Live data from Hacker News

I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

torrentfreak.com

61–70 of 90 posts

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#61
post #58
post #15

I am surprised about the high quality taste other people have who share this VPN. Csikszentmihalyi, Ebook Libraries, Stephen Merchant - proud of my fellow anonymists.

proud of my fellow anonymists Except, of course, that they didn't pay the authors for any of that high-quality content you like so much.

You can't actually know that.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#62
post #50
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> They could sell this information to MPAA and RIAA for gold. Maybe in the US, but in many other countries they would be breaking several privacy laws. In fact, even the collecting the initial minimal information (IP's + downloads) already breaks privacy laws in most of Europe. Commercially, this information has no value.

The lack of seriousness on the site greatly compromises the value of the data. As a captcha they they ask you enter the entire text of the USA Constitution, and give a mailing address in Antarctica. There is no evidence that large portions of the data isn't made up, no sane company would want to touch this. The agreement above sound more like an attempt to prevent people from contacting them in the first place (proba…

> The lack of seriousness on the site greatly compromises the value of the data.

I think that's the point. They want to make a point about privacy, but they don't want anyone to take the specific data seriously.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#65
post #64
post #25

i hope this doesn't prompt more people to start using bittorrent through tor.

why?

It is widely considered to be an abuse of tor. The system wasn't built for that from a technical perspective, and from a social perspective, you are degrading the quality of the service for the people who actually need it.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#66
post #53

The only thing it has for me is something called "Worms.Crazy.Golf" - something I have never downloaded. I also have a static IP. This site seems completely bogus.

apparently some trackers have fake peers that might use your IP address. regardless of if that is or isn't the case, it lends you some deniability.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#67
post #61
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

proud of my fellow anonymists Except, of course, that they didn't pay the authors for any of that high-quality content you like so much.

You can't actually know that.

I would, however, bet a beer.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#68
post #64
post #25

i hope this doesn't prompt more people to start using bittorrent through tor.

why?

because it makes it so difficult to provide exit nodes in the US for people that actually need them. DMCA complaints will quickly take down an exit node because of tor users sending bittorrent traffic out of it.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#69
post #6

I don't use BitTorrent very often (because I have incoming connections for that torrent in my router's state table for years after I do so), but there were a few things I wanted to download today so I just spun up an EC2 instance, installed Transmission, and did it from there. A 38GiB Blu-Ray image took about two hours. The next time I want to do this, I'll have a completely new IP address. Is this a terrible idea?

It depends. Do you ever want to be able to rely on Amazon Web Services as a piece of your business infrastructure at any point in the rest of your life? You're putting that in jeopardy by using EC2 for illegal purposes; Amazon could well ban you from the service if a copyright holder outs you. Amazon has no reason to be lenient here, especially given how ICE (DHS) has been handling copyright infringement... That's a…

It depends. Do you ever want to be able to rely on Amazon Web Services as a piece of your business infrastructure at any point in the rest of your life? You're putting that in jeopardy by using EC2 for illegal purposes; Amazon could well ban you from the service if a copyright holder outs you.

Presumably my business would use an account under the business name.

Re: I Know What You Downloaded on BitTorrent…

#70
post #68
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

why?

because it makes it so difficult to provide exit nodes in the US for people that actually need them. DMCA complaints will quickly take down an exit node because of tor users sending bittorrent traffic out of it.

Just like DMCA complaints have shut down other internet service providers, like Comcast? Ultimately, in the US, ISPs are not responsible for their users' activity. "Common carrier" and all that. When you open an exit node, you become an ISP.
Post reply on HN