Live data from Hacker News

AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

theguardian.com

61–70 of 222 posts

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#61

I was thinking about it, because wife was telling me story from work, where a woman was scammed with AI generated stuff and her colleague was a little too nonchalant about it ( 'it is on her to do her due diligence' ). And it made me annoyed. How can you possibly make due diligence when everyone around you is incentivized to lie? We do have a concept of fraud, but advertising seems to be able to move around its edges…

You should be distrustful of every emotion generated by a mass media campaign. They're all artificial, and generated for the benefit of the person running the campaign, not you.

It's still possible to function, it's just that you have to go out and seek information, and usually seek information through channels where the organization is not delivering it to you. Every non-profit files a Form 990 with the IRS, and every public company files a form 10-Q/K with the SEC. There's a wealth of information there for figuring out what the company is doing, but they usually like to obfuscate it in some extremely boring text and financial figures, because they want you to buy into the narrative they deliver to the press and not the facts they deliver to the government. They usually will not outright lie on these, though, because doing so is a crime that can put the CEO, CFO, and Board of Directors in jail.

Same for consumer stuff. Ruthlessly seek out back-channel information about products, whether it's word-of-mouth from friends, online reviews (though these are increasingly easily gamed these days), product tests from independent organizations (though again, many companies provide free products to review in exchange for favorable reviews), etc. I've found that keeping an online subscription to Consumer Reports has been well worth it because they're one of the few review sites where you pay them to review, the company doesn't pay them to get reviewed. Advertisements are worthless; treat them as such. Same goes for random cold calls; it's probably a scam, unless you can corroborate it otherwise.

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#62
post #25

I have suspected that I have seen some of these for Palestine in recent months. Not saying this has any implication on the broader reporting of it but… shit we’re really kind of screwed if media starts portraying everything via fictitious dramatization imagery. Especially on social media.

Doesn't have to involve any AI. I had door-to-door campaigners the other month asking to donate to some charity (probably Red Cross) to help with hunger in Palestine. They haven't meant to shoot at IDF to stop the blockade of aid, just to buy more of it since it was in the news and they needed to top up their budget. That's just how they work.

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#63

I was thinking about it, because wife was telling me story from work, where a woman was scammed with AI generated stuff and her colleague was a little too nonchalant about it ( 'it is on her to do her due diligence' ). And it made me annoyed. How can you possibly make due diligence when everyone around you is incentivized to lie? We do have a concept of fraud, but advertising seems to be able to move around its edges…

TBF, I just assume everyone is lying (either first hand or second) and its on them to prove to me they're not. Hasn't failed me yet.

I assume you're telling the truth.

(assuming everyone's lying until proven otherwise sounds like a miserable existence)

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#64
>While it is hard to quantify the prevalence of the AI-generated images, Alenichev and others say their use is on the rise, driven by concerns over consent and cost.

Although I agree that using AI-generated poverty porn is repulsive on many levels, I think there is a valid consent and privacy issue if using actual photos of real people in these circumstances.

A picture of a real person, especially a child who is being victimized by poverty and/or abuse is now being victimized twice.

In this case, AI could be used judiciously to alter the persons face/body and other identifiers to protect their identity, in the same way that print journalism changes names and other identifiers in text. I think this would be ethical as long as properly marked as having been altered and why.

Of course this does not address the motives of the company behind the ad, but it would at least provide increased transparency and privacy protections.

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#66
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nobody is saying it’s broadly ok to fake images otherwise. It’s pretty fucked up to, say, inject tragedy into narratives by showing victims as emancipated when they’re not. Or altering racial profiles to fit a narrative. It may not pop out as particularly noteworthy in a new age of fake imagery though.

s/emancipated/emaciated/ ?

Autocorrect, yes.

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#67
post #25

I have suspected that I have seen some of these for Palestine in recent months. Not saying this has any implication on the broader reporting of it but… shit we’re really kind of screwed if media starts portraying everything via fictitious dramatization imagery. Especially on social media.

> if media starts portraying everything via fictitious dramatization

let me do one nit picky correction

"does so in a a way even more efficient at manipulating our brains"

because a lot of media, especially social media, already do so. Just currently by using unrelated stock photos, photos from different "incididents" etc.

e.g. even on supposedly reputable news channels it's not rare to find the background images of completely unrelated incidents when they don't have any fitting "correct" images, and then maybe some small *note in some corner. Or not because didn't even notice.

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#68
post #19

> “It saddens me that the fight for more ethical representation of people experiencing poverty now extends to the unreal,” she said. This is an odd way of saying "people aren't aware of poverty amongst white people".

[flagged]

Gatekeeping from an account created less than 10 years ago? Wild!

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#69
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> We do have a concept of fraud We only do have such a concept when it's about an individual lying to a company for profit. When companies lie to individuals it's just business as usual, or worst-case scenario a "mistake" that the company pinky-promises will not happen again.

[flagged]

[dead]

Re: AI-generated 'poverty porn' fake images being used by aid agencies

#70
post #34

It’s really showing the real picture of all the aid agencies. They aim for your money. That’s the single purpose. Because they can’t provide photo documentation of they work on the site where apparently the aid happened. So sad. And many people fall for this scam.

It’s true, governments should have much more responsibility to provide aid internally and internationally so haphazard charity isn’t required for humans to take care of one another.
Post reply on HN