Live data from Hacker News

Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

about.nike.com

61–70 of 129 posts

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#61

Has anyone 3d printed something similar? Looks doable - motors and servos are really cheap on AliExpress

When Nike was working on the Mags (self-lacing) there were lots of hobby projects to try and build the same thing, but none of them could come close to the finish and integration that Nike could manage with their resources and industrial processes.

These Amplify are pretty complicated:

https://youtu.be/Nz2Y0e7SgFY?t=404

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#62
post #55

> This makes it easier for everyday athletes to walk or run more often, for longer amounts of time, while having more fun — adding movement to their lives, extending their walking commute, or helping them to enjoy the run for another mile or two. The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. Why would you want to extend it?

Because now they might dislike it less (depending on what they dislike). People do more of things they like.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Are you sure? I am talking about 60 and 70 year olds who can ride a non e bike 50+ miles without stopping, but who need an e-bike to ride 50+ miles at the same pace as their younger friends. How is that person not athletic? Sure they aren’t winning any gold medals, but they are still clearly in the top 1% of their age group.

Surgery recovery, too. An older cyclist is going to need surgeries more often than a younger one, and will take much longer to recover. For some guys a high-end electric assist bike is how they stay riding with the A-group while they're recovering.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#64

For those of you who don’t “see the point” of a device like this, what you are failing to see is your own personal use case. The use cases I can see for others are “anyone who might find this useful or fun”. To me, that means 1) people with medically compromised joints who would like to engage in experiences that their bodies don’t currently allow. 2) people who want to challenge themselves by making these joint addi…

I find running incredibly boring, because the scenery changes so damn slowly around you. I would happily put in the same effort for the same time, but go substantially faster to make it more fun. Not sure I would buy this product, but I see more than 0 use for it.

If you go at light speed across the universe, the scenery would also not change, until you collide with something.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#65

For those of you who don’t “see the point” of a device like this, what you are failing to see is your own personal use case. The use cases I can see for others are “anyone who might find this useful or fun”. To me, that means 1) people with medically compromised joints who would like to engage in experiences that their bodies don’t currently allow. 2) people who want to challenge themselves by making these joint addi…

I find running incredibly boring, because the scenery changes so damn slowly around you. I would happily put in the same effort for the same time, but go substantially faster to make it more fun. Not sure I would buy this product, but I see more than 0 use for it.

Getting off topic but this is exactly why, after never running for fun in my life, I got into cycling (a hobby that admittedly can easily turn expensive even if it doesn't have to).

Instead of running 10km in an hour, I could bike from Silicon Valley to the ocean and back in 3-4 hours, and have views over city, hills, oceans, suburbia, etc.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#66
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I find running incredibly boring, because the scenery changes so damn slowly around you. I would happily put in the same effort for the same time, but go substantially faster to make it more fun. Not sure I would buy this product, but I see more than 0 use for it.

If you go at light speed across the universe, the scenery would also not change, until you collide with something.

When you collide with something at light speed, you become the scenery (and the former scenery is no more), no?

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#67
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you sure? I am talking about 60 and 70 year olds who can ride a non e bike 50+ miles without stopping, but who need an e-bike to ride 50+ miles at the same pace as their younger friends. How is that person not athletic? Sure they aren’t winning any gold medals, but they are still clearly in the top 1% of their age group.

Surgery recovery, too. An older cyclist is going to need surgeries more often than a younger one, and will take much longer to recover. For some guys a high-end electric assist bike is how they stay riding with the A-group while they're recovering.

Other than ego, what's forcing people recovering from surgery to ride with the A-group?

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#68
post #55

> This makes it easier for everyday athletes to walk or run more often, for longer amounts of time, while having more fun — adding movement to their lives, extending their walking commute, or helping them to enjoy the run for another mile or two. The people I know who run all do it for the exercise, not because they like the running. Why would you want to extend it?

"If one could run without getting tired I don't think one would often want to do anything else" -C.S. Lewis, The Last Battle

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#69

For those of you who don’t “see the point” of a device like this, what you are failing to see is your own personal use case. The use cases I can see for others are “anyone who might find this useful or fun”. To me, that means 1) people with medically compromised joints who would like to engage in experiences that their bodies don’t currently allow. 2) people who want to challenge themselves by making these joint addi…

> 1) people with medically compromised joints who would like to engage in experiences that their bodies don’t currently allow.

They say:

> Engineered to augment natural lower leg and ankle movement

Meanwhile, most people who can't walk/run as they would like have issues from their knees upward.

Worse, having heavier lower leg means more strain on the upper leg.

Yes, there's probably a narrow niche of people with lower leg only issues that can be helped by this device, but most people have issues upward ; and this device have the potential to create issues upward on people not yet concerned by them.

Re: Project Amplify: Powered footwear for running and walking

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would like to have something like this if it helped me with e.g. shin splints, or similar, because I really love running, but I tend to overdo it and I don't have any other options than asphalt to run on. Not sure if this one would be good for shin splits though. I guess this could potentially just be a fun thing to run a bit faster, but that alone wouldn't be worth it for me. But if it allowed me to balance where…

I was going to comment the same thing, rather than push off harder, I'd hope it help brace for impact and relieve some of the weaker muscles. Yes, I should perhaps be doing strength training, but I have limited hours to exercise and I'd prefer to spend them running rather than training so that eventually I could be running. Another thing that happens is that your technique gets worse during longer runs, making you mo…

Off topic, but for what it's worth I'm getting myself a rowing machine to try and alleviate my running cravings, especially as winter is coming. I'm not sure if it will be able to reproduce the feelings I get from running as I haven't done rowing enough, but running seems to be the only thing I've found that puts me into this flow state. Cycling is too limited, legs only, HR doesn't get high enough, so hopefully rowing is better due to it being full body. Rowing won't be outside and I won't be physically moving around so that may be the downside. But the metrics to achieve should be much more consistent and comparable compared to if there's many weather changes otherwise, so looking forward to seeing progress there.
Post reply on HN