Live data from Hacker News

The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

i2-camera.polaroid.com

61–70 of 119 posts

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#61
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know but this is a huge amount of money for a niche product. I'm not sure they're equipped to run their business like Teenage Engineering or another niche thing targeting the very wealthy

They have a 'regular' one that's $120. Maybe this is the Teenage Engineering model.

The I-1, the model previous to this was designed by teenage engineering. They know what they’re doing.

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#62
post #31
post #7

I don't really get how this gets made. Instant cameras do not cost $500+

I was shocked to see the price tag on this. On the other hand, I could see it being used as mostly a marketing tool to provide an aspirational product to essentially set an anchor price that makes all their other lines feel more affordable. I honestly found that when I looked at their product line, all of a sudden, a $150 instant camera felt "affordable" after seeing the $600 one. I won't be buying one, but this had…

It’s an analogue camera with all the complexities involved in making something that exposes and results in a physical object and with relatively low production numbers and a high r&d spend required to make it. Why, coupled with a lack of anyone making anything else like this for Polaroid film would you think it would be dirt cheap?

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#63
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really hope that in my lifetime, and hopefully very soon, manual SLRs make a comeback. If not a come back then started manufacturing of the old greats again. I loved the photography but not the disposable digital photography. No, I was never an expert photographer and I don’t even want to be one. I just loved taking photos and the whole process of it and the fact that you couldn’t just take any number of photos you…

I don't think manual focus SLRs (If that's what you mean) are going anywhere now, there's widespread popularity for film photography and the "better" cameras (mechanical or reliable) are fetching silly money. And plenty of unreliable, hard-to-repair cameras are also fetching silly money. BUT - the value prop has totally changed. Running costs are very high, for processing and scanning or printing, and where digital h…

There’s people for whom “slow, and every shot is expensive” is a feature [1] but I agree – especially the loss of (color) film diversity has been hard to swallow and made everything considerably less fun. I still enjoy it, but I don’t know what I’ll do once my stash of deep frozen film runs out. With Fuji most probably having left the game, there won’t be competition for a cheap, basic color film – which IMHO is the thing that’s required to get more people into shooting film.

[1]: e.g. recently https://www.404media.co/how-and-why-to-get-into-film-photogr...

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#64

600€ for an obsolete-era machine that sells imperfection as a "feature" (probably because they don't have anything else to sell, as even their website's sample photos are mediocre quality) that many will probably use once or twice and get bored and jump back to their iPhone/DSLR/mirrorless anyway? No thanks.

I don't think you understand the selling point of these.

An ex of mine had a Polaroid, and had taken hundreds of pictures with friends and family, all cherished and passed to loved ones.

There's something special and somehow human about small, candid, imperfect photos that hits just right on memory lane and evokes nostalgia. It's more than just what it presents, it's about what it represents, and about the experience itself.

It stops being just a photo. Looking at it and going down memory lane is an experience in and of itself. You get to live that with your eyes, your fingers, your ears, and your nose even, and at the same time you can share them with others. At the same time you evoke the feelings and experiences from when you took it.

Every time you look at that picture you don't just remember what it depicts, you also experience every other time you experienced it.

That's just something no digital photo will ever be able to capture.

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#67
post #23

700 euros, oh my goodness! I would honestly expect it to be able to capture digital versions of the images too for that money.

Conversely, a digital camera that at a 700 Euro pricepoint also captures images on film? By the way, everybody have a digital instant camera in their pocket. It can also share them on the internet and send them to friends. It has unlimited poses and it can print to film if one really wants to. It can cost way more than 700 euros or less than 100.

Fuji Instax Evo Mini does that at about 200$.

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#68
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I really hope that in my lifetime, and hopefully very soon, manual SLRs make a comeback. If not a come back then started manufacturing of the old greats again. I loved the photography but not the disposable digital photography. No, I was never an expert photographer and I don’t even want to be one. I just loved taking photos and the whole process of it and the fact that you couldn’t just take any number of photos you…

I was an ardent manual film photography fan. Heck, I even bought a medium format camera. The hassle of developing film was too much even in the US. What won over digital is not just the freedom to click a million pictures, but the freedom to run your own darkroom on your PC/Mac. What I really need now is a compromise. I want the freedom of my own digital darkroom but I need a fully manual and digital camera with an i…

The Pixii digital rangefinder might be for you then (except for the poor battery life).

https://pixii.fr/

https://www.macfilos.com/2023/04/17/new-kid-on-the-block-the...

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#69

600€ for an obsolete-era machine that sells imperfection as a "feature" (probably because they don't have anything else to sell, as even their website's sample photos are mediocre quality) that many will probably use once or twice and get bored and jump back to their iPhone/DSLR/mirrorless anyway? No thanks.

I don't think you understand the selling point of these. An ex of mine had a Polaroid, and had taken hundreds of pictures with friends and family, all cherished and passed to loved ones. There's something special and somehow human about small, candid, imperfect photos that hits just right on memory lane and evokes nostalgia. It's more than just what it presents, it's about what it represents, and about the experience…

I do understand that there's a niche market for this. Though honestly, thinking all the R&D costs, that niche market (which gets even smaller with that price tag) can't offset those costs.

Re: The new Polaroid I-2 instant camera

#70

600€ for an obsolete-era machine that sells imperfection as a "feature" (probably because they don't have anything else to sell, as even their website's sample photos are mediocre quality) that many will probably use once or twice and get bored and jump back to their iPhone/DSLR/mirrorless anyway? No thanks.

It is showing €699.99 for me. But that is a bargain compared to when they first came out! https://legacybox.com/blogs/analog/how-much-was-the-first-po...

That would even be cheap for that era. But for today's age with all the alternatives and advanced devices, it's extremely expensive.
Post reply on HN