Live data from Hacker News

The Ukraine war is ultimately about Poland

noahpinion.blog

61–63 of 63 posts

Re: The Ukraine war is ultimately about Poland

#61
post #23

I think this is all a bit of an irrelevant academic discussion. If Russia were to cross into Poland, it would essentially pit the world against Russia. If you're on board with the article and believe Putin is on a historically motivated crusade of sorts, and of sound mind, it's difficult to imagine he'd initiate an invasion he has no chance of winning. The fact that Poland can't muster an armed force as sizeable as R…

[dead]

Re: The Ukraine war is ultimately about Poland

#62
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Regime change means your enemies controlling who runs your country Not really. The push has been towards democracy where who runs the country would be decided by the Russian people.

So if a more radical nationalist imperialist than Putin were to win open free elections, do you think NATO would be happy? Not to mention, by all accounts, Putin would probably win fully free elections even today. The opponents he's suppressing or killing are not extremely popular today, they are people who he fears might become popular if left unchecked.

Well, NATO is a defensive alliance and so not too worried if no one is invading anyone. But I think if Russia had a normal democratic situation with freeish press and lack of jailing or killing opponents they would be unlikely to continue the present kind of war which is a terrible deal for ordinary Russians. I remember the faces of the other Russians in the room when Putin announced the invasion and everyone looked horrified but scared to say anything.

Re: The Ukraine war is ultimately about Poland

#63
post #23

I think this is all a bit of an irrelevant academic discussion. If Russia were to cross into Poland, it would essentially pit the world against Russia. If you're on board with the article and believe Putin is on a historically motivated crusade of sorts, and of sound mind, it's difficult to imagine he'd initiate an invasion he has no chance of winning. The fact that Poland can't muster an armed force as sizeable as R…

That sounds copied from a pre 2022 invasion speech?
Post reply on HN