Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

github.com

61–70 of 153 posts

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#61
post #10

My mind is blown by the people saying $10/month is too much. $10 a month for this is an unbelievably good deal! If you value your time, this is a ridiculously good deal.

Eh. I might use it if my employer obtained it for me, but I'm not gonna go out of my way to pay $10 to Microsoft for it.

I'm also still skeptical about the legal aspects of it. Microsoft says that training the model is fair use. Good for them, but that's not applicable to me in any way.

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#62
post #19

I've found copilot invaluable for throwing together quick scripts, especially in languages I don't quite understand. Writing e.g. a bash script, and being able to add a comment saying # Print an error message in red and exit if this program returns an error and have it print out if ! some_program then echo -e "\e[31msome_program failed\e[0m" exit 1 fi makes it so much quicker to cobble together something that works w…

Maybe they can replace you with copilot and an unexperienced cheaper user.

Honestly, that’s the hope. Putting together well-solved combinations of computer functionality ought to become less-skilled work as technology progresses.

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#63

I've found copilot invaluable for throwing together quick scripts, especially in languages I don't quite understand. Writing e.g. a bash script, and being able to add a comment saying # Print an error message in red and exit if this program returns an error and have it print out if ! some_program then echo -e "\e[31msome_program failed\e[0m" exit 1 fi makes it so much quicker to cobble together something that works w…

Weird that it prints the error to stdout. I mean not that surprising really, I'd just expect error->stderr to be a pretty low-hanging association

I've seen many many scripts that ignore STDERR and just print everything normally.

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#64
post #8

This is not good news. It's actually changed from being free to costing $10/month. The productivity benefits are worth more than $10/month easily, but somehow I still don't want to pay for it... maybe it's because they're using public domain code to train the model.

because you thinking is free, you paying to have it think is not free. If saving time saved YOU money, then it would be worth it

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#66
post #8

This is not good news. It's actually changed from being free to costing $10/month. The productivity benefits are worth more than $10/month easily, but somehow I still don't want to pay for it... maybe it's because they're using public domain code to train the model.

Nitpick - they're not (just) using public domain code for training - they're using "publicly available sources, including code in public repositories on GitHub."[0]

This includes a lot of code under copyleft licenses, and possibly even more code under no license at all (implicitly All Rights Reserved). It's not obvious to me that it's ethical (or possibly even legal) to sell a model derived from code not in the public domain.

[0]: https://github.com/features/copilot

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#67
post #10

My mind is blown by the people saying $10/month is too much. $10 a month for this is an unbelievably good deal! If you value your time, this is a ridiculously good deal.

The value from copilot seems to be very dependant on exactly what you are coding, in which language and what libraries/frameworks you are using. I've been using it on and off for about a year and on the whole consider it at best a net neutral in terms of value. For every 10 times it saves me 2-3 minutes typing out some boiler plate it costs me 20-30 minutes to sort out some weird bug or subtle gibberish it has introduced in my codebase. Half the time the suggestions are just obviously wrong.

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#68

Have been using Copilot in the beta and it's just been amazing. I can't remember how many times my jaw has literally dropped as it knows what I'm trying to do, or yelled "Holy sh*t!" as it feels like it's reading my mind. That said, was highly disappointed with the switch to non-free. Maybe they never did say it would remain free, but they certainly didn't advertise it wouldn't be later. I feel bait-and-switched. Yes…

Not really, $10 is reasonable even if you’re a hobbyist who never expects to generate any revenue.

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#70
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's on github.

Someone else running copilot in a different workspace wouldn’t see those recommendations, you can try it yourself in a new workspace.

This isn't the first time it's done this. If I recall it regurgitated the doom source, along with the swearing.
Post reply on HN