Live data from Hacker News

An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

youtube.com

61–70 of 117 posts

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#61
post #3

Tl;Dw - Physics Girl, a popular science education YouTuber, is on an indefinite hiatus due to complications from long COVID resulting in chronic fatigue. The video has a lot more detail about the severity of her condition and her husband's efforts to care for her. Her friends are asking people to consider subscribing to her Patreon.

[flagged]

>Get your boosters people!

Heh. Was that a clever one or am I seeing things?

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#62
This is very sad to see and I wish Dianna and her family the very best for her recovery. I'm into year three of long COVID (ME/CFS) and was fortunate to not reach this level of severity, and to have improved slowly with time to mostly housebound rather than bedbound, but it is a remarkable disease.

The name does it little justice, and fatigue - while certainly pathological and disabling - is not the primary feature. The disease appears unique in terms of an abnormal response to exertion. This has been characterised via two-day cardiopulmonary exercise testing. Healthy controls and even those with other severely limiting diseases will show improvement on day 2, but ME/CFS uniquely shows a reduction on the second day.

Other key features are orthostatic intolerance with demonstration of reduction in cerebral blood flow in the majority on sitting/standing. Neurological symptoms including extreme sensitivity to light and sound explain her blindfold and ear protectors. Many have fluctuating cognitive slowing ("brain fog").

New insights into the metabolic derangements are being gained. Recently[1] evaluation of urine metabolomics demonstrated that healthy sedentary controls excrete many metabolites at 4 and 24 hours following an exercise challenge, while ME/CFS patients do not.

Apart from the devastating effects on patients and the economic impacts of losing so many from the workforce[2], I believe that understanding the immune and metabolic derangements underlying this condition will lead to major insights across many health domains.

[1] https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/24/4/3685 [2] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41579-022-00846-2

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

which is here: https://www.patreon.com/physicsgirl

She has almost 9000 patrons, and is an already successful Youtuber / e-celebrity. I'm sorry for what's happened to her, but I sincerely think charity is better directed elsewhere (for example, a local org that helps disadvantaged families receive healthcare/resources).

methinks you underestimate just how bad health care costs are in the US, especially for entrepreneurs who tend to not be able to afford good insurance. On top of that, where's the money coming for rent, power, food, etc? Her husband is a full time caretaker now so... he's not bringing in anything.

Yes, there's value in supporting the things you said, but ~9k patrons to support a creator who isn't creating, and her husband, and her medical costs and andandand... that's not actually very much, especially if she lives in a major city in the US where rent is frequently ridiculous.

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#64

[flagged]

Another possibility is that the ME/CFS diagnosis is correct, but it's unrelated to the covid-19 infection. I think the initial symptoms of ME/CFS are sometimes mild and ignored, and it's difficult to have a definite starting day and be sure it didn't star before the covid infection, or started after but is unrelated.

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

She has almost 9000 patrons, and is an already successful Youtuber / e-celebrity. I'm sorry for what's happened to her, but I sincerely think charity is better directed elsewhere (for example, a local org that helps disadvantaged families receive healthcare/resources).

methinks you underestimate just how bad health care costs are in the US, especially for entrepreneurs who tend to not be able to afford good insurance. On top of that, where's the money coming for rent, power, food, etc? Her husband is a full time caretaker now so... he's not bringing in anything. Yes, there's value in supporting the things you said, but ~9k patrons to support a creator who isn't creating, and her hu…

The minimum subscription is $3 per month. Even if all 9,000 are paying the minimum it's $27,000 per month.

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#66

Mason Earle is a professional rock climber who also deals with this condition (since before Covid) and was featured on Death, Sex, and Money: https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/deathsexmoney/episodes/...

How intensive rock climbing in terms of cardio load? It seems that cardio health was the biggest contributor to not getting serious Covid, seems surprising that an athlete would get this.

Very intensive with cardio. A big wall climb is probably 2-3k vertical feet or more of climbing. That's like climbing hundreds and hundreds of floors in a building (but even steeper and harder). Speed climbers can ascend something that high in a matter of hours. It's a big cardio and endurance demand.

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

She has almost 9000 patrons, and is an already successful Youtuber / e-celebrity. I'm sorry for what's happened to her, but I sincerely think charity is better directed elsewhere (for example, a local org that helps disadvantaged families receive healthcare/resources).

methinks you underestimate just how bad health care costs are in the US, especially for entrepreneurs who tend to not be able to afford good insurance. On top of that, where's the money coming for rent, power, food, etc? Her husband is a full time caretaker now so... he's not bringing in anything. Yes, there's value in supporting the things you said, but ~9k patrons to support a creator who isn't creating, and her hu…

I beg your pardon but the cheapest tier on her patreon is $3 a month. Please do not try to tell us that $325k a year minimum is not enough.

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

She has almost 9000 patrons, and is an already successful Youtuber / e-celebrity. I'm sorry for what's happened to her, but I sincerely think charity is better directed elsewhere (for example, a local org that helps disadvantaged families receive healthcare/resources).

methinks you underestimate just how bad health care costs are in the US, especially for entrepreneurs who tend to not be able to afford good insurance. On top of that, where's the money coming for rent, power, food, etc? Her husband is a full time caretaker now so... he's not bringing in anything. Yes, there's value in supporting the things you said, but ~9k patrons to support a creator who isn't creating, and her hu…

Graphtreon suggests she gained ~7,000 of those after this video was released. She only had 1,000 patrons last month: https://graphtreon.com/creator/physicsgirl

So yeah maybe 8,000 is enough now but maybe 1,000 was not :)

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

methinks you underestimate just how bad health care costs are in the US, especially for entrepreneurs who tend to not be able to afford good insurance. On top of that, where's the money coming for rent, power, food, etc? Her husband is a full time caretaker now so... he's not bringing in anything. Yes, there's value in supporting the things you said, but ~9k patrons to support a creator who isn't creating, and her hu…

I beg your pardon but the cheapest tier on her patreon is $3 a month. Please do not try to tell us that $325k a year minimum is not enough.

She doesnt' get 100% of that, she doesn't even get close. Several podcasts I listen to are killing their $2/$3 tiers as it doesn't make them any money. That's also assuming they continue the payment for the full year all 10k of them.

Re: An Update on Dianna's Health (Physics Girl) [video]

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

She has almost 9000 patrons, and is an already successful Youtuber / e-celebrity. I'm sorry for what's happened to her, but I sincerely think charity is better directed elsewhere (for example, a local org that helps disadvantaged families receive healthcare/resources).

methinks you underestimate just how bad health care costs are in the US, especially for entrepreneurs who tend to not be able to afford good insurance. On top of that, where's the money coming for rent, power, food, etc? Her husband is a full time caretaker now so... he's not bringing in anything. Yes, there's value in supporting the things you said, but ~9k patrons to support a creator who isn't creating, and her hu…

She also did not have more than 1000 patrons before the video push a few days ago. Which, particularly considering what must be substantial medical bills, is definitely not enough to sustain her family.
Post reply on HN