Live data from Hacker News

ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

binnenlandsbestuur.nl

61–70 of 229 posts

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Microsoft has to follow US sanctions, even if they are misplaced. This isn't a choice on Microsoft's part here. The ICC was applauded in the US in the when it went after Russia but when it goes after Israel it is sanctioned. It unfortunately hard to be impartial, like the ICC is, when it comes to international war crimes. The big players want you to play towards their favourites and only hold their enemies accountabl…

> Microsoft has to follow US sanctions Microsoft has to follow US law . If it believes an order has been issued unlawfully, it—and everyone who works there who follows the order—has a civic duty to oppose the order in court.

Quite a few of the things that European authorities have been getting worried about the US Government being able to force Microsoft to do are explicitly enshrined in US law. See, for example, the CLOUD Act: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CLOUD_Act

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#62
post #16

I think the bigger question is why they were using microsoft products in the first place. USA has been very hostile to the ICC under trump, but its not exactly a huge shift, bush was also incredibly hostile. It seems borderline incompetent to use a microsoft cloud offering given the political situation. Not to mention given the type of work they do, seems like hosting stuff off site at all is a bad plan.

How much do you think they should spend on IT to be independent from Microsoft (serious question) ? Wikipedia mentions they employ 800 persons working in several buildings and a detention center for a budget of 141 million USD.

Microsoft O365 Business Premium per person is 22 USD per month so total per year is ~200k USD (online price, I imagine they can negotiate a bit for that amount of people).

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#63
post #60
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

USA has been very hostile to the ICC since way before Trump. The ICC was created in 1998 when Bill Clinton was president of the USA. He never ratified the Rome treaty. And then GW, Obama, Trump and Biden didn't either. Very few americans batted an eye as far as I could tell. Your are after all by definition exceptional. (/s)

This is not a U.S. specific issue. Once you strip away all of the formalities, titles, and ceremonies, you'll realize there's no such thing as international law, at least not in any meaningful sense of the word. The law, by definition is a rule backed up by the use of force, specifically state-sanctioned violence. If you write a law but do not have the ability to use a sufficient amount violence to enforce it when ne…

[flagged]

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d love to see pictures. I’d love to drop MS/Google docs for something I can control myself.

Have you tried LibreOffice ( https://www.libreoffice.org/ ) or OnlyOffice ( https://www.onlyoffice.com/desktop )? Both are pretty decent, and free, and also have commercial versions.

MS365/Google docs is something entirely different to the old desktop office suites

It's a collaboration tool, with synced storage and file management etc

The overlap of a Venn diagram between users of these software is not very large - though there is some (overlap).

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#65

Lawyers historically are notoriously linked to Microsoft and its formats as a somewhat unintentional industry side standard. Moves like this hearten me as for certain lawyers the formats and standards they now will be expected to follow has just shifted, towards open source no less.

I remember when lawyers historically used WordPerfect for the same reasons. Now, I don’t know the details of how that industry shifted (MS dominance and WP shitting the bed with their GUI versions would be my guess), but it shows that it is possible.

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#66
Hei hei,

I'm working for the XWiki and CryptPad projects, which are integrated in openDesk. Here are a couple links / infos that can be interesting to understand the context of openDesk.

The openDesk project comes initially from an initiative of the Ministry of Interior of Germany in 2021, to build the alternative to Office 365. The project was progressively transferred in 2025 to a state-owned organization, the ZenDis (https://zendis.de), which oversees the global development of openDesk.

The source code is mainly available on https://gitlab.opencode.de/bmi/opendesk, where you will find mirrors of every project which is bundled into openDesk (Nextcloud, Collabora, Element, Univention, XWiki, Jitsi, OpenXchange, CryptPad, OpenProject, …)

There was also a couple public presentations about openDesk at FOSDEM during the past years :

* In 2024 : https://archive.fosdem.org/2024/schedule/event/fosdem-2024-3...

* In 2025 : https://archive.fosdem.org/2025/schedule/event/fosdem-2025-5...

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#67
post #63
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is not a U.S. specific issue. Once you strip away all of the formalities, titles, and ceremonies, you'll realize there's no such thing as international law, at least not in any meaningful sense of the word. The law, by definition is a rule backed up by the use of force, specifically state-sanctioned violence. If you write a law but do not have the ability to use a sufficient amount violence to enforce it when ne…

[flagged]

I feel like this comment ^ was made in bad faith. Providing an accurate description of reality is not an endorsement of that reality, but I'm pretty sure you already know this, and your comment here is more of a rhetorical tool than an addition to the discussion.

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#68
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d love to see pictures. I’d love to drop MS/Google docs for something I can control myself.

But would you be willing to pay for it? Would your company/organization be willing to move?

Absolutely not

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#69
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you tried LibreOffice ( https://www.libreoffice.org/ ) or OnlyOffice ( https://www.onlyoffice.com/desktop )? Both are pretty decent, and free, and also have commercial versions.

MS365/Google docs is something entirely different to the old desktop office suites It's a collaboration tool, with synced storage and file management etc The overlap of a Venn diagram between users of these software is not very large - though there is some (overlap).

And both the products I mentioned also support online collaboration and storage. See LibreOffice Online ( https://www.libreoffice.org/download/libreoffice-online/ ), OnlyOffice Workspace ( https://www.onlyoffice.com/workspace ) and OnlyOffice Enterprise ( https://www.onlyoffice.com/docs-enterprise ). I can't comment how feature compatible these are but alternatives do exist and that's good new for us. (Note that openDesk is based on a fork of LibreOffice Online, which is a commercial variant for those who don't want to bother implementing everything themselves).

Re: ICC ditches Microsoft 365 for openDesk

#70
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That approach is also insane. You’re always going to be vulnerable somewhere and there isn’t a better country to be if you’re in software, cloud services or AI. Not to mention it’s not like Microsoft Execs want to pickup and leave the States either.

Don't need to. Would it be a big deal to hop on a plane to e.g. Switzerland once a year?

Doing that little is effectively the same as doing nothing at all, and they wouldn’t actually be insulated.
Post reply on HN