Live data from Hacker News

Stanford prof calls police after whistleblower exposes $5000/hour gov. contacts

twitter.com

61–65 of 65 posts

Re: Stanford prof calls police after whistleblower exposes $5000/hour gov. contacts

#61
post #29
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not that they published a paper without any Black co-authors. There has been a controversial push in California to reform public school math education guidelines called the California Math Framework [1]. It [2] frames current math education in California as failing minority students and gives suggestions for how to remedy it. The issue has been controversial as some see it as injecting social justice topics into…

> academic researchers studying pedagogy and had little to no input from actual teachers. This makes sense but doesn’t square with the lack of black authors. Would black academic researchers studying pegagogy be better than actual teachers? It seems the issue is lack of teachers participating in the design and testing of the framework than the race of the authors. Is there a evidence or accusation of discrimination i…

> This makes sense but doesn’t square with the lack of black authors. Would black academic researchers studying pegagogy be better than actual teachers?

It helps to have people who understand education and who understand (often from personal experience) the very phenomena one claims to be addressing.

> Is there a evidence or accusation of discrimination in the selection of the authors?

There is no accusation, merely an observation which was enough to attract the ire of the Stanford prof.

Re: Stanford prof calls police after whistleblower exposes $5000/hour gov. contacts

#62
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>but it does seem untoward that the main author of the California math framework is also making $5000/hour when the client is not a tech company but a public school district with mostly minority and economically disadvantaged students It seems lazy to dismiss that person just because he charges a high rate. If his services are effective and there's no better alternatives, who cares how much it costs? People getting o…

Jelani Nelson himself is probably a better alternative and does much of his work for free.

Because there are people who volunteer for habitat4humanity doesn't give me a good reason to be indignant when my builder asks me to pay her for her work.

Re: Stanford prof calls police after whistleblower exposes $5000/hour gov. contacts

#63
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The stated reason was doxxing.

He didn't doxx her before the threat was made. Doxxing means revealing private personal information, but the contract (paid with government funds) that he shared is public record and thus not private by definition. He may have doxxed her by revealing her email address but that happened after the threat.

That's not really correct. Generally someone's address is considered public information and yet sharing it on a site like Twitter is still considered doxxing. In fact, most doxxing happens using publicly available data.

Re: Stanford prof calls police after whistleblower exposes $5000/hour gov. contacts

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think it's as simple as that. I'm not a lawyer, but I think one could certainly be accused of inciting violence by telling the truth creatively, to the right audience, under the right circumstances (like Trump's tweets during Jan 6).

Yes, you are very clearly not a lawyer.

Do you have more information to share?

Re: Stanford prof calls police after whistleblower exposes $5000/hour gov. contacts

#65

Super misleading title, I definitely thought reading it that she called 911 and the "whistleblower" had an actual confrontation with the cops. Instead she mentioned in an email she was seeking legal counsel after being subjected to what she felt was harassment, and that involved talking to the police. Not entirely sure about the details but this dude is extremely suspect. Every single tweet he tries to paint himself…

> this dude is extremely suspect "This dude" is both a prominent educator and prominent researcher of algorithms. If you actually look at his twitter history, this sort of tweet [0] is much more common than any trying to "paint himself as a victim." I'm sorry, but if someone siccs lawyers and/or the police on you for a tweet you make criticizing them, you are a victim and it beyond reasonable to be upset about it. Th…

You are projecting far too much.
Post reply on HN