulator Seeks Help Fighting A Patent Troll

#70

I'm not really sure on this, but Uniloc owner Ric Richardson doesn't seem prima facie to fit the normal patent troll profile: he appears to be a bona fide inventor, but then I only looked at wikipedia and his blog http://ricrichardson.blogspot.co.uk/ . Doesn't mean I support his action, of course and the whle legal system is fcked, hence the problem of the trolls, like Nathan Myrhvold's "Intellectual Ventures" https:…

"he appears to be a bona fide inventor"

Not sure what constitutes a bona fida inventor but the first post on his blog is how he has just taken out a patent on another invention.

It seems he just invents stuff to then patent it. To me an inventor builds things. This is more akin to coming up with an idea and then cutting off anybody from every executing that idea without even having executed it yourself.

Post reply on HN