Live data from Hacker News

Switzerland Makes Open Source Software Mandatory for Public Sector

news.itsfoss.com

61–67 of 67 posts

Re: Switzerland Makes Open Source Software Mandatory for Public Sector

#61
post #53
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have an example of something FOSS can't do?

Photoshop vs Gimp for example

Yeah, sure GIMP is not in the same class as Photoshop. How about GIMP vs. Paint?

GIMP is not the only open source image editor.

Re: Switzerland Makes Open Source Software Mandatory for Public Sector

#62
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>they also started switching to Linux for their infrastructure after the war, After the war? To which do you refer?

How many wars are currently in Europe?

I'm always in awe on how petty and pedantic some people can be in the comments here, acting confused and pretending to misunderstand you out of context, if you aren't 100% verbose with your statements as if they're context unaware of current world events. They're worse than LLMs.

Re: Switzerland Makes Open Source Software Mandatory for Public Sector

#64
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What if a third party non-open source product does something that FOSS can’t do or is dramatically behind on? That's almost the best side effect: in a place where open source is mandatory, they will have to fund the missing features and it will be available to everyone, once and for all. If everyone does that, we rapidly get great software, sharing the costs, very efficiently, and it's all open source. The alternat…

> in a place where open source is mandatory, they will have to fund the missing features and it will be available to everyone, once and for all Or the majority of their users will suffer with substandard products, while highly paid or influential users will get exceptions to the policy so they can use the software they want.

How is it relevant to open source? Today, users already suffer with whatever substandard product was chosen and enforced. Except it's also probably proprietary.

Re: Switzerland Makes Open Source Software Mandatory for Public Sector

#65
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> in a place where open source is mandatory, they will have to fund the missing features and it will be available to everyone, once and for all Or the majority of their users will suffer with substandard products, while highly paid or influential users will get exceptions to the policy so they can use the software they want.

How is it relevant to open source? Today, users already suffer with whatever substandard product was chosen and enforced. Except it's also probably proprietary.

[deleted]

Re: Switzerland Makes Open Source Software Mandatory for Public Sector

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First approach (by Swiss Post) was rejected by swiss citizens. https://sarahjamielewis.com/evoting/

That's e-voting and that was an absolute disaster. This is E-id which we voted on not to have the private sector operate. The current solution proposed are quite good, the biggest issue that remains is that currently the law is not clear who can require the ID and this should be tightened so I don't need to show my ID to use a pay toilet.

Who issues the id?
Post reply on HN