Live data from Hacker News

Spain shuts airspace for US planes involved in Iran war

english.aawsat.com

61–65 of 65 posts

Re: Spain shuts airspace for US planes involved in Iran war

#61
post #60
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Granted to them for free"? The US has been paying Spain for base access since 1953. Hundreds of millions per renewal cycle in military aid, economic assistance, and direct spending. It was never free and it was never a favor. Spain negotiated compensation every time. "Who does Spain need defending from?" Nobody, because of the security architecture my tax dollars built. That's not evidence the bases are a favor to u…

No, specifically, which of their neighbors do they need protecting from. France? Portugal? Andorra?? The bases are a remnant of American imperialism, they serve no purpose but to further American interest. Any pretension they do anything else can only be explained as late imperial delusion of grandeur. The fact the Spanish don't let you use them to engage in your unforced act of historic self harm can be seen as yet…

Spain had the largest empire in the Western Hemisphere. Extracted silver, enslaved entire populations, and lost it when we kicked their teeth in during 1898. That's imperialism. Paying someone hundreds of millions to let you park planes on their runway is not. And "which neighbor do they need defending from" is a question that tells on itself. If you still think wars are about neighboring countries you haven't been paying attention to anything happening in the world right now.

Re: Spain shuts airspace for US planes involved in Iran war

#62
post #61
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, specifically, which of their neighbors do they need protecting from. France? Portugal? Andorra?? The bases are a remnant of American imperialism, they serve no purpose but to further American interest. Any pretension they do anything else can only be explained as late imperial delusion of grandeur. The fact the Spanish don't let you use them to engage in your unforced act of historic self harm can be seen as yet…

Spain had the largest empire in the Western Hemisphere. Extracted silver, enslaved entire populations, and lost it when we kicked their teeth in during 1898. That's imperialism. Paying someone hundreds of millions to let you park planes on their runway is not. And "which neighbor do they need defending from" is a question that tells on itself. If you still think wars are about neighboring countries you haven't been p…

> . If you still think wars are about neighboring countries you haven't been paying attention to anything happening in the world right now

I'm not sure what you're referring to. There's only one war in Europe right now and it's between two neighbors.

Y'all bombing brown people again is not a war or a threat to us, it's just something we'd rather not be part of.

Re: Spain shuts airspace for US planes involved in Iran war

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Israel has had public education and public healthcare forever… This also applies to US aid.

Nope, Israel had it much earlier.

Why would you even bother to post this obviously false claim? Might as well claim that the earth is flat.

Re: Spain shuts airspace for US planes involved in Iran war

#64
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Israel, the nation state, came into being in 1948, with the explicit financial and military aid of the United States to do so. It has had American support since within hours of its founding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Israel#State_of_... "At the end of 1948, 53% of Israel's Jewish population was insured, about 80% of them by Clalit, with a few small health funds insuring the remainder. In the followi…

To be fair here, what people often overlook by using Israel's current government as a reference point is that during the Kibbutz era Israel was decidedly left-wing. So I wouldn't necessarily attribute the presence of 90% or later 100% health care to US money.

>So I wouldn't necessarily attribute the presence of 90% or later 100% health care to US money.

This is very strange, given that there would be no state of Israel without US money.

Post reply on HN