Live data from Hacker News

A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

qmul.ac.uk

61–70 of 92 posts

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#61
post #58

I really hope that stuff like “the commonest” doesn’t become one of the most common mistakes in HN headlines…

I'm confused, do you have issue with the word "commonest"? The American Heritage dictionary gives the positive, comparative, and superlative forms as common, commoner, and commonest. What's the mistake?

I can only bring German school-level English to the table, but my instincts told me that someone played loose with what should be “the most common”.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#62
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And what happened? Did your blood pressure return to normal? Did the years of medication have any permanent side effects?

I still take one BP medication - 40mg of Lisinopril. My blood pressure numbers are much more "normal" - usually around 135/85. I seem to be caffeine sensitive in general. On days where I drink caffeine, my BP is ~15 points higher on the systolic side. It lasts the entire day. I may be a slow metabolizer. I've had a ton of anxiety over the years that seems to have vanished with the adrenalectomy. I was always on edge…

My ex also had a cyst on her kidney, influencing hormones and anxiety.

Kudos on your quest. Let's hope medical field improves diagnosing.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#63
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm confused, do you have issue with the word "commonest"? The American Heritage dictionary gives the positive, comparative, and superlative forms as common, commoner, and commonest. What's the mistake?

I can only bring German school-level English to the table, but my instincts told me that someone played loose with what should be “the most common”.

Your instincts are incorrect, "commonest" is a valid word and it's being used correctly in the title of this article.

I hope this mistake of correcting things that aren't mistakes doesn't become one of the most common mistakes in HN comments...

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#64
post #51
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I still take one BP medication - 40mg of Lisinopril. My blood pressure numbers are much more "normal" - usually around 135/85. I seem to be caffeine sensitive in general. On days where I drink caffeine, my BP is ~15 points higher on the systolic side. It lasts the entire day. I may be a slow metabolizer. I've had a ton of anxiety over the years that seems to have vanished with the adrenalectomy. I was always on edge…

Yes, lots of palpitations. To the point where I wore a monitor for a few days so that my cardiologist could evaluate. With hyperaldosteronism, because your body retains elevated levels of sodium, it dumps potassium. The low potassiums is probably the main cause of the palpitations. Low potassium is a marker for hyperaldosteronism.

That's interesting. I have figured that out on my own and self medicate by eating a lot of bananas which has helped a ton. I also found taking magnesium also helped. I should really check for hyperaldosteronism which I have always suspected but like you was always steered towards bp medication and got eye rolls if I tried to engage in a educated conversation about the topic.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#65
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And what happened? Did your blood pressure return to normal? Did the years of medication have any permanent side effects?

I still take one BP medication - 40mg of Lisinopril. My blood pressure numbers are much more "normal" - usually around 135/85. I seem to be caffeine sensitive in general. On days where I drink caffeine, my BP is ~15 points higher on the systolic side. It lasts the entire day. I may be a slow metabolizer. I've had a ton of anxiety over the years that seems to have vanished with the adrenalectomy. I was always on edge…

Have they put you on any low dose anxiolytics like valium?

Is the caffeine effect reproducible with tea or just coffee/energy drinks?

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#66
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm confused, do you have issue with the word "commonest"? The American Heritage dictionary gives the positive, comparative, and superlative forms as common, commoner, and commonest. What's the mistake?

I can only bring German school-level English to the table, but my instincts told me that someone played loose with what should be “the most common”.

Even if commonest is a valid word I agree that 'the most common' would read better. English is my first language.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#67
post #3

Can someone who knows more about the field to comment on whether this is as revolutionary as it sounds?

- this only concerns 5 - 10% of all hypertension patients - ~50% of adult Americans have hypertension - scanning all medication-non-responders (= people suffering from "resistant hypertension") and operating on all of them to remove the causative nodules sounds like quite the tall order - doctors won't just suddenly start sending all the resistant hypertension patients to CTs to diagnose this cause, instead they will…

That sounds terrible. Are you advocating for that or just saying that is just what will happen.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#68
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can only bring German school-level English to the table, but my instincts told me that someone played loose with what should be “the most common”.

Your instincts are incorrect, "commonest" is a valid word and it's being used correctly in the title of this article. I hope this mistake of correcting things that aren't mistakes doesn't become one of the most common mistakes in HN comments...

I don’t understand your need to be rude after learning that someone is not a native speaker.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#69
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can only bring German school-level English to the table, but my instincts told me that someone played loose with what should be “the most common”.

Your instincts are incorrect, "commonest" is a valid word and it's being used correctly in the title of this article. I hope this mistake of correcting things that aren't mistakes doesn't become one of the most common mistakes in HN comments...

“Commonest mistakes” - ftfy

I concur with GP. IME, “most common” or “most fun” is generally looked upon as better form than “commonest”, or “funnest”. The latter catches the eye and not in a good way, having as it does the ring of childishness to it. Legal, sure. Proper? Nope.

Re: A new scan to detect and cure the commonest cause of high blood pressure

#70
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your instincts are incorrect, "commonest" is a valid word and it's being used correctly in the title of this article. I hope this mistake of correcting things that aren't mistakes doesn't become one of the most common mistakes in HN comments...

I don’t understand your need to be rude after learning that someone is not a native speaker.

If you aren't a native speaker why did you try to correct the writer of the article?

You're allowed to be rude but I am not? I don't want this to be a flame war, I want you to actually reflect on why you think you're allowed to be rude but I am not.

Post reply on HN