Live data from Hacker News

My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

old.reddit.com

61–70 of 103 posts

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#61
post #28

Advertising is a virus. It will take over all ecosystems.

If it wasn’t effective it would go away. Enough people out there are actually clicking on these things to be profitable. Who are they? I’ve literally never clicked on an ad in my life. I’m pretty sure no one I know has also (I hope) so who are these people clicking and paying.

I don’t think OP is saying it’s not effective. It can be a virus and effective. The point is more about the consequences.

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#62
If true, yet another reason why I'm glad I ditched Prime Video.

I noticed that FireTV Sticks now autoplay ads on launch without an option to disable that. For such setups, I'm likely to replace them with Apple TV (not perfect, but better) that aren't naked ad-delivery platforms like they're trying to copy something from a dystopian sci-fi movie.

Also, it wouldn't work on my main setup because it uses a soundbar that's only controllable by an IR remote. I would be willing to bet that it sends an HDMI CEC signal to unmute stereo receiver volume levels too.

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#63

Advertising is a virus. It will take over all ecosystems.

Isn't it a subset of the problem of "excessive, continuous profit maximization is a virus", and advertising is just one obvious manifestation of it? Maybe we need social ventures along the entire stack of hardware, software, and cloud platforms? And then group buys for licenses to and streaming of media?

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#65

I'm surprised we haven't seen the "AI-powered" uBlock Origin of video yet. Not blocking by the web request but rather by analyzing the video signal itself. Or even a nice appliance-tier solution. I want to buy an HDMI splitter that when it sees an ad coming through Input 1, switches to Input 2. Switches back to Input 1 when its over. For folks still stuck with cable TV this is Nobel Prize territory.

These SBCs like Radxa ROCK 5 have HDMI in and out, and a good amount of processing power. If it weren't for HDCP, we might see some OSS solutions in the next couple of years.

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#66

I'm surprised we haven't seen the "AI-powered" uBlock Origin of video yet. Not blocking by the web request but rather by analyzing the video signal itself. Or even a nice appliance-tier solution. I want to buy an HDMI splitter that when it sees an ad coming through Input 1, switches to Input 2. Switches back to Input 1 when its over. For folks still stuck with cable TV this is Nobel Prize territory.

SponsorBlock[1] does a pretty good job of skipping inline adverts and similar stuff on YouTube. It is, however, crowdsourced rather than using machine learning (so far as I am aware).

[1] https://sponsor.ajay.app/

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#67
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ProTip: If you cancel prime then you don't see any prime adverts. I love paying for content. I'm not going to support double-dipping.

I did the math last year, and with the discount on things I buy from Amazon cancelling Prime would cost me hundreds of dollars per year. So for me, cancelling Prime wouldn't send the signal that I'd want it to. As far as not purchasing from Amazon to being with, nobody else is even close, sadly.

The prime discounts are fake. Cost compare to Walmart. Their shipping is also free and fast. I hate Walmart, but I hate them slightly less than Amazon.

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#68
post #29
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Same way that people refer to a house under mortgage as “their” home. Edit: How about a rental in a building with ads in the elevators?

They do own the house. The mortgage holder has a security interest in the property.

Your idea of ownership is simplistic. Around me, the local government owns the home as can be easily found out if you don't pay your annual rent called "property tax".

Even if you are not a homeower, you still are not free and clear...

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I did the math last year, and with the discount on things I buy from Amazon cancelling Prime would cost me hundreds of dollars per year. So for me, cancelling Prime wouldn't send the signal that I'd want it to. As far as not purchasing from Amazon to being with, nobody else is even close, sadly.

The prime discounts are fake. Cost compare to Walmart. Their shipping is also free and fast. I hate Walmart, but I hate them slightly less than Amazon.

I have tried that in the recent past and not found that to be the case. There were no obvious wins in the things I get regularly, and quite a lot of things I get on Amazon just aren't available on Walmart, or if they are they are quite hard to find. For example, a recent purchase of "Fresh Roast" decaf whole bean coffee is over 10% more expensive on Walmart ($27.95 vs $24.25). A Milwaukee track saw blade is $58 vs $37.

As you say, not that Walmart is better than Amazon, but it would be nice to have some more competition to Amazon.

Re: My Amazon TV Now Unmutes Itself During Prime Video Commercial Breaks

#70

I'm surprised we haven't seen the "AI-powered" uBlock Origin of video yet. Not blocking by the web request but rather by analyzing the video signal itself. Or even a nice appliance-tier solution. I want to buy an HDMI splitter that when it sees an ad coming through Input 1, switches to Input 2. Switches back to Input 1 when its over. For folks still stuck with cable TV this is Nobel Prize territory.

Nice for sure. Until then: pay for sub, never use it, grab content from ‘other sources’.

Apps like https://overseerr.dev make it incredibly simple for household members to request content.

Post reply on HN