Live data from Hacker News

Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

github.com

61–70 of 72 posts

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#61
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why not just sign the social.org file and publish it as social.asc or something?

Right. But I would still prefer markdown file format, so I could simply open it in web browser. :)

Sure. But the point of this system is you use it from emacs.

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#62
post #34

If this takes off and becomes mainstream, will you show some inclusiveness towards poor people like me who will dare editing their org social files with an editor like Kate?

While an interesting idea, it's kind of niche. I somehow doubt that this will become mainstream , even among techies.

Oh yeah, I was being humorous, I don't think this can take off neither.

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#63
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because that would require leaving emacs, I guess. Just a guess. I'm a Vim user so unlike emacs users I do know how to shower but like emacs users I can't manage to carry a conversation with someone in person. We only think partly alike.

> Because that would require leaving emacs, I guess. Yeah, but if this kind of social network was hosted on Vim, nobody would be able to exit it I guess.

Frankly, you'd need to make vim even harder to exit if you want to compete with the big players in this space.

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#65
post #2

Reminds me of .plan files from back in the day.

Exactly - the finger protocol with .plan/.project files was essentially a proto-social network where users could publish status updates on Unix systems, and org-social follows that same decentralized, text-file-based philosophy but with modern tooling.

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Org mode is far more structured than markdown. Structured enough that so you can naturally store data in, and easily access/edit it later. Whenever someone tries to do something similar in markdown, they have to invent an extension of markdown to do it.

Yes markdown is simply about formatting text. Org is a data format.

Markdown really isn't a specific thing with all the incompatible implementations, many of which allow embedding HTML (i.e. "whatever happens to be supported by current version of Chrome" is also part of those Markdown formats).

If you pick one of the more sane (or at least less insane) variants of Markdown, like Pandoc's variant, you do get at least some ways to embed data in reliable ways. It also makes it easy to export and style documents and write your own filters that can make use of the data in various ways. In general I prefer to use ORG-mode, but for some purposes I use Pandoc Markdown instead.

https://pandoc.org/demo/example33/8-pandocs-markdown.html

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#67
I am a heavy ORG-mode user, but this looks like a more complex variant of a gemlog. A gemlog is just a gemtext file with a list of links to posts, including the date of each post in the link text. Then each post is just a gemtext file. Gemtext being the extremely simple, line-based, format that is used for making Gemini sites. A gemlog is basically a blog that is also its own RSS feed, without any of the complexities of things on the real web.

It is never going to go mainstream, but there is a critical mass of people using it and it is probably for the best if it never grows much beyond that.

https://geminiprotocol.net/docs/gemtext-specification.gmi

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#68
post #36

Sounds a bit like the idea that Bluesky started out with. I don't really get why specifically org mode though, sounds like you could be doing the same thing with a simple Markdown file. And while you're at it, why not just use HTML and read your friends' blogs in the browser?

You could do the same thing with a Markdown file, but I wouldn't call it simpler than Org. Maybe by simple you meant "familiar to more people"?

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#69
post #37

Finally a social network that only true nerdy people will ever join, I might just finally pick up emacs again.

What about Mastodon? (I'm, like, 80% joking)

Anyone can get past a dog, nobody f$;&&) with a lion.

Anyone can get on mastodon, nobody f&)@) with emacs.

But seriously the barrier to entry is high enough you will only get the true geeks.

Re: Org-social is a decentralized social network that runs on Org Mode

#70
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about Mastodon? (I'm, like, 80% joking)

Anyone can get past a dog, nobody f$;&&) with a lion. Anyone can get on mastodon, nobody f&)@) with emacs. But seriously the barrier to entry is high enough you will only get the true geeks.

A barrier-to-entry isn't necessary if no non-geeks want to join in the first place (which is, IME, true of Mastodon). Mastodon has successfully made itself a place that no non-geek would ever _want_ to spend time on anyway, so no barriers-to-entry are necessary to maintain that state.

(You can decide for yourself whether this comment is praising or criticizing Mastodon)

Post reply on HN