Live data from Hacker News

A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

devblogs.microsoft.com

61–70 of 112 posts

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#61
post #5

Frankly, it is really annoying when developers working at one of the large closed-source platform oligopolists blame their users for trying to work around the deficiencies (or even outright hostile "business model" optimizations) in their software by whatever scant means are left to them: maybe if Microsoft didn't keep removing good functionality and stopped forcing bad "features" on everyone, fewer people would see…

[deleted]

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#62

Maybe large swaths of users wouldn't download enhancement suites if you actually listened to them? It took like 3 years to support the basic feature to "never group tabs" in the Taskbar -- that's been supported by previous versions of windows for decades. That's why I downloaded patches.

[deleted]

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#63
post #42
post #3

Seeing the title and the domain I instantly knew whose blog post this is...

Is it just me? His posts always begin with an interesting technical anecdote and then veer off into boring propaganda with sullies the reputability. It's an intellectual let-down.

That's just you. Raymond Chen is a great programmer and writer, we are lucky to have him.

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#64
post #5

Frankly, it is really annoying when developers working at one of the large closed-source platform oligopolists blame their users for trying to work around the deficiencies (or even outright hostile "business model" optimizations) in their software by whatever scant means are left to them: maybe if Microsoft didn't keep removing good functionality and stopped forcing bad "features" on everyone, fewer people would see…

I disagree strongly. If you start mucking around in the memory of the system, and shit breaks, it's on you and not Microsoft. The amount of effort they put into compatibility is Herculean, and honestly is way above and beyond what is reasonable to expect. It's not their fault that they can't handle every single edge case of programmers going rogue and stomping all over the rest of the system.

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#65
post #6

I know it must be frustrating from Microsoft's standpoint, but those are needed because they keep changing things. Start All Back is one very popular explorer.exe patch that makes the Windows 11 taskbar function a lot like Windows 10. For one thing, it allows you to move the taskbar again. I've also made an explorer.exe in-memory patch to disable flashing taskbar buttons in Windows 10, it injected itself to WndProc a…

[deleted]

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#67
post #6

I know it must be frustrating from Microsoft's standpoint, but those are needed because they keep changing things. Start All Back is one very popular explorer.exe patch that makes the Windows 11 taskbar function a lot like Windows 10. For one thing, it allows you to move the taskbar again. I've also made an explorer.exe in-memory patch to disable flashing taskbar buttons in Windows 10, it injected itself to WndProc a…

Wallpapers can be animated? This is like learning my car can count butterflies. I wonder why such a feature exists but also now feel obligated to hook VLC into the wallpaper function so i can play movies underneath all my other work. Can wallpapers have sound?

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#68
post #5

Frankly, it is really annoying when developers working at one of the large closed-source platform oligopolists blame their users for trying to work around the deficiencies (or even outright hostile "business model" optimizations) in their software by whatever scant means are left to them: maybe if Microsoft didn't keep removing good functionality and stopped forcing bad "features" on everyone, fewer people would see…

The “correct” way to do this would be to check that the surroundings of the code you’re injecting into are as expected, similar to how applying a diff patch file contains lines before/after to synchronize with the text being patched. When confronted with an incompatible change, the extension would just disable itself and not proceed with the patching. I’ve heard of MS Office extensions that function like that and work robustly.

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#69

There is an interview with Raymond Chen where he is trying to defend the reason why they crippled the taskbar with Windows 11 [1]. Watching that I was just thinking NO NO NO - it worked fine for the last 25 years and there can be absolutely no reason why they had to destroy the taskbar now. He deserves every headache he gets with these support requests. Or to quote this comment of the linked article: > There wouldn’t…

Watching the clip, the improvements he's talking about are great and very welcomed. Is this a case of any change being considered bad because you're used to how things are?

This isn't about "change", they just removed some essential functionality that I use daily since 1995.

Besides from being used to it, it is also required for my work to have wide, labeled, ungrouped application buttons instead of icons that are oftentimes barely distinguishable.

Re: A jump into the middle of an instruction from nowhere (2023)

#70

There is an interview with Raymond Chen where he is trying to defend the reason why they crippled the taskbar with Windows 11 [1]. Watching that I was just thinking NO NO NO - it worked fine for the last 25 years and there can be absolutely no reason why they had to destroy the taskbar now. He deserves every headache he gets with these support requests. Or to quote this comment of the linked article: > There wouldn’t…

I wouldn't say it worked "fine" for 25 years. It's still there all the time taking screen space. You can hide it but it will re-appear if you move your mouse to the now cleared screen real estate. The reason I need taskbar hacks is that I want one feature they never added: hide the taskbar permanently until I explicitly ask to see it (for example by pressing a Windows Key). For me it doesn't matter much if the taskba…

Maybe this works better for you: https://www.autohotkey.com/boards/viewtopic.php?p=371022#p37...

The nice thing on Windows is that the UI can be uniformly manipulated that way.

Post reply on HN