Live data from Hacker News

YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

youtube.com

61–70 of 90 posts

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#61
post #18

I recently searched for a homey cooking recipe and YouTube pulled up a video titled something like 'Tearful father says goodbye to daughter before gang assassination', with a correspondingly horrifying thumbnail. I responded by logging out, deleting the cookies for my YouTube container, and adding the YouTube domain to my adblock. My use of YouTube is now restricted to RSS feeds for channels I like, redirected to an…

> 'Tearful father says goodbye to daughter before gang assassination' I’ve had this one suggested to me multiple times as well for completely unrelated content. It’s not the kind of thing that I watch or would click on even out of curiosity, but YouTube really thinks I should watch it for some reason.

The comical thing to me is when I search, I can't even find the video in question.

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#62
post #6

Life hack, maybe it will help someone out: Add a "before:YYYY" to the search to go back to a simpler time. Eg, "before:2012 python talk" As an experiment open two tabs and compare the results of "python talk" and "before:2012 python talk". The difference is staggering.

Thanks a lot!

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#63
post #55
post #6

Life hack, maybe it will help someone out: Add a "before:YYYY" to the search to go back to a simpler time. Eg, "before:2012 python talk" As an experiment open two tabs and compare the results of "python talk" and "before:2012 python talk". The difference is staggering.

My only complaint about this is that so much of the old stuff has been removed, privated, marked as age restricted, blurred due to refusal to be marked as "for kids"[1] and removing the comment section, or otherwise made inaccessible by their authors. The reason usually being that it's embarassing or otherwise doesn't reflect the uploader's modern persona. A lot of awesome content is missing from the results due to t…

The way YouTube doesn't show you the metadata for removed videos anymore is infuriating. You end up with playlists where you can tell something was removed but not what.

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#66

you get what you pay for, right folks? surely with a youtube premium account you get the premium search experience.

Unfortunately no, I paid for premium for a while believing this, but the experience is exactly the same. Though it's very possible I'm just missing the sarcasm here.

Very possible

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#68

The most frustrating thing about youtube is how it's not smart enough to figure out that I want to watch "XX Part 55" after watching "XX Part 54". It just gives me random other videos on autoplay.

Absolutely -- this seriously seems like it should have been fixed years ago.

And it's not like you need fancy AI to do it. Just a handful of simple heuristics.

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#69
post #9
post #3

I wonder if a distributed attempt to build a complementary index for YouTube could be an answer; wherein users install a browser plugin that captures the results and metadata of a given query or metadata when a video is watched.

This would amount to doing free labor to prop up a trillion dollar company’s subpar product. Then again, YouTube is only barely profitable as-is right? And getting people to switch to a more sustainable paid alternative is a non-starter. So maybe this is the future we deserve

Nobody that would consider using such an index would be browsing YouTube without an ad blocker.

Free labour is how I was downloading YT videos to my unsupported Windows Phone device in 2011.

Post reply on HN