Live data from Hacker News

News Minimalist – Only significant news

newsminimalist.com

61–70 of 232 posts

Re: News Minimalist – Only significant news

#61
post #2

Very cool! > “Today ChatGPT read 1289 top news and gave 13 of them a significance score over 6/10.” Is an excellent hook. I wish there was more of a basis on the score it chose. For example: > “Russia suffers 100,000 casualties in Ukraine conflict, US estimates.” is #2 and ranked 6.8 > “White House estimates Russia has suffered 100,000 casualties in Ukraine since December.” is #237 and ranked 3.8.

Agreed on the point, but your example brings up a different problem for me. 100,000 dead Russians, is very likely the propaganda number. Maybes it’s right; maybe it’s not, IDK, but I know that there has been zero negative Ukraine news since the conflict started (ghost of Kiev anyone?), and the media machine definitely only works one way on this topic. I mean, Russia isn’t the good guy here, but I don’t excuse propaga…

The estimate is 100 000 casualities (20k dead and 80k wounded), and it seems to be correlated with several different intelligence sources.

The number is news because Russia is waging a large-scale invasion of another country using cannon fodder tactics. Reporting on that invasion is not simply propaganda.

Re: News Minimalist – Only significant news

#63

Very nice I have subscribed to test it out for a couple of weeks. I would love a simple mobile app, it's just easy to tap your news app on a phone, ideally with a way to customize the notification timing. I have certain moments each day when I want to consume this type of content (breakfast, lunch break) A small community driven comment section with Karma system would also be nice. I like to discuss news and it enabl…

Why not open it in the mobile browser? Or put a reference for the website on your home screen? You could use newsletterify.com (disclaimer: author here) to read them in the browser, not your inbox.

Re: News Minimalist – Only significant news

#65
I must remember to check this again on a day with some very significant news, because at the moment everything it's showing me is kinda below the bar of what I want to read.

It's a nice idea and looks like it's implemented well. My problem is probably that different things are significant to different people. Following that thread leads to filter bubbles, of course.

For big international (usually bad!) news I tend to go to Wikipedia Current Events: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events

Could News Minimalist have an option to only show good news with some significance? I think that might be popular and quite useful for the mental health of lots of people.

Good things do happen but they're under-reported because death, destruction and conflict draw more clicks & views. A way to surface the less depressing news would be welcome.

Re: News Minimalist – Only significant news

#67

Hey HN, author of the site here! Happy to answer any questions. (below is the project description I used when posted about it on Reddit) The problem I have with most news sites is that I can't read only important news: an article about a virus outbreak is followed by some celebrity gossip or another smartphone release. But even on sites that focus on important events articles are posted every day and there are always…

Great idea!

Personally, I want an even higher signal to noise ratio and even fewer articles. Perhaps significance > 7, and articles from the last week.

Re: News Minimalist – Only significant news

#69
post #52

Hey HN, author of the site here! Happy to answer any questions. (below is the project description I used when posted about it on Reddit) The problem I have with most news sites is that I can't read only important news: an article about a virus outbreak is followed by some celebrity gossip or another smartphone release. But even on sites that focus on important events articles are posted every day and there are always…

This is an awesome idea and I'm kicking myself for not thinking about it before. Very creative. Have you made any attempt at quantifying its biases? Both whether it considers left- or right-leaning articles more significant and where it focuses most of its reporting. (Economy and the US from a first glance?)

Thank you!

> Have you made any attempt at quantifying its biases?

I haven't. I can share ChatGPT's evaluation of sources credibility, maybe that will give people some insights. For example, Reuters got 9.5 (out of 10), Lifehacker 7, Oprah Mag 3.

> where it focuses most of its reporting. (Economy and the US from a first glance?)

I'd say today is just US and economy-heavy day. There were many days when other categories and geographies made the top (I especially enjoy these). One example: https://newsletter.newsminimalist.com/p/tuesday-april-25-3-m...

Re: News Minimalist – Only significant news

#70
This seems to be highly focused on global financial news, which are unsignificant to most people on this planet. It would be nice to be able to include or exclude certain news-categories to actually produce a list that has some significance to the reader.
Post reply on HN