Live data from Hacker News

Gold prices are hitting records

wsj.com

61–70 of 87 posts

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#61
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

BTC has drastically outperformed gold over last 10 years but is also extremely volatile https://inflationchart.com/gold-in-btc/?logarithmic=1

Zoom out a bunch on the gold price chart and you'll see it is volatile as well.

If you have to zoom out to see it though, it's by definition less volatile, surely?

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#62
post #3
post #2

If you adjust for inflation, there have been 3 periods in the last 50 years with higher gold values. https://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-...

Looks like Great Depression, 1979/1980, and right after the Great Recession. What is the significance of 79/80?

Peak blood lead levels.

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> for the level of real inflation I'm not normally doing much business in gold, the value of gold compared to the dollar is nearly meaningless to me. I do often buy things like food and energy. To me the value of the dollar compared to a gallon of gas or a plate of food or a kWh of electricity is the "real" inflation. The value of gold isn't "real" to me or most consumers.

prices, of all goods, inflate exponentially the relative value of specific goods fluctuates within a small constant in the long run, the exponential dominates the linear ---- thus the price of gold is a yardstick of the exponential inflation of prices, irrespective of the relative fluctuations of gold vs food vs energy

In an economy, gold is just one more good. Sure, we could use it as an inflation index. Or we could use gasoline, or new cars, or eggs, or any of a million other things. Why should we use gold as opposed to all those other things?

Or, here's an idea, maybe we should use a weighted index of several of those things as a measure, in order to prevent misleading data from the fluctuations in the price of any one item?

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#64
post #8

The US real estate to gold ration has always facinated me: https://www.longtermtrends.net/real-estate-gold-ratio/ If you bought a house with gold in 1890 or 2023, the price would be... about the same.

So in terms of gold, real estate is currently kind of cheap?

Or gold is expensive.

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Zoom out a bunch on the gold price chart and you'll see it is volatile as well.

If you have to zoom out to see it though, it's by definition less volatile, surely?

Zoom out on bitcoin then and it looks less volatile too!

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> for the level of real inflation I'm not normally doing much business in gold, the value of gold compared to the dollar is nearly meaningless to me. I do often buy things like food and energy. To me the value of the dollar compared to a gallon of gas or a plate of food or a kWh of electricity is the "real" inflation. The value of gold isn't "real" to me or most consumers.

prices, of all goods, inflate exponentially the relative value of specific goods fluctuates within a small constant in the long run, the exponential dominates the linear ---- thus the price of gold is a yardstick of the exponential inflation of prices, irrespective of the relative fluctuations of gold vs food vs energy

That is just not true. Inflation is not an immutable law of nature. In fact, we should expect to see the prices of certain commodities go down as technological advances drive efficiency and productivity. And in fact many times in the past we have seen the price of food, for example, go down relative to other expenditures.

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#67
post #3
post #2

If you adjust for inflation, there have been 3 periods in the last 50 years with higher gold values. https://www.macrotrends.net/1333/historical-gold-prices-100-...

Looks like Great Depression, 1979/1980, and right after the Great Recession. What is the significance of 79/80?

~1980, ~2010, and ~2020 are the three times it was higher, inflation adjusted. The Great Depression era doesn't come close (and is also well outside of the 50 year window given).

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#68

How does this track with bitcoin prices, out of curiosity? (Full disclosure: I own neither!)

The price of gold priced in ₿, keeps falling. See also https://www.longtermtrends.net/bitcoin-vs-gold/

Thanks for the link I guess I was wondering if bitcoin vs USD and gold vs USD have similarities. I remember thinking they would, but then finding out that at least during certain periods, bitcoin was boosted by low interest rates, as people would borrow money to bet on bitcoin. That led bitcoin to drop when interest rates went up.

I'm curious if the correlation is generally positive (as people seek both when getting out of cash) or negative (for the reason described above).

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> for the level of real inflation I'm not normally doing much business in gold, the value of gold compared to the dollar is nearly meaningless to me. I do often buy things like food and energy. To me the value of the dollar compared to a gallon of gas or a plate of food or a kWh of electricity is the "real" inflation. The value of gold isn't "real" to me or most consumers.

prices, of all goods, inflate exponentially the relative value of specific goods fluctuates within a small constant in the long run, the exponential dominates the linear ---- thus the price of gold is a yardstick of the exponential inflation of prices, irrespective of the relative fluctuations of gold vs food vs energy

The three lines above the last don't do anything to say why you'd want to use the price of gold for that yardstick. And once again with it being so detached from the actual reality of most consumers it seems to be a pretty poor one. In fact, the ending of "irrespective of the relative fluctuations of gold vs food vs energy" kind of alludes to its value being radically detached from things people actually care about. If the fluctuations of USD / Gold are so detached from things people actually care about, it seems like it is a worthless yardstick.

And here's the real question. If the price of gas and the price of food stays the same but gold goes to $9,000/oz, did my life change? No, not really. If the other prices stay the same but gold goes to $20/oz, did my life change? No. If gas goes to $50/gal, did my life change? Radically. If (index of food) goes 10x higher, did my life change? Radically. Which is the "real" inflation again?

Re: Gold prices are hitting records

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

prices, of all goods, inflate exponentially the relative value of specific goods fluctuates within a small constant in the long run, the exponential dominates the linear ---- thus the price of gold is a yardstick of the exponential inflation of prices, irrespective of the relative fluctuations of gold vs food vs energy

In an economy, gold is just one more good. Sure, we could use it as an inflation index. Or we could use gasoline, or new cars, or eggs, or any of a million other things. Why should we use gold as opposed to all those other things? Or, here's an idea, maybe we should use a weighted index of several of those things as a measure, in order to prevent misleading data from the fluctuations in the price of any one item?

Hey, that idea sounds really great. We could create some normalized basket of goods consumers normally buy. Then we could chart that basket as some kind of index of consumer prices.

Nah. Who would do that. We can just look at the price of gold, that's all that really matters.

Post reply on HN