Live data from Hacker News

I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

businessinsider.com

61–70 of 107 posts

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#61
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s not “very clear” to this outsider that Twitter was bloated, not that the firings adhere to any particular “debloating” rationale. Edit: The approach Musk has taken to layoffs also does not evoke maturity.

Quoted post unavailable.

No post body was provided.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, but he is impulsive, careless, fraudulent and, when it comes to software, incompetent.

I find analysis of this type petty and stupid. It’s like arguing Doyle Brunson was just really lucky. How much success, across multiple decades in so many different fields of business and technology, must someone acquire before meeting your standards? I feel like I’m reading comments on Slashdot about Bill Gates in 1999. But in comparison, Elon Musk is wildly more successful than 1999 Bill Gates.

Agreed. Impulsive, careless, fraudulent? Sure that's fine to have opinions and thoughts on, he's a public figure and we have a right to gossip and all. But incompetent? I feel like you need a bit more factual meat to something like that. That's a stretch. You can fail upwards in a lot of crowded fields, especially software startups, but Tesla, SpaceX, Starlink? Give the man some credit.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#63
post #13

This article reads like an abused partner defending their abuser. This kind of double-sidedness is extremely common in abusive relationships, in large part because it's a really effective method of exerting control over someone while encouraging them to blame themselves for being abused. > If there are employees not aligned with that vision, he will chew them out and he will do it in a vicious way, which is his right…

We're all adults, don't like his style, don't work for him. It's that simple. Obviously enough people don't think his style is harsh or vicious, as described in the article, otherwise his numerous companies wouldn't have a line out the door of prospective employees. My take on the article was Musk drives you like a good highschool sports coach. Demanding, hard, unforgiving... and you either live up to the high expect…

> Which actually sounds wonderful... working with an entire organization that is aligned in thought and motivations, and everyone bringing their 'A' game. Compare that to your current job...

Join a cult?

> Not to mention the guy in the article only worked with Musk for less than 1 year, over 20 years ago.

He's likely much worse now. A person's nature doesn't change so much over the years but the experiences they have influences how those traits come out. What happens when someone like this has acquired wealth and success, has been surrounded by sycophants, and repeatedly gets away with shit behavior. Who's really going to stop a 'bad Elon' day for him? As we saw on the Twitter thing, nobody can stop a 'good Elon' idea that he maybe shouldn't have done either.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That just feels like a cheap way to live. Maybe it's prudent, but I feel like I couldn't live with myself.

Read Sun Tzu, live like a great general, pick your battles wisely, and make the cost worth the gain. You will make more of a difference and live a life of more power than 'trying to not live a cheap way'.

It probably makes sense not to work for someone who can destroy your life and is inclined to do so on a whim. The calculus in dealing with those people is apparently different than just about anyone else you'll encounter in life.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very horrible vs. extremely horrible. Spot the difference.

If I were younger, I’d work for either of them. I’m not fragile.

> I’d work for either of them.

Why? You could work in a less toxic environment and just buy their stock if you believe in the mission.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#66
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This. We're talking about a guy who publicly falsely accused a guy he was jealous of of being a pedo without evidence. Just imagine what he would do if he could get away with it without backlash I wouldn't want to gez on his bad side because I think he has the power and pettiness to ruin my life

You can grovel in front of an abuser, giving up all human dignity, if you want. In the end, he is just a man, and evil one at that.

Leaving is not groveling.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#67
Sounds like Bill Gates. He yelled and bullied people to get what he wanted (and he has admitted it). Steve Jobs was also part of this club, more or less.

There is no denying this type of uncivilized abusive leadership works sometimes. It drives off people not suited to it, but results speak for themselves.

Complete opposite approaches work also. I think it's tied to leaders personality. Asshole can't succeed with nice guy strategy, nice guy can't succeed with asshole strategy.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#68
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We're all adults, don't like his style, don't work for him. It's that simple. Obviously enough people don't think his style is harsh or vicious, as described in the article, otherwise his numerous companies wouldn't have a line out the door of prospective employees. My take on the article was Musk drives you like a good highschool sports coach. Demanding, hard, unforgiving... and you either live up to the high expect…

The difference is your sports coach knows what good looks like. Musk is a bloviating idiot demanding on-paper code review.

The guy literally earned hundreds of millions of dollars by writing code. I think that qualifies him to do code reviews however he wants... no?

My code has earned me zero millions so far...

> The difference is your sports coach knows what good looks like

How can we honestly say Musk doesn't? Has his numerous successes not demonstrated he clearly knows what he's doing? All of his thousands and thousands of employees are just... hostages I guess?

I get it's fashionable to hate on Musk right now - and if you review my comment record you will see very few have been more bearish on Musk since the very beginning, but this latest round of criticisms are really just not reality.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#69

The vision of space occupation has always come across to me as really stupid. From many scientific points of view it is infeasible, and many philosophical perspectives on top of that. I get the idea of making your vision come true and treating every obstacle as a technicality, but not all problems work that way. Especially not ones that go really far against biology.

> really stupid. From many scientific points of view it is infeasible, and many philosophical perspectives on top of that.

That might be true. But let’s think about it from a larger perspective. Let’s just assume that, however unlikely, we managed to survive next 800 million years on this planet. Once our Sun starts dying, we gotta get out of here anyway. For sure, the only end game for us must be to become an interplanetary species.

Re: I worked for Elon Musk in the early days of SpaceX

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The guy has money and acolytes in high places. Quit if you want, but dont make an enemy of someone who can blacklist you. Just leave. Dont make a scene.

This. We're talking about a guy who publicly falsely accused a guy he was jealous of of being a pedo without evidence. Just imagine what he would do if he could get away with it without backlash I wouldn't want to gez on his bad side because I think he has the power and pettiness to ruin my life

And now he controls twitter. I doubt he will self-censor. Such allegations may well live on in search results for many years.
Post reply on HN