Live data from Hacker News

Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

linuxuprising.com

61–70 of 90 posts

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#61
post #42

I could understand Gnome as an ideological hack back when KDE wasn't completely open source or when Ubuntu pushed beautiful and polished versions of Gnome 2. And when KDE was on version 4. Today, why would anyone choose anything except KDE?

To me KDE is overloaded with settings and menus, it looks outdated and Gnome leans a lot more into multi-workspace/keyboard controls rather than the Windows-like behavior and I prefer that.

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

GTK != Gnome. KDE is extremely bloated and so that is why I avoid it. One KDE package wants to pull in pretty much all the dependencies for a full desktop environment which isn't what I want to do.

If you find yourself using the term bloated you should in most cases find a new word because it communications only imprecision. It neither uses excessive RAM, nor requires excessive storage, nor runs slowly. Do you mean it has too many features? In the context of the prior comment which was choosing between Gnome and KDE the fact that applications require you to have half of KDE is meaningless as you are if you pick…

[dead]

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#63

Gnome doesn't need any more KDE Connect clients. GSConnect is pretty much perfect and most importantly, is integrated into the Quick Settings. What I have always been puzzled by is the near absence of KDE Connect clients for tiling compositors. I would love to one day use KDE Connect in a way that feels native for something like Sway.

This is not a Gnome client. It is a gtk based client which doesn't require Gnome. It is also from the author of GSConnect.

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#64

Gnome doesn't need any more KDE Connect clients. GSConnect is pretty much perfect and most importantly, is integrated into the Quick Settings. What I have always been puzzled by is the near absence of KDE Connect clients for tiling compositors. I would love to one day use KDE Connect in a way that feels native for something like Sway.

This works on other desktops besides Gnome

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#65
post #2

Perfect! Works great for an alpha release. Few years ago i had kde and used kde connect, but i didn't want that much qt in my life (can't stand it), and switched to gnome. There was gsconnect but it wasn't that realiable. Used that for a while but in the end i switched to sway, becaus twms are great and everything is so much snappier. But one thing was missing, kdeconnect. I didn't want qt, and gsconnect was a gnome…

What's wrong with surrounding yourself with qt?

It's just an opinion, it's subjective:

For example the only qt application i use is wireshark, it looks to me like windows 7, hijacks my input several times when i want to type somewhere else, hovering over menu items at the top is always off for me,...

And GTK seems to work better for me with tiling window managers, as popups are by default not windows (idk what they are), this way if I click on something and a popup or dialog comes up, it stays as a popup or dialog and doesn't take up half of my screen and splits my screen.

GTK isn't perfect, but at least it looks good and is more pleasent to use for me.

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#66
post #46
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Without context this is just noise. Also when you say: don't trust Telegram, while not saying anything about WhatsApp, you are, on average, pushing people from a solution that isn't proven to be trustworthy to a solution that is proven to be untrustworthy . Because unless you simultaneously point out that WhatsApp is worse, that is where people will go if they listen to you and avoid Telegram.

Telegram is not e2ee.

Telegram has a Secret Chat. It's on the 3 dots menu in the screen for a contact. Secret chats are available only on one device, they don't sync to the other devices of the user.

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#68
post #25

KDE Connect is the one "linux" tool where after showing to my partner what it can do she asked me if I could install on her Windows laptop, her tablet, and her phone. It's been extremely practical when exchanging PDFs of (say) traintickets, remote controlling the volume of whichever laptop we connected to the projector for movie night (which was the "tech demo" that convinced her), and so on.

Indeed, kudos to the devs for maintaining a Windows version too!

I checked recently to see if there was a version of it for MacOS for my work laptop, and they apparently do have one in development, but right now it's only available through nightly builds. The commitment to cross platform support for this really is impressive!

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#69
post #63

Gnome doesn't need any more KDE Connect clients. GSConnect is pretty much perfect and most importantly, is integrated into the Quick Settings. What I have always been puzzled by is the near absence of KDE Connect clients for tiling compositors. I would love to one day use KDE Connect in a way that feels native for something like Sway.

This is not a Gnome client. It is a gtk based client which doesn't require Gnome. It is also from the author of GSConnect.

GTK may be a universal GUI tool kit but the description "Gnome Tool Kit" is more appropriate.

Re: Valent Is a KDE Connect Client for GTK-Based Desktops

#70
post #64

Gnome doesn't need any more KDE Connect clients. GSConnect is pretty much perfect and most importantly, is integrated into the Quick Settings. What I have always been puzzled by is the near absence of KDE Connect clients for tiling compositors. I would love to one day use KDE Connect in a way that feels native for something like Sway.

This works on other desktops besides Gnome

Pretty sure it works on Gnome as well. One would say that's the main target.
Post reply on HN