Live data from Hacker News

Google's widespread tracking across the web

simpleanalytics.com

61–70 of 108 posts

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#61
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

how can you make it illegal?? >make a new law >they just move elsewhere how??? tell me

You just tell Congress that the data brokers have all the rights to sell our data to Chinese data brokers. Maybe that will change their mind.

Is tiktok still up and running?

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#62

In the case of this particular website, perhaps Google tracks you less, but you get tracked by ` https://test-v1.adriaan.com ` — whatever that means. 9: https://test-v1.adriaan.com/script-v1.js " async> https://test-v1.adriaan.com/simple.gif?type=event&hostname=t... Gecko/20100101 Firefox/128.0&version=test-2025-04-22-v2&event=onload&path=/blog/google-is-tracking-you-even-when-you-use-duck-duck-go&referrer=&session_i…

Ha, nice find! I'm the Adriaan in adriaan.com. I'm testing some new script features that might improve deliverability. It's not sending any personal data. I use another domain to have the least effect of ad-blockers.

> Ha, nice find! I'm the Adriaan in adriaan.com. I'm testing some new script features that might improve deliverability. It's not sending any personal data. I use another domain to have the least effect of ad-blockers.

You are sending the user agent, path, referrer, a session id + the IP (which is automatically sent) to your personal server and also using a different domain to track users who have ad blockers installed. Even Google Analytics does not use random domain names to track adblock users (yet).

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#63
post #57
post #24

User tracking only exists because it generates money. We should ban the entire practice. No more targeted ads (with very little exceptions).

Then something else will replace it. To make the same amount of money.

Could we make that thing perhaps Being Very Nice?

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#64
post #2

This title is highly misleading, implying that Google tracks DuckDuckGo searches directly, which isn’t true. It also reinforces a conspiracy theory that we’re owned by Google, which also of course isn’t true. Kindly please change it to be more accurate about Google analytics and other Google trackers on websites you may visit. We’ve been sounding the alarm about Google analytics, tag manager, and other Google tracker…

Yeah. This is simple fear mongering to sell its own analytics product.

It's simple fear mongering and aimed at the wrong audience. Companies want people tracked to improve their ads and have a higher reach. The people who are being tracked can't exactly do much about what tracking system a website uses.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#66
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ha, nice find! I'm the Adriaan in adriaan.com. I'm testing some new script features that might improve deliverability. It's not sending any personal data. I use another domain to have the least effect of ad-blockers.

> Ha, nice find! I'm the Adriaan in adriaan.com. I'm testing some new script features that might improve deliverability. It's not sending any personal data. I use another domain to have the least effect of ad-blockers. You are sending the user agent, path, referrer, a session id + the IP (which is automatically sent) to your personal server and also using a different domain to track users who have ad blockers install…

So the correct title must be: "SimpleAnalytics track you TWICE when you're reading about Google tracking you (even when using DuckDuckGo)."

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#67
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

how you can ban the practice??? in what way ?

You ban it by making it illegal.

Rolling through stop signs is illegal, but people do it all the time without penalty. It's not enough to simply make something illegal. You also have to have groups empowered to enforce the law and dole out punishments heavy enough to act as a deterrent.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#69
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is the MAC collected?

It isn't, parent is making stuff up. Browsers do not offer an interface that is exposing that information. And remote servers are outside of your local network and thus cannot see these values, either.

That's true for browsers, but Google controls both the Android OS and Google Play Services, giving them access to hardware identifiers on Android smartphones. Given the broad adoption of Android devices and the potential to correlate data, this is not a case of "making stuff up." Even if your MAC address is spoofed/randomized, the remaining data points are still sufficient to track you.

Re: Google's widespread tracking across the web

#70

Let's face reality: as soon as you browse the internet, you will be tracked and identified. Here are just a few data points used for fingerprinting: IP address, User-Agent string, Referrer URL, Requested URL, Language, Locale, Screen resolution, Time zone, System time, Installed fonts, Installed plugins, Cookie data, Browser fingerprint, Canvas fingerprint, WebGL fingerprint, AudioContext fingerprint, Mouse movements…

This list manages to be mostly correct while still spreading FUD. These can all be tracked, but the threat actors are very much uncoordinated in exploiting this info, and much of it (especially things like keystroke and mouse fingerprinting) is expensive to track en masse.

Just using Firefox with uBlock, no history, and privacy settings on max, through a somewhat trustworthy VPN like Mullvad will make your data mostly useless. Yeah, "they" could still catch you in a million ways, but if your threat model revolves mostly around surveillance capitalism you'll just be too much of a hassle to matter

Post reply on HN