Live data from Hacker News

Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

simonwillison.net

61–70 of 96 posts

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

You mispronounced genuinely polite. It is free to be so. Is that not allowed here when someone doesn’t have strong feelings? If you care here about here, you care too much imho, find something that matters to care about.

It's not polite to be condescending.

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You mispronounced genuinely polite. It is free to be so. Is that not allowed here when someone doesn’t have strong feelings? If you care here about here, you care too much imho, find something that matters to care about.

It's not polite to be condescending.

My comment was genuine. It is a genuine shame someone states they despise me with little additional context, and as I said, it doesn’t bother me and I do wish them well. Where was the condescending? Am I supposed to have strong feelings? Am I supposed to lash out? No, all unnecessary. “Be conservative in what you do, be liberal in what you accept from others". They are simply at a different point in their journey than I am.

How else would you politely respond to someone who comments only “I know. I despise you”?

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#63
post #46

See also https://antirez.com/news/150 https://antirez.com/hnstyle?username=pg&threshold=20&action=... Which lets you find the alts of a handle

suspected alts .. like the pg example I also have similar accounts with similar match levels and I know I've never had a HN alt, nor do I recognise any of my suggested alts as familar accounts I've interacted with.

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#64

This is...disquieting. It's one thing to know that it's possible, another thing to know nation states or large megacorps are doing it, but another thing entirely to see such verbose output from free models about, well, me . The first two, I've made peace with (nothing I can do about it anyway). The last one picks quite fiercely at old trauma that really makes me reconsider my socials in general, not just HN. But mayb…

From another perspective, it's like hearing others judging you behind your back. First few times it's awkward and maybe even annoying, but given enough time you stops to give a damn about it.

But, the problem is real if it's a nation states or megacorps are doing it. They'll use such tech in an unjustified way, make a misjudgement, and then ask you to explain yourself out of the situation. Yeah, they're definitely going that, because they don't give a damn about it.

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#65
post #33

You can just ask a chatbot about Hacker News or reddit users based on their username.

I asked about my comments and was amused by one part of the answer:

6. Slightly dry, understated style

The tone is usually compact, matter-of-fact, and occasionally wry rather than performative. Even their Wuhan taxi-driver remark has that deadpan “I have seen the circus” flavor.

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#66

Story time: My first full time job (early 2000s) was working for a firm that did online cybersecurity related investigations for Fortune 500 companies (generally via a 3rd party law firm they had retained). A big part of this was running investigations into people running "pump and dump" stock schemes on Yahoo message boards. We would generally start by scraping all of the posts for a user who had instigated one of t…

I thought I had deja vu when reading your comment so I searched and found that you wrote something very similar 6 years ago, then 4 months ago and then 3 comments within the last month.

Out of curiosity and without meaning it to sound like an accusation, did you write such similar posts by hand or do you use some form of automation for commenting?

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#67
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We all know this, but in the past someone probably wasn't going to go through thousands of your comments unless you've really pissed them off. It's worth realising how much lower the activation energy is these days.

You’re right about the speed; but it doesn’t change the outcome. If you don’t want it to be associated with you, you simply can’t put it out there.

There are emergent effects of technologies getting cheaper and more accessible.

Surveillance was always possible but it was expensive because a person or two had to literally watch a suspect. So it was rare in practice and suspects had to be chosen carefully.

Mass surveillance is not new in the sense that surveillance was always possible. What is new is the scope of power it gives to those who can use it.

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#68
post #2

> This is arguably their defining HN characteristic: they are one of the most vocal, persistent AI optimists on the platform. They claim ~90-95% of their shipped code is AI-generated, report 5-10x productivity gains, and have built a detailed methodology around it — using Playwright for visual verification, static typechecking as a hallucination filter, and e2e test suites as automated validation harnesses Wow, I sou…

I sound like an annoying old people I guess so I think I'm worse. Either way I forgive you. (GPT called me a wiring closet gremlin)

"wiring closet gremlin"!?

I knew the original!8-)) Hope you aren't him!

Re: Profiling Hacker News users based on their comments

#70

Story time: My first full time job (early 2000s) was working for a firm that did online cybersecurity related investigations for Fortune 500 companies (generally via a 3rd party law firm they had retained). A big part of this was running investigations into people running "pump and dump" stock schemes on Yahoo message boards. We would generally start by scraping all of the posts for a user who had instigated one of t…

> b. related to a, how even small tidbits combined over time can build a pretty accurate picture of who someone is.

that's basically why clickstream analytics is so powerful

Post reply on HN