Live data from Hacker News

Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

old.reddit.com

61–70 of 96 posts

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#61
post #27

VLC player paired with a network share does pretty much everything I need to watch local media. I have a Jellyfin instance, and I do like it, but I often find myself falling back to VLC for one reason or another.

And it works on locked down hardware too, Apple TV for example. Use that for a long time and it's perfect

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#62
post #27

VLC player paired with a network share does pretty much everything I need to watch local media. I have a Jellyfin instance, and I do like it, but I often find myself falling back to VLC for one reason or another.

Versions of VLC for "weaker" devices like Fire TV do not open network shares sadly.

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#63
post #25

Is this perhaps people who don’t have port forwarding setup and are costing Plex money on their proxy?

Plex limits their proxy to 1mbps for free users, 2mbps for paid.

If this were a significant cost I can't see why they wouldn't provide the option to pay for more bandwidth, or make relay a metered feature.

https://support.plex.tv/articles/216766168-accessing-a-serve...

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#64
post #29
post #7

I keep both Plex and Jellyfin installed on my server with the same media. Plex is easier to navigate for my family than Jellyfin (specifically their respective Roku apps). But the way that Plex is pushing their monetization with ads and now rentals, and now shenanigans like this, I feel it's time to fully migrate to Jellyfin. I should learn Roku development so I can contribute to their app...

I’ve never seen an ad on Plex. Never saw anything about rentals.

Yeah, like the sibling comment said, I meant ads for Plex's own services. Whenever they rollout these new "features" I see them on my home screen or in the navigation and have to turn it off. I'm more frustrated in how aggressive they are in pushing these new avenues of revenue; I just want to watch my own media and nothing else.

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's a good setup to run jellyfin on. I currently run it on a Linux desktop. I tried running it on a raspberry pi, but it felt like it was struggling. Did I expect too much?

Jellyfin is fine if you direct stream only, but any form of transcoding will kill your server. It is a bit hard to get other people to download the desktop Jellyfin Media Player or Infuse on iOS, and I don't think Android has a version of the app with massive codec support.

What do you mean? My Jellyfin Server is transcoding movies and is not dying, at all.

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#66
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just wanted to write that I'm glad that I'm using Jellyfin at home :) No unnecessary online accounts, just "my" media on my server.

What's a good setup to run jellyfin on. I currently run it on a Linux desktop. I tried running it on a raspberry pi, but it felt like it was struggling. Did I expect too much?

I'm running it in a docker container on a small server with a GTX 1050Ti and a AMD Ryzen 3 3200G with 16GB RAM.

Was more complicated than I thought to initially pass the GPU through to the Container, but it runs fine and lets me watch movies on any device I own.

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#67

I know people with large networks of people paying $10/month for access to pirated content. I have my own Jellyfin server with pirated content for myself and mother, but I don't feel good charging money for "stolen" things. Stealing to eat is one thing, stealing bread to sell for profit is different.

I mostly agree and wouldn't do it myself, but as a consumer what are the odds this is just a better experience? All content, very few restrictions

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#68
post #55

This is why it's better to control your software. Firms change over time and your interests are likely to diverge from theirs. This is _especially_ true when we're talking about media-related software which is always contentious in terms of copyright. Jellyfin isn't as feature-rich or polished as Plex, but I rest assured knowing that I'm the one who controls my installation.

I have 3 paid subscription services (Disney+, Prime and Netflix). But most of the time we just use Jellyfin. It's just better UX, even if it lacks polish. Stuff is in predictable places, in one app. I don't need to scroll past 2 full screens of generated lists with suggested content to get to my personal hand made watch list. I'm fully ready to drop subscription streaming and go back to buying DVD or Bluray box sets…

I'm the same way. I want a digital shelf, not an ever-changing curation.

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#69

This is why it's better to control your software. Firms change over time and your interests are likely to diverge from theirs. This is _especially_ true when we're talking about media-related software which is always contentious in terms of copyright. Jellyfin isn't as feature-rich or polished as Plex, but I rest assured knowing that I'm the one who controls my installation.

Unfortunately I've had nothing but headaches with Jellyfin's media streamer. I'm doing a local Jellyfin to their AppleTV client, and it is just glitchy as heck. Plex is almost as good as Netflix's player, meaning completely reliable. Jellyfin's server maybe good, but their clients leave a lot to be desired. The main problem with Jellyfin is that there isn't much money to pay for development. Open Source is great, but…

I've had very few problems (though I'm using an NVIDIA shield), but yeah that polish is what made Plex appealing at first.

Re: Plex Accounts Getting Disabled

#70

Speaking of Plex alternatives, does anyone have a great alternative to Plexamp (Plex's local music player)? [1] [1]: https://www.plex.tv/plexamp/

What's wrong with Plexamp? I used it for a few months a year or two ago and I loved it.

You need a Plex Server to run it (unless I'm missing something).
Post reply on HN