Live data from Hacker News

Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

rogerebert.com

61–70 of 73 posts

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#61

The first season was excellent, and then in the 2nd season they did ruin lots of the story lines with just lame choices, and then the ending went completely downhill for me. It pissed me off, just like GoT. There was this other series called Murderbot which had some similarities in the setting of the story. It was not that great compared to the 1st season of Raised by Wolves, but it was consistent throughout the whol…

The murder bot books are a bit silly from the get go, so the show leaned into the campy vibe to sell the comedic aspect. As someone who loves the book, I think the show is a 10/10 for capturing the feeling. Though if you where expecting as more serious scifi I can see why you think it's of inferior quality.

> As someone who loves the book... 10/10 for capturing the feeling

As someone who read all the books (fun vacation pop read), I think gendering the murderbot was a significant loss.

I also think going with an Eddie Redmayne (https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fpreview.redd.... or https://starschanges.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/eddie-re...) or (given wardrobe) even an Asia Argento (https://www.shutterstock.com/editorial/image-editorial/MfT7Q... or https://todaymix.ru/uploads/posts/2020-01/azija-ardzhento-59...) could have worked to maintain the conceit.

It's hard to have no gender reveal for 7 books, but it makes the introspection so much more interesting.

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#62

This is one I really didn't like. It's just too weird for me. It thrns my stomach to even think about it. Really dusgusting somehow. I say this as a big fan of horror and sci-fi and Alien* in particular.

Why? Is it the androids raising children or something else?

I don't know how to explain, just some visceral ick factor I've never had before.

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#63
post #55
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If this is true, why couldn't Bezos bankroll the show to maintain its quality?

Because it was worth a little but not a lot to him? I'll pay $20 for an audiobook, but I won't pay $100 for one.

One might be surprised by the proportion math of one's $20 as % of one's earnings or net worth versus his, and how far the same % could go.

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#64
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it was worth a little but not a lot to him? I'll pay $20 for an audiobook, but I won't pay $100 for one.

One might be surprised by the proportion math of one's $20 as % of one's earnings or net worth versus his, and how far the same % could go.

[deleted]

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#65
post #51

Cool show, weird plot, but what totally ruined for me was... Travis Fimmel. IMO this guy has zero range. Always the same lazy, drunk-ish style since, I don't know, Vikings. Ragnar in Kattegat, Ragnar in Azeroth, Ragnar in space, Ragnar in Dune.

https://ragnantmedia.com/heartfelt-farewell-travis-fimmel-bi...

Oh wow. I didn't know. Praise Sol I guess?

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#66
post #27

"Ridley Scott directed the first two episodes of the series, and using his name as part of the marketing is a fair move (even if it was created by Aaron Guzikowski, who wrote Prisoners.)" Interesting observation made by Nick on www.rogerebert.com

Ridley Scott can be terrible with stories (or picks projects with poor stories), as long as individual scenes are great.

I've had trouble watching some of his work to their end, there was just so much WTF and random stuff.

His name on a project is for me a signal to carefully check some reviews before committing.

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#67
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If this is true, why couldn't Bezos bankroll the show to maintain its quality?

Because billionaires can't love anything more than they love money.

Sounds like you're more obsessed with money than he is. He spent a billion dollars on a terrible Tolkein show.

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Look it up on justwatch.

I did, it’s just blank. Don’t think I’ve ever seen that before. https://www.justwatch.com/us/tv-show/raised-by-wolves-2020

Looks like Blu-ray/DVD physical media are still being sold.

Re: Raised by Wolves Is Original Sci-Fi at Its Most Polarizing (2020)

#69
post #51

Cool show, weird plot, but what totally ruined for me was... Travis Fimmel. IMO this guy has zero range. Always the same lazy, drunk-ish style since, I don't know, Vikings. Ragnar in Kattegat, Ragnar in Azeroth, Ragnar in space, Ragnar in Dune.

Agreed. I think the overacting suited his character, but it got old very fast. Then I tried to watch Vikings, and was put off in the same way. I think he could have potential if directed correctly, but so far he has been overacting with the same kind of psychotic swagger in every role I've seen him in.
Post reply on HN