Live data from Hacker News

Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

engadget.com

61–70 of 186 posts

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#61
post #29
post #8

I wonder if there’s a “git over BitTorrent”. Having a cryptographically signed (by authors, not by GitHub) and fully open source git hosting network would be a boom for FOSS security in general.

As much as it pains me to say this this might be a good use of blockchain

Blockchain is just a slow database. What you want is a peer to peer system which actually has peers instead of a couple super nodes and ephemeral drive-by clients.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#62
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As much as it pains me to say this this might be a good use of blockchain

Care to explain? If you just mean verified tree, git already is that.

I think he means uncensorable or at least very very hard to censor.

The problem is it could be very expensive. Think NFT but the metadata is the source code of the emulator. You're not removing that from the blockchain, ever. It also needs to be a popular blockchain, like ETH, BTC, SOL or whatever people still use today.

There are "coins" where your stake is disk space but if it's not a widespread thing it just dies off (conway GoL style)

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#63
post #40
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But which law makes it illegal to circumvent such systems? DMCA section 1201

You are right, it says it right there: No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201 Can the emulators remove the circumvention code to avoid the DMCA takedown?

[deleted]

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#64
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As much as it pains me to say this this might be a good use of blockchain

Care to explain? If you just mean verified tree, git already is that.

I think he's referring to the distributed portion of a blockchain. A centralized github-type for profit business is required to respond to these takedown requests. Nintendo's lawyers would need to go after every individual node hosting this vc blockchain.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#65
post #40
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But which law makes it illegal to circumvent such systems? DMCA section 1201

You are right, it says it right there: No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201 Can the emulators remove the circumvention code to avoid the DMCA takedown?

Isn't the whole emulator a circumvention? It circumvents the hardware which "effectively controls access to a work", which is the console itself.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#66
post #33
post #30

Why are emulators illegal? I understand that they are associated with piracy because people play pirates games on them. But it’s like banning BitTorrent because it allows you to pirate, or Windows because you can play pirates games on it as well. The article mentions that emulators “illegally circumvent Nintendo’s technological protection measures and run illegal copies of Switch games.”. But which law makes it illeg…

> But which law makes it illegal to circumvent such systems? DMCA section 1201

Overriding DMCA it's legal for interoperation purposes.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#67

Nintendo is in an interesting position whereby they are actually selling emulators as a product to this day. Which gives them more of a leg to stand on in these sorts of efforts, regardless of whether or not I personally agree.

I would say the opposite, it gives them less of a leg to stand since they cannot say that there's never any justification for emulation anymore like they said in the past.

That’s like saying I can’t make photocopies of my own ID because I’ve said in the past that identity thieves shouldn’t make photocopies of my ID.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#68
post #60
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or we can simply have a git hoster which is not in the US and as such is not impacted by DCMA

US copyright tends to be less restrictive and more relaxed than many other countries.

Not true as you can see here.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#69
post #40
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But which law makes it illegal to circumvent such systems? DMCA section 1201

You are right, it says it right there: No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201 Can the emulators remove the circumvention code to avoid the DMCA takedown?

Could "effectively controls access" be attacked here? The purpose of the hardware is not to control access.

Re: Nintendo blitzes GitHub with over 8k emulator-related DMCA takedowns

#70
post #40
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> But which law makes it illegal to circumvent such systems? DMCA section 1201

You are right, it says it right there: No person shall circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a work protected under this title. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201 Can the emulators remove the circumvention code to avoid the DMCA takedown?

Not even for research purposes?
Post reply on HN